Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2024, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (2): 185-197.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2023161
Yong-liang ZHANG(), Ze TENG, Feng HAO, Tie-feng YU, Yu-xia ZHANG
Received:
2023-05-17
Revised:
2023-07-07
Online:
2024-02-20
Published:
2023-12-12
Contact:
Yong-liang ZHANG
Yong-liang ZHANG, Ze TENG, Feng HAO, Tie-feng YU, Yu-xia ZHANG. Effects of different mixed sowing patterns and sowing ratios of alfalfa on grassland productivity and community stability in grass-legume mixtures[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(2): 185-197.
茬次 Cutting time | 种类 Species | 牧草产量F值 Forage yield F value | 相对产量F值 Relative yield F value | 相对密度F值 Relative density F value | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | ||
1茬 First cropping | 禾草Grass | 0.87 | 3.45** | 4.63** | 1.15 | 3.20** | 4.40** | 0.92 | 0.88 | 0.64 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 2.78 | 11.09** | 3.07* | 3.64 | 21.50** | 2.87* | 2.06 | 18.36** | 1.44 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 0.27 | 2.98* | 3.68** | |||||||
2茬 Second cropping | 禾草Grass | 2.10 | 4.63** | 3.34** | 2.33 | 4.36** | 3.16* | 4.97* | 3.27** | 1.67 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 2.28 | 5.16** | 0.18 | 0.82 | 42.00** | 0.31 | 0.11 | 10.06** | 0.17 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 6.07* | 1.37 | 1.36 | |||||||
3茬 Third cropping | 禾草Grass | 20.91** | 6.97** | 4.23** | 21.21** | 6.70** | 3.60** | 5.08* | 6.52** | 2.27 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 9.44** | 7.42** | 1.67 | 1.52 | 15.72** | 0.14 | 0.01 | 37.64** | 0.52 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 3.80 | 5.30* | 2.13 | |||||||
全年 Annual | 禾草Grass | 0.48 | 4.35** | 3.29** | 0.49 | 4.13** | 3.21* | |||
苜蓿Alfalfa | 7.30** | 13.44** | 0.83 | 4.90* | 51.91** | 0.39 | ||||
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 3.97 | 4.26** | 1.43 |
Table 1 Analysis of variance on the effects of mixed sowing patterns and ratios on forage yield, relative yield and relative density
茬次 Cutting time | 种类 Species | 牧草产量F值 Forage yield F value | 相对产量F值 Relative yield F value | 相对密度F值 Relative density F value | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | A因素 A factor | B因素 B factor | A×B | ||
1茬 First cropping | 禾草Grass | 0.87 | 3.45** | 4.63** | 1.15 | 3.20** | 4.40** | 0.92 | 0.88 | 0.64 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 2.78 | 11.09** | 3.07* | 3.64 | 21.50** | 2.87* | 2.06 | 18.36** | 1.44 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 0.27 | 2.98* | 3.68** | |||||||
2茬 Second cropping | 禾草Grass | 2.10 | 4.63** | 3.34** | 2.33 | 4.36** | 3.16* | 4.97* | 3.27** | 1.67 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 2.28 | 5.16** | 0.18 | 0.82 | 42.00** | 0.31 | 0.11 | 10.06** | 0.17 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 6.07* | 1.37 | 1.36 | |||||||
3茬 Third cropping | 禾草Grass | 20.91** | 6.97** | 4.23** | 21.21** | 6.70** | 3.60** | 5.08* | 6.52** | 2.27 |
苜蓿Alfalfa | 9.44** | 7.42** | 1.67 | 1.52 | 15.72** | 0.14 | 0.01 | 37.64** | 0.52 | |
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 3.80 | 5.30* | 2.13 | |||||||
全年 Annual | 禾草Grass | 0.48 | 4.35** | 3.29** | 0.49 | 4.13** | 3.21* | |||
苜蓿Alfalfa | 7.30** | 13.44** | 0.83 | 4.90* | 51.91** | 0.39 | ||||
禾豆Grass+alfalfa | 3.97 | 4.26** | 1.43 |
种类 Species | 处理 Treatment | 产量 Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||
无芒雀麦 Smooth bromegrass | B1 | 4816.77±1185.83a | 1988.84±468.56a | 406.00±179.08ab | 7211.61±138.14a |
B2 | 3966.46±761.18b | 1612.47±572.29abc | 216.58±89.37cd | 5795.52±945.40b | |
B3 | 3621.13±817.78bc | 2079.77±636.47a | 264.81±109.93cd | 5965.72±634.86b | |
B4 | 3817.93±618.64bc | 1691.05±338.74ab | 452.60±128.99a | 5961.58±1010.84b | |
B5 | 4004.94±529.70b | 1335.34±346.38bc | 205.06±33.81d | 5545.34±82.20bc | |
B6 | 3846.28±991.11bc | 1471.85±310.29bc | 326.99±172.55bc | 5645.13±329.85bc | |
B7 | 3589.09±927.77bc | 1269.78±424.86bc | 294.11±151.35cd | 5152.98±336.96cd | |
B8 | 3094.88±261.28c | 1178.92±309.43c | 192.25±62.94d | 4466.06±185.96d | |
苜蓿 Alfalfa | B1 | 1334.06±481.08e | 1543.00±296.51c | 1143.01±250.38d | 4020.07±779.83d |
