Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2022, Vol. 31 ›› Issue (3): 181-191.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2020589
Qi-yu LIU1(), Lan YUN1,2(), Yi-fan CHEN1, Hong-yu GUO1, Zhen LI1, Zhi-qi GAO1, Jun WANG1, Feng-ling SHI1,2
Received:
2020-12-29
Revised:
2021-02-26
Online:
2022-03-20
Published:
2022-01-15
Contact:
Lan YUN
Qi-yu LIU, Lan YUN, Yi-fan CHEN, Hong-yu GUO, Zhen LI, Zhi-qi GAO, Jun WANG, Feng-ling SHI. The dynamic analysis of forage yield and interspecific competition in alfalfa-grass mixed pasture[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(3): 181-191.
编号 Code | 混播处理 Mixed treatments | 行数 Row number | 混播比例 Mixed sowing ratio | 每行播种量 Sowing rate of each line (g) |
---|---|---|---|---|
A1B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~8.192 |
A1B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~12.288 |
A1B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~12.288 |
A2B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~9.976 |
A2B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~14.964 |
A2B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~14.964 |
A3B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~25.184 |
A3B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~37.776 |
A3B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~37.776 |
C1 | 单播新麦草Monoculture P. juncea | 8 | - | 16.384 |
C2 | 单播缘毛雀麦Monoculture B. ciliatus | 8 | - | 19.952 |
C3 | 单播长穗偃麦草Monoculture E. elongata | 8 | - | 50.368 |
C4 | 单播草原3号苜蓿Monoculture M. varia | 8 | - | 12.888 |
Table 1 The proportion and sowing rate of mixed alfafa and grass mixed sowing
编号 Code | 混播处理 Mixed treatments | 行数 Row number | 混播比例 Mixed sowing ratio | 每行播种量 Sowing rate of each line (g) |
---|---|---|---|---|
A1B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~8.192 |
A1B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~12.288 |
A1B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-新麦草P. juncea | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~12.288 |
A2B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~9.976 |
A2B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~14.964 |
A2B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~14.964 |
A3B1 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 4~4 | 1∶1 | 6.444~25.184 |
A3B2 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 3~6 | 1∶2 | 4.833~37.776 |
A3B3 | 草原3号苜蓿M. varia-长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 2~6 | 1∶3 | 3.222~37.776 |
C1 | 单播新麦草Monoculture P. juncea | 8 | - | 16.384 |
C2 | 单播缘毛雀麦Monoculture B. ciliatus | 8 | - | 19.952 |
C3 | 单播长穗偃麦草Monoculture E. elongata | 8 | - | 50.368 |
C4 | 单播草原3号苜蓿Monoculture M. varia | 8 | - | 12.888 |
物种Species | 刈割期Ⅰ Mowing period Ⅰ | 刈割期Ⅱ Mowing period Ⅱ | 刈割期Ⅲ Mowing period Ⅲ |
---|---|---|---|
新麦草P. juncea | 抽穗期Heading stage | 乳熟期Milk ripening stage | 完熟期Full-ripe stage |
缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 抽穗期Heading stage | 初花期Early flowering stage | 乳熟期Milk ripening stage |
长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 拔节期Jointing stage | 抽穗期Heading stage | 灌浆期 Filling stage |
草原3号苜蓿M. varia | 初花期Early flowering stage | 盛花期Full-bloom stage | 结荚期Podding stage |
Table 2 Corresponding phenological periods of forages in different mowing periods
物种Species | 刈割期Ⅰ Mowing period Ⅰ | 刈割期Ⅱ Mowing period Ⅱ | 刈割期Ⅲ Mowing period Ⅲ |
---|---|---|---|
新麦草P. juncea | 抽穗期Heading stage | 乳熟期Milk ripening stage | 完熟期Full-ripe stage |
缘毛雀麦B. ciliatus | 抽穗期Heading stage | 初花期Early flowering stage | 乳熟期Milk ripening stage |
长穗偃麦草E. elongata | 拔节期Jointing stage | 抽穗期Heading stage | 灌浆期 Filling stage |
草原3号苜蓿M. varia | 初花期Early flowering stage | 盛花期Full-bloom stage | 结荚期Podding stage |
混播处理 Mixed treatments | 刈割期Ⅰ Mowing period Ⅰ | 刈割期Ⅱ Mowing period Ⅱ | 刈割期Ⅲ Mowing period Ⅲ | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | |
A1B1 | 3333.33bc | 6400.00a | 9733.33a | 4333.33a | 12166.67a | 16500.00a | 4666.67a | 6733.33a | 11400.00abc |
A1B2 | 3500.00bc | 5666.67a | 9166.67a | 4733.33a | 13900.00a | 18633.33a | 4266.67a | 9133.33a | 13400.00ab |
A1B3 | 2600.00c | 5433.33a | 8033.33a | 4233.33a | 11433.33a | 15666.66a | 5933.33a | 10566.67a | 16500.00a |
A2B1 | 5166.67a | 5000.00a | 10166.67a | 8700.00a | 6300.00a | 15000.00a | 6500.00a | 8800.00a | 15300.00a |
A2B2 | 4766.67ab | 3700.00a | 8466.67a | 5566.67a | 4966.67a | 10533.34ab | 6533.33a | 6600.00a | 13133.33ab |
A2B3 | 4633.33ab | 4700.00a | 9333.33a | 7200.00a | 7933.33a | 15133.33a | 6433.33a | 8000.00a | 14433.33ab |
A3B1 | 2400.00c | 5900.00a | 8300.00a | 5600.00a | 12433.33a | 18033.33a | 8300.00a | 6866.67a | 15166.67a |
A3B2 | 2800.00c | 5500.00a | 8300.00a | 5133.33a | 10033.33a | 15166.66a | 6133.33a | 10966.67a | 17100.00a |
A3B3 | 2900.00c | 4466.67a | 7366.67a | 4000.00a | 7166.67a | 11166.67ab | 7300.00a | 8933.33a | 16233.33a |
C1 | 3266.67bc | - | 3266.67c | 3733.33a | - | 3733.33b | 3866.67a | - | 3866.67d |
C2 | - | - | 4866.67bc | 6066.67a | - | 6066.67b | 6633.33a | - | 6633.33cd |
C3 | 2730.00c | - | 2730.00c | 5500.00a | - | 5500.00b | 5850.00a | - | 5850.00cd |
C4 | - | 4700.00a | 4700.00bc | - | 10266.67a | 10266.67ab | - | 8233.33a | 8233.33bcd |
Table 3 The dry matter yield of different cutting periods under different mixed sowing treatments (kg·hm-2)
混播处理 Mixed treatments | 刈割期Ⅰ Mowing period Ⅰ | 刈割期Ⅱ Mowing period Ⅱ | 刈割期Ⅲ Mowing period Ⅲ | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | 禾草 Grass | 苜蓿 Alfalfa | 总产量 Total yield | |
A1B1 | 3333.33bc | 6400.00a | 9733.33a | 4333.33a | 12166.67a | 16500.00a | 4666.67a | 6733.33a | 11400.00abc |
A1B2 | 3500.00bc | 5666.67a | 9166.67a | 4733.33a | 13900.00a | 18633.33a | 4266.67a | 9133.33a | 13400.00ab |
A1B3 | 2600.00c | 5433.33a | 8033.33a | 4233.33a | 11433.33a | 15666.66a | 5933.33a | 10566.67a | 16500.00a |
A2B1 | 5166.67a | 5000.00a | 10166.67a | 8700.00a | 6300.00a | 15000.00a | 6500.00a | 8800.00a | 15300.00a |