B2 | 2359.55±404.19cd | 1480.16±213.34c | 1653.64±253.67c | 5493.35±159.12c | |
B3 | 1873.11±534.71de | 1561.05±494.32c | 1554.91±231.18cd | 4989.06±942.49cd | |
B4 | 2148.85±326.89d | 1735.18±395.37c | 1782.55±523.11c | 5666.57±462.73c | |
B5 | 2955.84±575.15bc | 2029.72±275.38bc | 2302.56±518.39ab | 7288.12±842.62b | |
B6 | 3209.03±1203.45b | 2049.06±655.70bc | 1876.19±387.85bc | 7134.28±1741.12b | |
B7 | 2884.04±676.71bc | 2523.44±372.02ab | 2312.26±257.66ab | 7719.75±994.73b | |
B8 | 3942.65±990.20a | 2720.61±718.57a | 2471.20±862.57a | 9134.47±2069.99a | |
禾豆 Grass+alfalfa | B1 | 6150.83±1442.27abc | 3531.84±359.49ab | 1549.01±275.92d | 11231.68±1559.42d |
B2 | 6326.01±958.48abc | 3092.63±650.42b | 1870.22±330.92cd | 11288.87±1058.77cd | |
B3 | 5494.24±845.56c | 3640.81±696.74ab | 1819.72±190.20cd | 10954.78±1096.06d | |
B4 | 5966.78±687.73bc | 3426.22±356.70ab | 2235.14±644.93abc | 11628.45±729.21c | |
B5 | 6960.77±542.07ab | 3365.06±441.02ab | 2507.63±500.17ab | 12833.46±1127.34ab | |
B6 | 7055.31±1026.23a | 3520.91±578.46ab | 2203.18±436.14bc | 12779.40±1231.60bc | |
B7 | 6473.13±559.26abc | 3793.22±636.90ab | 2606.37±401.68ab | 12872.72±1013.68ab | |
B8 | 7037.53±1152.35a | 3899.53±666.52a | 2830.13±861.80a | 13767.19±1967.91a |
Table 2 Forage yield under different mixture ratios of alfalfa (kg·hm-2)
种类 Species | 处理 Treatment | 产量 Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||
无芒雀麦 Smooth bromegrass | B1 | 4816.77±1185.83a | 1988.84±468.56a | 406.00±179.08ab | 7211.61±138.14a |
B2 | 3966.46±761.18b | 1612.47±572.29abc | 216.58±89.37cd | 5795.52±945.40b | |
B3 | 3621.13±817.78bc | 2079.77±636.47a | 264.81±109.93cd | 5965.72±634.86b | |
B4 | 3817.93±618.64bc | 1691.05±338.74ab | 452.60±128.99a | 5961.58±1010.84b | |
B5 | 4004.94±529.70b | 1335.34±346.38bc | 205.06±33.81d | 5545.34±82.20bc | |
B6 | 3846.28±991.11bc | 1471.85±310.29bc | 326.99±172.55bc | 5645.13±329.85bc | |
B7 | 3589.09±927.77bc | 1269.78±424.86bc | 294.11±151.35cd | 5152.98±336.96cd | |
B8 | 3094.88±261.28c | 1178.92±309.43c | 192.25±62.94d | 4466.06±185.96d | |
苜蓿 Alfalfa | B1 | 1334.06±481.08e | 1543.00±296.51c | 1143.01±250.38d | 4020.07±779.83d |
B2 | 2359.55±404.19cd | 1480.16±213.34c | 1653.64±253.67c | 5493.35±159.12c | |
B3 | 1873.11±534.71de | 1561.05±494.32c | 1554.91±231.18cd | 4989.06±942.49cd | |
B4 | 2148.85±326.89d | 1735.18±395.37c | 1782.55±523.11c | 5666.57±462.73c | |
B5 | 2955.84±575.15bc | 2029.72±275.38bc | 2302.56±518.39ab | 7288.12±842.62b | |
B6 | 3209.03±1203.45b | 2049.06±655.70bc | 1876.19±387.85bc | 7134.28±1741.12b | |
B7 | 2884.04±676.71bc | 2523.44±372.02ab | 2312.26±257.66ab | 7719.75±994.73b | |
B8 | 3942.65±990.20a | 2720.61±718.57a | 2471.20±862.57a | 9134.47±2069.99a | |
禾豆 Grass+alfalfa | B1 | 6150.83±1442.27abc | 3531.84±359.49ab | 1549.01±275.92d | 11231.68±1559.42d |
B2 | 6326.01±958.48abc | 3092.63±650.42b | 1870.22±330.92cd | 11288.87±1058.77cd | |
B3 | 5494.24±845.56c | 3640.81±696.74ab | 1819.72±190.20cd | 10954.78±1096.06d | |
B4 | 5966.78±687.73bc | 3426.22±356.70ab | 2235.14±644.93abc | 11628.45±729.21c | |
B5 | 6960.77±542.07ab | 3365.06±441.02ab | 2507.63±500.17ab | 12833.46±1127.34ab | |
B6 | 7055.31±1026.23a | 3520.91±578.46ab | 2203.18±436.14bc | 12779.40±1231.60bc | |
B7 | 6473.13±559.26abc | 3793.22±636.90ab | 2606.37±401.68ab | 12872.72±1013.68ab | |
B8 | 7037.53±1152.35a | 3899.53±666.52a | 2830.13±861.80a | 13767.19±1967.91a |
组合 Combination | 产量 Yield | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||
A1B1 | 5828.03±486.50a | 2275.67±406.15ab | 256.33±34.37cde | 8360.03±495.06a | |
A1B2 | 3373.29±128.30bc | 1930.54±360.85bc | 277.61±115.38cde | 5581.44±408.63bc | |
A1B3 | 3174.54±159.72c | 1519.81±126.93cd | 257.27±198.87cde | 4951.63±325.24c | |
A1B4 | 3665.84±626.33bc | 1731.00±401.43bcd | 369.94±142.67bcd | 5766.77±1110.17bc | |
A1B5 | 4432.74±246.88b | 1360.24±463.31cd | 175.33±36.10e | 5968.31±273.89bc | |
A1B6 | 3423.60±1252.48bc | 1598.24±141.94bcd | 197.61±91.73e | 5219.45±550.12c | |
A1B7 | 3014.54±1194.99c | 1513.57±519.12cd | 169.58±12.08e | 4697.69±163.70c | |
A1B8 | 3152.68±450.09c | 1326.44±377.86cd | 186.67±55.08e | 4665.78±106.97c | |
A2B1 | 3805.50±196.37bc | 1702.02±341.57bcd | 555.67±107.66a | 6063.19±298.71bc | |
A2B2 | 4559.64±867.58b | 1294.41±650.49cd | 155.56±34.69e | 6009.60±1518.75bc | |
A2B3 | 4067.73±371.41bc | 2639.72±248.14a | 272.35±84.72cde | 6979.81±43.26b | |
A2B4 | 3970.02±1152.30bc | 1651.09±356.95bcd | 535.26±106.76a | 6156.37±1383.23bc | |
A2B5 | 3577.13±279.28bc | 1310.44±278.36cd | 234.80±27.69de | 5122.37±437.70c | |
A2B6 | 4268.97±693.64bc | 1345.45±397.96cd | 456.37±121.53ab | 6070.80±1183.28bc | |
A2B7 | 4163.64±387.97bc | 1025.98±31.21d | 418.63±92.11abc | 5608.25±442.43bc | |
A2B8 | 3037.09±205.66c | 1031.41±174.79d | 197.84±34.63e | 4266.34±414.26c |
Table 3 Yield of smooth bromegrass under different mixed sowing combinations (kg·hm-2)
组合 Combination | 产量 Yield | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||
A1B1 | 5828.03±486.50a | 2275.67±406.15ab | 256.33±34.37cde | 8360.03±495.06a | |
A1B2 | 3373.29±128.30bc | 1930.54±360.85bc | 277.61±115.38cde | 5581.44±408.63bc | |
A1B3 | 3174.54±159.72c | 1519.81±126.93cd | 257.27±198.87cde | 4951.63±325.24c | |
A1B4 | 3665.84±626.33bc | 1731.00±401.43bcd | 369.94±142.67bcd | 5766.77±1110.17bc | |
A1B5 | 4432.74±246.88b | 1360.24±463.31cd | 175.33±36.10e | 5968.31±273.89bc | |
A1B6 | 3423.60±1252.48bc | 1598.24±141.94bcd | 197.61±91.73e | 5219.45±550.12c | |
A1B7 | 3014.54±1194.99c | 1513.57±519.12cd | 169.58±12.08e | 4697.69±163.70c | |
A1B8 | 3152.68±450.09c | 1326.44±377.86cd | 186.67±55.08e | 4665.78±106.97c | |
A2B1 | 3805.50±196.37bc | 1702.02±341.57bcd | 555.67±107.66a | 6063.19±298.71bc | |
A2B2 | 4559.64±867.58b | 1294.41±650.49cd | 155.56±34.69e | 6009.60±1518.75bc | |
A2B3 | 4067.73±371.41bc | 2639.72±248.14a | 272.35±84.72cde | 6979.81±43.26b | |
A2B4 | 3970.02±1152.30bc | 1651.09±356.95bcd | 535.26±106.76a | 6156.37±1383.23bc | |
A2B5 | 3577.13±279.28bc | 1310.44±278.36cd | 234.80±27.69de | 5122.37±437.70c | |
A2B6 | 4268.97±693.64bc | 1345.45±397.96cd | 456.37±121.53ab | 6070.80±1183.28bc | |
A2B7 | 4163.64±387.97bc | 1025.98±31.21d | 418.63±92.11abc | 5608.25±442.43bc | |
A2B8 | 3037.09±205.66c | 1031.41±174.79d | 197.84±34.63e | 4266.34±414.26c |
组合 Combination | 产量Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
A1B1 | 1606.11±430.03def | 1494.65±96.28de | 1140.24±358.79f | 4241.00±876.91d |
A1B2 | 2221.95±230.63cde | 1588.57±198.39cde | 1781.54±101.05cdef | 5592.06±245.89cd |
A1B3 | 2236.30±529.60cde | 1744.54±386.01bcde | 1700.85±134.94cdef | 5681.69±852.06cd |
A1B4 | 2052.75±246.10cdef | 1916.24±199.01bcde | 1787.41±407.95cdef | 5756.40±58.47cd |
A1B5 | 2731.35±793.61bcd | 2074.56±129.81abcde | 2611.39±626.39ab | 7417.29±1278.57bc |
A1B6 | 4218.61±874.92a | 2180.42±898.74abcde | 2039.56±223.79bcde | 8438.59±1700.28ab |
A1B7 | 3182.61±966.82abc | 2588.52±153.51ab | 2357.15±55.46bc | 8128.28±1115.80ab |
A1B8 | 3626.82±1170.77ab | 2930.76±937.61a | 3117.89±717.10a | 9675.47±2795.46a |
A2B1 | 1062.01±149.18f | 1591.35±470.80cde | 1145.78±107.24f | 3799.14±703.61d |
A2B2 | 2497.15±289.28bcde | 1371.74±275.78e | 1525.74±417.29def | 5394.64±440.33cd |
A2B3 | 1509.92±589.21ef | 1377.56±438.66e | 1408.96±113.29ef | 4296.43±277.27d |
A2B4 | 2244.95±574.66cde | 1554.11±566.23cde | 1777.69±767.28cdef | 5576.75±965.09cd |
A2B5 | 3180.33±577.31abc | 1984.89±443.76abcde | 1993.74±166.72bcde | 7158.96±901.58bc |
A2B6 | 2199.44±355.24cde | 1917.71±523.27bcde | 1712.81±551.53cdef | 5829.96±663.33cd |
A2B7 | 2585.48±352.62bcde | 2458.37±585.05abcd | 2267.37±525.97bcd | 7311.22±1152.11bc |
A2B8 | 4258.48±723.96a | 2510.46±608.45abc | 1824.52±298.14cdef | 8593.46±1283.34ab |
Table 4 Yield of alfalfa under different mixed sowing combinations (kg·hm-2)
组合 Combination | 产量Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
A1B1 | 1606.11±430.03def | 1494.65±96.28de | 1140.24±358.79f | 4241.00±876.91d |
A1B2 | 2221.95±230.63cde | 1588.57±198.39cde | 1781.54±101.05cdef | 5592.06±245.89cd |
A1B3 | 2236.30±529.60cde | 1744.54±386.01bcde | 1700.85±134.94cdef | 5681.69±852.06cd |
A1B4 | 2052.75±246.10cdef | 1916.24±199.01bcde | 1787.41±407.95cdef | 5756.40±58.47cd |
A1B5 | 2731.35±793.61bcd | 2074.56±129.81abcde | 2611.39±626.39ab | 7417.29±1278.57bc |
A1B6 | 4218.61±874.92a | 2180.42±898.74abcde | 2039.56±223.79bcde | 8438.59±1700.28ab |