A2B2 | 4766.67ab | 3700.00a | 8466.67a | 5566.67a | 4966.67a | 10533.34ab | 6533.33a | 6600.00a | 13133.33ab |
A2B3 | 4633.33ab | 4700.00a | 9333.33a | 7200.00a | 7933.33a | 15133.33a | 6433.33a | 8000.00a | 14433.33ab |
A3B1 | 2400.00c | 5900.00a | 8300.00a | 5600.00a | 12433.33a | 18033.33a | 8300.00a | 6866.67a | 15166.67a |
A3B2 | 2800.00c | 5500.00a | 8300.00a | 5133.33a | 10033.33a | 15166.66a | 6133.33a | 10966.67a | 17100.00a |
A3B3 | 2900.00c | 4466.67a | 7366.67a | 4000.00a | 7166.67a | 11166.67ab | 7300.00a | 8933.33a | 16233.33a |
C1 | 3266.67bc | - | 3266.67c | 3733.33a | - | 3733.33b | 3866.67a | - | 3866.67d |
C2 | - | - | 4866.67bc | 6066.67a | - | 6066.67b | 6633.33a | - | 6633.33cd |
C3 | 2730.00c | - | 2730.00c | 5500.00a | - | 5500.00b | 5850.00a | - | 5850.00cd |
C4 | - | 4700.00a | 4700.00bc | - | 10266.67a | 10266.67ab | - | 8233.33a | 8233.33bcd |
处理 Treatments | 刈割期Mowing period | 处理 Treatments | 刈割期Mowing period | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ⅰ | Ⅱ | Ⅲ | Ⅰ | Ⅱ | Ⅲ | ||
A1B1 | 2.50±0.36a | 2.80±1.18a | 2.15±0.45a | A2B3 | 1.98±0.57a | 2.16±0.82a | 2.07±0.98a |
A1B2 | 2.50±0.71a | 2.97±0.22a | 2.37±0.62a | A3B1 | 2.47±0.98a | 1.97±0.46a | 2.70±0.98a |
A1B3 | 2.08±0.47a | 2.56±0.47a | 3.11±1.04a | A3B2 | 2.12±0.17a | 1.90±0.39a | 2.74±0.38a |
A2B1 | 2.56±0.75a | 2.05±0.20a | 2.15±0.25a | A3B3 | 2.24±0.95a | 1.79±1.01a | 2.58±0.81a |
A2B2 | 1.84±0.20a | 1.52±0.44a | 1.91±0.47a |
Table 4 Effect of mixed seeding treatments on land equivalent ratio (LER)
处理 Treatments | 刈割期Mowing period | 处理 Treatments | 刈割期Mowing period | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ⅰ | Ⅱ | Ⅲ | Ⅰ | Ⅱ | Ⅲ | ||
A1B1 | 2.50±0.36a | 2.80±1.18a | 2.15±0.45a | A2B3 | 1.98±0.57a | 2.16±0.82a | 2.07±0.98a |
A1B2 | 2.50±0.71a | 2.97±0.22a | 2.37±0.62a | A3B1 | 2.47±0.98a | 1.97±0.46a | 2.70±0.98a |
A1B3 | 2.08±0.47a | 2.56±0.47a | 3.11±1.04a | A3B2 | 2.12±0.17a | 1.90±0.39a | 2.74±0.38a |
A2B1 | 2.56±0.75a | 2.05±0.20a | 2.15±0.25a | A3B3 | 2.24±0.95a | 1.79±1.01a | 2.58±0.81a |
A2B2 | 1.84±0.20a | 1.52±0.44a | 1.91±0.47a |
1 | Lu F K, Wang J G. Study on cutting height of mixed sowing of alfalfa with smooth brome. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2014, 36(1): 49-52, 57. |
鲁富宽, 王建光. 紫花苜蓿和无芒雀麦混播草地适宜刈割高度研究. 中国草地学报, 2014, 36(1): 49-52, 57. | |
2 | Xie K Y, Zhang Y J, Li X L, et al. Competition and coexistence of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and smooth broom (Bromus inermis Leyss.) in mixture. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2015, 48(18): 3767-3778. |
谢开云, 张英俊, 李向林, 等. 无芒雀麦和紫花苜蓿在(1∶1)混播中的竞争与共存. 中国农业科学, 2015, 48(18): 3767-3778. | |
3 | Zhang C, Yun L, Li Z, et al. Genetic diversity and structure analysis in Psathyrostachys Nevski population using SSR markers. Journal of Plant Genetic Resources, 2019, 20(1): 48-59. |
张晨, 云岚, 李珍, 等. 新麦草种质的 SSR 遗传多样性及群体结构分析. 植物遗传资源学报, 2019, 20(1): 48-59. | |
4 | Bai K Y, Wang P, Han J G, et al. Nitrogen distribution at grass-soil system and growing dynamic on Russian wildryegrass pasture as influenced by grazing. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 1999, 7(1): 3-5. |
白可喻, 王培, 韩建国, 等. 放牧强度对新麦草人工草地氮素在牧草与土壤中的分配和动态的影响. 草地学报, 1999, 7(1): 3-5. | |
5 | Gu A L, Larrv H, Yun J F. Establishment of two entries of Psathyrostachys juncea in the arid and semi-arid areas in Inner Mongolia. Grassland of China, 1994, 5(5): 12-14, 27. |
谷安琳, Larrv H, 云锦凤. 新麦草在内蒙古干旱草原的建植试验. 中国草地, 1994, 5(5): 12-14, 27. | |
6 | Shi F L. A study on suitable seed harvesting time for fringed bromegrass. Journal of Inner Mongolia Institute of Agriculture & Animal Husbandry, 1996, 17(4): 54-57. |
石凤翎. 缘毛雀麦适宜采种期的研究. 内蒙古农牧学院学报, 1996, 17(4): 54-57. | |
7 | Wang W J, Song Y X, Hu W J, et al. Comparison of biomass accumulation-related traits in the F1 hybrids of common wheat and tall wheatgrass and their parents. Pratacultural Science, 2020, 37(9): 1821-1832. |
汪文佳, 宋运贤, 胡伟娟, 等. (小麦×长穗偃麦草)F1与长穗偃麦草生物量积累相关性状的比较. 草业科学, 2020, 37(9): 1821-1832. | |
8 | Xu M, Wang Q, Wang Y X, et al. Effects of different salt stress on seed germination and seedling growth of Elytrigia elongate. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2020, 42(1): 15-20. |
徐曼, 王茜, 王奕骁, 等. 不同盐胁迫对长穗偃麦草种子萌发及幼苗生长的影响. 中国草地学报, 2020, 42(1): 15-20. | |
9 | Zhou Y T, Guo Q, Mao P C, et al. High-frequency regeneration system of mature embryos of Elytrigia elongata. Pratacultural Science, 2019, 36 (5): 1317-1322. |
周妍彤, 郭强, 毛培春, 等. 长穗偃麦草成熟种胚高频再生体系. 草业科学, 2019, 36(5): 1317-1322. | |
10 | Zheng W, Jianaerguli, Tang G R, et al. Determination and comparison of community stability in different legume-grass mixes. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. |
郑伟, 加娜尔古丽, 唐高溶, 等. 不同混播方式下豆禾混播草地群落稳定性的测度与比较. 草业学报, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. | |
11 | Yang X P, Li P, Dong C F, et al. Studies on the dynamics of above-ground biomass and nutritive value of annual ryegrass and common oat mixtures. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2020, 28(1): 149-158. |
杨晓鹏, 李平, 董臣飞, 等. 多花黑麦草+燕麦混播草地地上生物量和营养品质动态研究. 草地学报, 2020, 28(1): 149-158. | |
12 | Xie K Y, Cao K, Wan J C, et al. Change in productivity of swards of different forage legume and grass species monocultures and combinations in the semi-arid region of Xinjiang province. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2020, 29(4): 29-40. |
谢开云, 曹凯, 万江春, 等. 新疆半干旱区不同豆科/禾本科牧草混播草地生产力的变化研究. 草业学报, 2020, 29(4): 29-40. | |
13 | Aponte A, Samarappuli D, Berti M T. Alfalfa-grass mixtures in comparison to grass and alfalfa monocultures. Agronomy Journal, 2019, 111(2): 628-638. |
14 | Wang C Y, Zhi Z S. Effect of different soil and planting density on Sudan grass agronomic traits. Inner Mongolia Agricultural Science and Technology, 2014, 11(2): 24-27. |
王春勇, 支中生. 不同土壤及种植密度对苏丹草农艺性状的影响. 内蒙古农业科技, 2014, 11(2): 24-27. | |