A1B7 | 3182.61±966.82abc | 2588.52±153.51ab | 2357.15±55.46bc | 8128.28±1115.80ab |
A1B8 | 3626.82±1170.77ab | 2930.76±937.61a | 3117.89±717.10a | 9675.47±2795.46a |
A2B1 | 1062.01±149.18f | 1591.35±470.80cde | 1145.78±107.24f | 3799.14±703.61d |
A2B2 | 2497.15±289.28bcde | 1371.74±275.78e | 1525.74±417.29def | 5394.64±440.33cd |
A2B3 | 1509.92±589.21ef | 1377.56±438.66e | 1408.96±113.29ef | 4296.43±277.27d |
A2B4 | 2244.95±574.66cde | 1554.11±566.23cde | 1777.69±767.28cdef | 5576.75±965.09cd |
A2B5 | 3180.33±577.31abc | 1984.89±443.76abcde | 1993.74±166.72bcde | 7158.96±901.58bc |
A2B6 | 2199.44±355.24cde | 1917.71±523.27bcde | 1712.81±551.53cdef | 5829.96±663.33cd |
A2B7 | 2585.48±352.62bcde | 2458.37±585.05abcd | 2267.37±525.97bcd | 7311.22±1152.11bc |
A2B8 | 4258.48±723.96a | 2510.46±608.45abc | 1824.52±298.14cdef | 8593.46±1283.34ab |
组合 Combination | 产量 Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
A1B1 | 7434.15±184.31a | 3770.31±348.22ab | 1396.57±276.99d | 12601.03±475.31abcd |
A1B2 | 5595.24±314.19cde | 3519.11±529.33abc | 2059.15±37.48bcd | 11173.50±1268.93cde |
A1B3 | 5410.84±934.64de | 3264.35±607.76abc | 1958.13±222.87bcd | 10633.32±1676.51de |
A1B4 | 5718.59±445.04bcde | 3647.24±363.79abc | 2157.34±635.43bcd | 11523.17±1120.55bcde |
A1B5 | 7164.09±486.83ab | 3434.79±398.95abc | 2453.38±552.52ab | 13052.26±1304.41abc |
A1B6 | 7642.21±1103.21a | 3778.66±669.66ab | 2237.17±99.77bcd | 13658.04±771.05ab |
A1B7 | 6197.15±744.92abcde | 4102.09±630.18ab | 2526.73±62.30abc | 12825.97±1089.85abcd |
A1B8 | 6779.50±1618.31abcd | 4257.20±726.23a | 3304.56±672.45a | 14341.25±2911.65a |
A2B1 | 4867.52±343.78e | 3293.37±122.73abc | 1701.44±248.39cd | 9862.33±390.78e |
A2B2 | 7056.79±866.19abc | 2666.15±548.97c | 1681.30±303.21cd | 11404.24±1218.66bcde |
A2B3 | 5577.65±953.34cde | 4017.28±696.86ab | 1681.31±126.79cd | 11276.24±234.91cde |
A2B4 | 6214.98±1083.48abcd | 3205.20±248.48bc | 2312.94±729.16bcd | 11733.13±502.71bcde |
A2B5 | 6757.46±473.49abcd | 3295.33±527.87abc | 2228.54±259.35bcd | 12281.33±607.13abcd |
A2B6 | 6468.41±695.93abcd | 3263.16±399.33abc | 2169.19±642.61bcd | 11900.76±844.77bcde |
A2B7 | 6749.11±296.49abcd | 3484.35±559.31abc | 2686.00±496.24ab | 12919.47±1117.83abcd |
A2B8 | 7295.57±665.72a | 3541.87±395.93abc | 2355.70±843.95bc | 13193.13±573.30abc |
Table 5 Yield of grass+alfalfa under different mixed sowing combinations (kg·hm-2)
组合 Combination | 产量 Yield | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
A1B1 | 7434.15±184.31a | 3770.31±348.22ab | 1396.57±276.99d | 12601.03±475.31abcd |
A1B2 | 5595.24±314.19cde | 3519.11±529.33abc | 2059.15±37.48bcd | 11173.50±1268.93cde |
A1B3 | 5410.84±934.64de | 3264.35±607.76abc | 1958.13±222.87bcd | 10633.32±1676.51de |
A1B4 | 5718.59±445.04bcde | 3647.24±363.79abc | 2157.34±635.43bcd | 11523.17±1120.55bcde |
A1B5 | 7164.09±486.83ab | 3434.79±398.95abc | 2453.38±552.52ab | 13052.26±1304.41abc |
A1B6 | 7642.21±1103.21a | 3778.66±669.66ab | 2237.17±99.77bcd | 13658.04±771.05ab |
A1B7 | 6197.15±744.92abcde | 4102.09±630.18ab | 2526.73±62.30abc | 12825.97±1089.85abcd |
A1B8 | 6779.50±1618.31abcd | 4257.20±726.23a | 3304.56±672.45a | 14341.25±2911.65a |
A2B1 | 4867.52±343.78e | 3293.37±122.73abc | 1701.44±248.39cd | 9862.33±390.78e |
A2B2 | 7056.79±866.19abc | 2666.15±548.97c | 1681.30±303.21cd | 11404.24±1218.66bcde |
A2B3 | 5577.65±953.34cde | 4017.28±696.86ab | 1681.31±126.79cd | 11276.24±234.91cde |
A2B4 | 6214.98±1083.48abcd | 3205.20±248.48bc | 2312.94±729.16bcd | 11733.13±502.71bcde |
A2B5 | 6757.46±473.49abcd | 3295.33±527.87abc | 2228.54±259.35bcd | 12281.33±607.13abcd |
A2B6 | 6468.41±695.93abcd | 3263.16±399.33abc | 2169.19±642.61bcd | 11900.76±844.77bcde |
A2B7 | 6749.11±296.49abcd | 3484.35±559.31abc | 2686.00±496.24ab | 12919.47±1117.83abcd |
A2B8 | 7295.57±665.72a | 3541.87±395.93abc | 2355.70±843.95bc | 13193.13±573.30abc |
处理 Treatment | 1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | |
B1 | 0.58±0.13a | 2.85±0.66a | 0.41±0.08ab | 4.44±1.55a | 0.53±0.07a | 11.95±2.40a |
B2 | 0.66±0.12a | 1.90±0.57b | 0.45±0.10a | 3.37±0.97b | 0.50±0.06a | 6.96±1.31b |
B3 | 0.59±0.09a | 1.17±0.46c | 0.42±0.07ab | 1.73±0.70c | 0.52±0.13a | 4.53±1.15c |
B4 | 0.66±0.15a | 1.23±0.37c | 0.47±0.07a | 1.93±0.65c | 0.45±0.12ab | 3.84±0.86cd |
B5 | 0.70±0.10a | 1.14±0.32c | 0.44±0.10a | 2.15±0.29c | 0.46±0.13ab | 3.40±0.75cd |
B6 | 0.65±0.11a | 0.83±0.26c | 0.38±0.12abc | 1.29±0.33c | 0.38±0.08bc | 2.70±0.87d |
B7 | 0.60±0.05a | 0.91±0.18c | 0.33±0.08bc | 1.41±0.43c | 0.33±0.13cd | 2.61±0.45d |
B8 | 0.69±0.11a | 0.80±0.17c | 0.28±0.11c | 1.12±0.58c | 0.27±0.05d | 2.31±0.53d |
Table 6 Relative density (RD) of mixed sowing components under different mixture ratios of alfalfa
处理 Treatment | 1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | |
B1 | 0.58±0.13a | 2.85±0.66a | 0.41±0.08ab | 4.44±1.55a | 0.53±0.07a | 11.95±2.40a |
B2 | 0.66±0.12a | 1.90±0.57b | 0.45±0.10a | 3.37±0.97b | 0.50±0.06a | 6.96±1.31b |
B3 | 0.59±0.09a | 1.17±0.46c | 0.42±0.07ab | 1.73±0.70c | 0.52±0.13a | 4.53±1.15c |
B4 | 0.66±0.15a | 1.23±0.37c | 0.47±0.07a | 1.93±0.65c | 0.45±0.12ab | 3.84±0.86cd |
B5 | 0.70±0.10a | 1.14±0.32c | 0.44±0.10a | 2.15±0.29c | 0.46±0.13ab | 3.40±0.75cd |
B6 | 0.65±0.11a | 0.83±0.26c | 0.38±0.12abc | 1.29±0.33c | 0.38±0.08bc | 2.70±0.87d |
B7 | 0.60±0.05a | 0.91±0.18c | 0.33±0.08bc | 1.41±0.43c | 0.33±0.13cd | 2.61±0.45d |
B8 | 0.69±0.11a | 0.80±0.17c | 0.28±0.11c | 1.12±0.58c | 0.27±0.05d | 2.31±0.53d |
处理 Treatment | 1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | |
B1 | 0.84±0.20a | 2.83±0.79a | 0.52±0.12a | 4.30±0.77a | 0.34±0.15ab | 10.95±3.36a | 0.67±0.13a | 4.21±0.78a |
B2 | 0.68±0.12b | 2.54±0.48a | 0.44±0.16ab | 2.06±0.28b | 0.17±0.07d | 7.69±1.13b | 0.53±0.09b | 2.87±0.12b |
B3 | 0.62±0.15bc | 1.31±0.50b | 0.55±0.17a | 1.47±0.43c | 0.21±0.09cd | 4.86±0.60c | 0.55±0.12b | 1.75±0.35c |
B4 | 0.66±0.11bc | 1.18±0.21b | 0.45±0.09ab | 1.21±0.23cd | 0.37±0.10a | 4.33±1.05c | 0.55±0.08b | 1.48±0.13cd |
B5 | 0.70±0.10b | 1.26±0.25b | 0.35±0.09bc | 1.13±0.23cd | 0.17±0.03d | 3.87±1.62c | 0.51±0.06bc | 1.52±0.19cd |
B6 | 0.67±0.18bc | 1.18±0.44b | 0.39±0.09bc | 0.95±0.30d | 0.27±0.15bc | 2.88±1.11c | 0.52±0.12bc | 1.25±0.28d |
B7 | 0.62±0.17bc | 0.89±0.26b | 0.34±0.11bc | 1.01±0.21cd | 0.24±0.12cd | 3.12±0.52c | 0.47±0.07bc | 1.15±0.20d |
B8 | 0.54±0.04c | 1.06±0.33b | 0.31±0.08c | 1.00±0.34cd | 0.16±0.04d | 3.13±1.26c | 0.43±0.04c | 1.19±0.29d |
Table 7 Relative yield (RY) of mixed seeding components under different mixture ratios of alfalfa
处理 Treatment | 1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | |
B1 | 0.84±0.20a | 2.83±0.79a | 0.52±0.12a | 4.30±0.77a | 0.34±0.15ab | 10.95±3.36a | 0.67±0.13a | 4.21±0.78a |
B2 | 0.68±0.12b | 2.54±0.48a | 0.44±0.16ab | 2.06±0.28b | 0.17±0.07d | 7.69±1.13b | 0.53±0.09b | 2.87±0.12b |
B3 | 0.62±0.15bc | 1.31±0.50b | 0.55±0.17a | 1.47±0.43c | 0.21±0.09cd | 4.86±0.60c | 0.55±0.12b | 1.75±0.35c |
B4 | 0.66±0.11bc | 1.18±0.21b | 0.45±0.09ab | 1.21±0.23cd | 0.37±0.10a | 4.33±1.05c | 0.55±0.08b | 1.48±0.13cd |
B5 | 0.70±0.10b | 1.26±0.25b | 0.35±0.09bc | 1.13±0.23cd | 0.17±0.03d | 3.87±1.62c | 0.51±0.06bc | 1.52±0.19cd |
B6 | 0.67±0.18bc | 1.18±0.44b | 0.39±0.09bc | 0.95±0.30d | 0.27±0.15bc | 2.88±1.11c | 0.52±0.12bc | 1.25±0.28d |
B7 | 0.62±0.17bc | 0.89±0.26b | 0.34±0.11bc | 1.01±0.21cd | 0.24±0.12cd | 3.12±0.52c | 0.47±0.07bc | 1.15±0.20d |
B8 | 0.54±0.04c | 1.06±0.33b | 0.31±0.08c | 1.00±0.34cd | 0.16±0.04d | 3.13±1.26c | 0.43±0.04c | 1.19±0.29d |
处理 Treatment | 相对产量总和 Relative yield total | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
B1 | 0.98±0.24ab | 0.74±0.10ab | 0.89±0.20c | 1.25±0.17c |
B2 | 0.94±0.14ab | 0.64±0.17b | 0.94±0.14bc | 1.33±0.08c |
B3 | 0.82±0.16b | 0.77±0.17a | 0.94±0.11bc | 1.27±0.12c |
B4 | 0.89±0.12ab | 0.69±0.09ab | 1.24±0.30ab | 1.37±0.06c |
B5 | 1.01±0.08a | 0.64±0.10b | 1.14±0.32abc | 1.56±0.15ab |
B6 | 1.02±0.18a | 0.67±0.09ab | 1.13±0.26abc | 1.55±0.18b |
B7 | 0.93±0.14ab | 0.69±0.14ab | 1.34±0.18a | 1.59±0.14ab |
B8 | 0.96±0.15ab | 0.71±0.11ab | 1.41±0.49a | 1.74±0.28a |
Table 8 Relative yield total(RYT) of grassland under different mixed sowing ratios of alfalfa
处理 Treatment | 相对产量总和 Relative yield total | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
1茬 First cropping | 2茬 Second cropping | 3茬 Third cropping | 全年 Annual | |
B1 | 0.98±0.24ab | 0.74±0.10ab | 0.89±0.20c | 1.25±0.17c |
B2 | 0.94±0.14ab | 0.64±0.17b | 0.94±0.14bc | 1.33±0.08c |
B3 | 0.82±0.16b | 0.77±0.17a | 0.94±0.11bc | 1.27±0.12c |
B4 | 0.89±0.12ab | 0.69±0.09ab | 1.24±0.30ab | 1.37±0.06c |
B5 | 1.01±0.08a | 0.64±0.10b | 1.14±0.32abc | 1.56±0.15ab |
B6 | 1.02±0.18a | 0.67±0.09ab | 1.13±0.26abc | 1.55±0.18b |
B7 | 0.93±0.14ab | 0.69±0.14ab | 1.34±0.18a | 1.59±0.14ab |
B8 | 0.96±0.15ab | 0.71±0.11ab | 1.41±0.49a | 1.74±0.28a |
项目 Item | 处理 Treatment | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A1B1 | A1B2 | A1B3 | A1B4 | A1B5 | A1B6 | A1B7 | A1B8 | |
评价值Evaluation value | 0.0796 | 0.0669 | 0.0500 | 0.0647 | 0.0666 | 0.0458 | 0.0340 | 0.0414 |
排序Order | 3 | 7 | 12 | 9 | 8 | 13 | 16 | 14 |
项目 Item | 处理 Treatment | |||||||
A2B1 | A2B2 | A2B3 | A2B4 | A2B5 | A2B6 | A2B7 | A2B8 | |
评价值Evaluation value | 0.0783 | 0.0511 | 0.0820 | 0.0989 | 0.0570 | 0.0773 | 0.0689 | 0.0376 |
排序Order | 4 | 11 | 2 | 1 | 10 | 5 | 6 | 15 |
Table 9 The value of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation of each combination under different alfalfa and grass mixed sowing combination
项目 Item | 处理 Treatment | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A1B1 | A1B2 | A1B3 | A1B4 | A1B5 | A1B6 | A1B7 | A1B8 | |
评价值Evaluation value | 0.0796 | 0.0669 | 0.0500 | 0.0647 | 0.0666 | 0.0458 | 0.0340 | 0.0414 |
排序Order | 3 | 7 | 12 | 9 | 8 | 13 | 16 | 14 |
项目 Item | 处理 Treatment | |||||||
A2B1 | A2B2 | A2B3 | A2B4 | A2B5 | A2B6 | A2B7 | A2B8 | |
评价值Evaluation value | 0.0783 | 0.0511 | 0.0820 | 0.0989 | 0.0570 | 0.0773 | 0.0689 | 0.0376 |
排序Order | 4 | 11 | 2 | 1 | 10 | 5 | 6 | 15 |
1 | Ye T, Wu X J, Lu Y X, et al. Effect of planting ratio on the stability of forage yield and population density in two alfalfa-grass mixtures. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(5): 127-137. |
叶婷, 吴晓娟, 芦奕晓, 等. 混播比例对两种苜蓿混播草地产量和种群密度稳定性的影响. 草业学报, 2023, 32(5): 127-137. | |
2 | Zhang Y L, Zhang L J, Yu T F, et al. Effects of grass-legume combinations and intercropping patterns on the forage yield and yield stability. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2019, 27(5): 1410-1418. |
张永亮, 张丽娟, 于铁峰, 等. 禾豆组合与间作方式对牧草产量及产量稳定性的影响. 草地学报, 2019, 27(5): 1410-1418. | |
3 | Zheng W, Jianaerguli, Tang G R, et al. Determination and comparison of community stablity in different legume-grass mixes. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. |
郑伟, 加娜尔古丽, 唐高溶, 等. 不同混播方式下豆禾混播草地群落稳定性的测度与比较. 草业学报, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. | |
4 | Zhang Y L, Yu T F, Hao F, et al. Effects of fertilization and legume-grass ratio on forage yield and NPK utilization efficiency. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2020, 29(11): 91-101. |
张永亮, 于铁峰, 郝凤, 等. 施肥与混播比例对豆禾混播牧草产量及氮磷钾利用效率的影响. 草业学报, 2020, 29(11): 91-101. | |
5 | Liu Q Y, Yun L, Chen Y F, et al. The dynamic analysis of forage yield and interspecific competition in alfalfa-grass mixed pasture. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(3): 181-191. |
刘启宇, 云岚, 陈逸凡, 等. 苜蓿—禾草混播草地牧草产量及种间竞争关系的动态研究. 草业学报, 2022, 31(3): 181-191. | |
6 | Liu M, Gong J R, Wang Y H, et al. Effects of legume-grass mixed sowing on forage grass yield and quality in artificial grassland. Arid Zone Research, 2016, 33(1): 179-185. |
刘敏, 龚吉蕊, 王忆慧, 等. 禾豆混播建植人工草地对牧草产量和草质的影响. 干旱区研究, 2016, 33(1): 179-185. | |
7 | Chen J S, Zhu R F, Gao C, et al. Interspecific competition of mixed grassland of bromegrass (Bromus inermis L.) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2013, 21(6): 1157-1161. |
陈积山, 朱瑞芬, 高超, 等. 苜蓿和无芒雀麦混播草地种间竞争研究. 草地学报, 2013, 21(6): 1157-1161. | |
8 | Zhang H H, Shi S L, Wu B, et al. A study of yield interactions in mixed sowings of alfalfa and three perennial grasses. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(2): 159-170. |
张辉辉, 师尚礼, 武蓓, 等. 苜蓿与3种多年生禾草混播效应研究. 草业学报, 2022, 31(2): 159-170. | |
9 | Lu F K, Wang J G. Study on cutting height of mixed sowing of alfalfa with smooth brome. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2014, 36(1): 49-52, 57. |
鲁富宽, 王建光. 紫花苜蓿和无芒雀麦混播草地适宜刈割高度研究. 中国草地学报, 2014, 36(1) :49-52, 57. | |
10 | Qi J, Zheng W, Zhang X H, et al.Determination and comparison of the production performance of pastures among different spatial structure of legume-grass mixtures. Pratacultural Science, 2016, 33(1): 116-128. |
祁军, 郑伟, 张鲜花, 等. 不同豆禾混播模式的草地生产性能. 草业科学, 2016, 33(1): 116-128. | |
11 | Gou R, You M H, Liu J P, et al. Effect of sowing methods on the productivity of mixed Avena sativa and Vicia sativa pastures. Pratacultural Science, 2019, 36(3): 804-812. |
苟蓉, 游明鸿, 刘金平, 等. 播种方式对燕麦和箭筈豌豆混播草地牧草生产性能的影响. 草业科学, 2019, 36(3): 804-812. | |
12 | Bai Y C. Different sowing styles and proportion of alfalfa and Elymus sibiricus with the influence of mixed seeding grass. Hohhot: Inner Mongolia Agricultural University, 2011. |
白音仓. 不同播种方式及比例对紫花苜蓿和老芒麦混播草地的影响. 呼和浩特: 内蒙古农业大学, 2011. | |
13 | Wo Y. Study on production performance and soil nutrient characteristics of soybean grass mixed grassland with different planting modes. Tongliao: Inner Mongolia Minzu University, 2022. |
沃野. 不同种植模式禾豆混播草地生产性能和土壤养分特性研究. 通辽: 内蒙古民族大学, 2022. | |
14 | Yao Z Y, Li J, Song L Z, et al. Study on the effect of cross sowing of Elymus nutans and Medicago sativa in different periods. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2020, 28(5): 1454-1459. |
姚泽英, 李军, 宋连昭, 等. 垂穗披碱草与紫花苜蓿不同时期交叉混播效果研究. 草地学报, 2020, 28(5): 1454-1459. | |
15 | Wang P, Zhou D W, Zhang B T. Coexistence and inter-specific competition in grass-legume mixture. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2009, 29(5): 2560-2567. |
王平, 周道玮, 张宝田. 禾豆混播草地种间竞争与共存. 生态学报, 2009, 29(5): 2560-2567. | |
16 | Zhang Y L, Gao K, Yu T F, et al. Effects of sowing patterns on productivity and interspecific relationship of alfalfa-grass mixture system. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2020, 42(2): 47-57. |
张永亮, 高凯, 于铁峰, 等. 禾草种类与混播比例对苜蓿-禾草混播系统生产力及种间关系的影响. 中国草地学报, 2020, 42(2): 47-57. | |
17 | Teng Z, Zhang Y L, Zhang Y X, et al. Grassland production performance and photosynthetic characteristics under different alfalfa densities and grass bean mixed sowing. Pratacultural Science, 2022, 39(8): 1618-1627. |
滕泽, 张永亮, 张玉霞, 等. 紫花苜蓿密度及禾豆混播方式下草地生产性能及光合特性. 草业科学, 2022, 39(8): 1618-1627. | |
18 | Ren W, Zhang Z X, Lin C X, et al. Effects of mixed seeding ratio on biomass allocation and competition of Onobrychis viciifolia and Elymus nutans under cold conditions in the Tianzhu alpine region. Pratacultural Science, 2020, 37(10): 2035-2048. |
任文, 张志新, 蔺昶兴, 等. 混播比例对高寒草地红豆草-垂穗披碱草混播群落生物量分配与竞争的影响. 草业科学, 2020, 37(10): 2035-2048. | |
19 | Zheng W, Zhu J Z, Jianaerguli, et al. Effects of different mixed sowing patterns on production perfomance of legume grass mixture. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2011, 33(5): 45-50. |
郑伟, 朱进忠, 加娜尔古丽, 等. 不同混播方式对禾豆混播草地生产性能的影响. 中国草地学报, 2011, 33(5): 45-50. | |
20 | Du J Y, Li X Y, Yang L, et al. Study on the changes of grassland productivity in the third year of mixed sowing in Bashang area of northwest of Hebei. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2022, 30(7): 1855-1861. |
杜俊颖, 李鑫洋, 杨莉, 等. 冀西北坝上地区禾豆混播草地建植第三年草地生产力变化研究. 草地学报, 2022, 30(7): 1855-1861. | |
21 | Li M, Qi J, Yang H, et al. Effect of mixed planting ratio and planting method on the productivity and inter specific ralationship of Elymus sibiricus and alfalfa in mixed planting system. Grassland and Turf, 2022, 42(1): 29-37. |
李明, 祁娟, 杨航, 等. 混播比例及播种方式对老芒麦与紫花苜蓿混播系统生产力及种间关系的影响. 草原与草坪, 2022, 42(1): 29-37. | |
22 | Liu J Y, Liao Y Z J, Li X, et al. Effects of different nitrogen treatments on the growth and carbon-nitrogen metabolism of tall fescue under low-light stress. Pratacultural Science, 2022, 39(1): 96-103. |
刘嘉艺, 廖杨子杰, 李萱, 等. 不同氮处理和弱光下高羊茅生长及其碳氮代谢特征. 草业科学, 2022, 39(1): 96-103. | |
23 | Zhu Y Q, Zheng W, Wang X, et al. Effect of mixed pattern on growth efficiency and mixed advantage of Bromu sinnermis+Onobrychis viciaefolia mixture pasture. Pratacultural Science, 2017, 34(11): 2335-2346. |
朱亚琼, 郑伟, 王祥, 等. 混播方式对无芒雀麦+红豆草混播草地植物生长效率及混播效应的影响. 草业科学, 2017, 34(11): 2335-2346. | |
24 | Zheng W, Zhu J Z, Kuerban, et al. Dynamics of interspecific competition of legume-grass mixture under different mixed sowing patterns. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2010, 18(4): 568-575. |
郑伟, 朱进忠, 库尔班, 等. 不同混播方式下禾豆混播草地种间竞争动态研究. 草地学报, 2010, 18(4): 568-575. | |
25 | Xie K Y, Zhang Y J, Li X L, et al. Competition and coexistence of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and smooth brome (Bromus inermis Layss.) in mixture. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2015, 48(18): 3767-3778. |
谢开云, 张英俊, 李向林, 等. 无芒雀麦和紫花苜蓿在(1:1)混播中的竞争与共存. 中国农业科学, 2015, 48(18): 3767-3778. | |
26 | Wang D, Wang J J, Li L H, et al. Forage yield and interspecific competition of mixed sowing of alfalfa and wheatgrass under dry farming. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2014, 36(5): 27-31. |
王丹, 王俊杰, 李凌浩, 等. 旱作条件下苜蓿与冰草不同混播方式的产草量及种间竞争关系. 中国草地学报, 2014, 36(5): 27-31. | |
27 | Zuo Y C, Du Z H, Zhu Y Q, et al. Effects of mixture sowing on forage yield and interspecific competition of alfalfa and orchard grass. Animal Husbandry and Feed Science, 2010, 2(10/11/12): 39-41. |
[1] | Shi-long LEI, Li-rong LIAO, Jie WANG, Lu ZHANG, Zhen-cheng YE, Guo-bin LIU, Chao ZHANG. The diversity-Godron stability relationship of alpine grassland and its environmental drivers [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 1-12. |
[2] | Hui-hui ZHANG, Shang-li SHI, Bei WU, Zi-li LI, Xiao-long LI. A study of yield interactions in mixed sowings of alfalfa and three perennial grasses [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(2): 159-170. |
[3] | Jing-dong ZHAO, Yan-tao SONG, Xin-lei XU, Wuyunna. Effects of nitrogen application and mowing on yield and quality of forage in degraded grassland in northwest Liaoning Province [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(8): 36-48. |
[4] | Hui-xin JIANG, Shan-shan BAI, Bo WU, Jing-yi SONG, Guo-liang WANG. A multivariate evaluation of agronomic straits and forage quality of 22 oat varieties in the Huang-Huai-Hai area of China [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(1): 140-149. |
[5] | ZHANG Yong-liang, YU Tie-feng, HAO Feng, GAO Kai. Effects of fertilization and legume-grass ratio on forage yield and NPK utilization efficiency [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2020, 29(11): 91-101. |
[6] | XU Hai-peng, YU Cheng, SHU Chao-cheng, JIN Shao-hong, PANG Xiao-pan, GUO Zheng-gang. The effect of plateau pika disturbance on plant community diversity and stability in an alpine meadow [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(5): 90-99. |
[7] | WANG Qian, LI Zhi-jian, LI Jing, ZHOU Bang-wei. Evaluation of agronomic and forage quality traits of a range of oat cultivars [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(12): 149-158. |
[8] | WANG Xue-Chun, WANG Hong-Ni, HUANG Jing, YANG Guo-Tao, HU Yun-Gao. Simulation of soil moisture dynamics and ryegrass growth in the hilly region of Sichuan Province using the environmental policy integrated climate model [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2017, 26(9): 1-13. |
[9] | DUAN Qian-Wen, CHENG Hui, HOU Fu-Jiang. Using maturity to predict forage yield and nutritional quality of forage cereals in the Jingtai Oasis [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2017, 26(6): 185-194. |
[10] | WANG Bo-Jie, TANG Hai-Ping, HE Li, LIN Guo-Hui, ZHAO Shi-Jie, ZHAO Ming-Xu. Stability of alfalfa and wheatgrass pasture under dry farming in a pastoral agronomy area [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2016, 25(4): 222-229. |
[11] | ZHENG Wei, Jianaerguli, TANG Gaorong, ZHU Jinzhong. Determination and comparison of community stability in different legume-grass mixes [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. |
[12] | YUE Yan-hong,QI Xiao,WANG Yan-rong,PENG Lan-qing,YU Ling. Persistence of 35 Medicago sativa varieties at the 10th year after establishment [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2014, 23(1): 58-64. |
[13] | PUYANG Xue-hua, DAI Zi-yun, GAO Chen-hao, SONG Zheng, HAN Lie-bao, MENG Jian-zhong. A study on the eco-environment health assessment in golf course [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2013, 22(4): 266-274. |
[14] | SHE Feng-xia, HAO Ming-de, ZANG Yi-fei. Alfalfa productivity and plateau characteristics in a gully region of the Loess Plateau [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2013, 22(2): 313-317. |
[15] | DING Cheng-long, GU Hong-ru, XU Neng-xiang, CHENG Yun-hui. Effect of cutting time on the biomass production and forage quality of Lolium multiflorum [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2011, 20(6): 186-194. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||