15 | Fan Y K, Yun L, Li Z, et al. Correlation analysis of agronomic traits related to forage yield of Psathyrostachys juncea. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2020, 42(3): 119-125. |
范亚坤, 云岚, 李珍, 等. 新麦草饲草产量相关农艺性状的关联性分析. 中国草地学报, 2020, 42(3): 119-125. | |
16 | Javanmard A, Nasiri Y, Shekari F. Competition and dry matter yield in intercrops of barley and legume for forage. Albanian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 2014, 13(1): 22. |
17 | Zhang Y L, Zhang L J, Yu T F, et al. Effects of grass-legume combinations and intercropping patterns on the forage yield and yield stability. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2019, 27(5): 1410-1418. |
张永亮, 张丽娟, 于铁峰, 等. 禾豆组合与间作方式对牧草产量及产量稳定性的影响. 草地学报, 2019, 27(5): 1410-1418. | |
18 | Wang P, Zhou D W, Zhang B T. Coexistence and inter-specific competition in grass-legume mixture. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2009, 29(5): 2560-2567. |
王平, 周道玮, 张宝田. 禾-豆混播草地种间竞争与共存. 生态学报, 2009, 29(5): 2560-2567. | |
19 | Sheng Y P, Zhao C Z, Gao F Y, et al. Interspecific competition between Avena sativa and Vicia vilosa in mixed sowing grassland in alpine mountainous region. Chinese Journal of Ecology, 2011, 30(11): 2437-2441. |
盛亚萍, 赵成章, 高福元, 等. 高寒山区混播草地燕麦和毛苕子种间的竞争关系. 生态学杂志, 2011, 30(11): 2437-2441. | |
20 | Fan J W, Zhong H P, Du Z C, et al. Competition of pasture plants. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2004, 13(3): 1-8. |
樊江文, 钟华平, 杜占池, 等. 草地植物竞争的研究. 草业学报, 2004, 13(3): 1-8. | |
21 | Dong S K, Hu Z Z. Research advancement on the stability of artificial grassland and the mechanisms of its maintenance. Grassland and Turf, 2000, 6(3): 3-8. |
董世魁, 胡自治. 人工草地群落稳定性及其调控机制研究现状. 草原与草坪, 2000, 6(3): 3-8. | |
22 | Grace J B. On the measurement of plant competition intensity. Ecology, 1995, 76(1): 305-308. |
23 | Zhang Y L, Gao K, Yu T F, et al. Effects of sowing patterns on productivity and interspecific relationship of alfalfa-grass mixture system. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2020, 42(2): 47-57. |
张永亮, 高凯, 于铁峰, 等. 禾草种类与混播比例对苜蓿-禾草混播系统生产力及种间关系的影响. 中国草地学报, 2020, 42(2): 47-57. | |
24 | Biligetu B, Jefferson P G, Muri R, et al. Late summer forage yield, nutritive value, compatibility of warm and cool-season grasses seeded with legumes in western Canada. Canadian Journal of Plant Science, 2014, 94(7): 1139-1148. |
25 | Ren Y Y, Wang X L, Zhang S Q, et al. Influence of spatial arrangement in maize-soybean intercropping on root growth and water use efficiency. Plant and Soil, 2017, 415(1/2): 131-144. |
26 | Grace J B. On the measurement of plant competition intensity. Ecology, 1995, 76(1): 305-308. |
27 | Weigelt A, Jolliffe P. Indices of plant competition. Journal of Ecology, 2003, 91(5): 707-720. |
28 | Yang C H, Li X L, Zhang X Q, et al. The dynamical studies on biomass and interspecific competition of limpograss and red clover mixture. Journal of Sichuan Agricultural University, 2006, 24(1): 32-36. |
杨春华, 李向林, 张新全, 等. 扁穗牛鞭草+红三叶混播草地生物量及种间竞争的动态研究. 四川农业大学学报, 2006, 24(1): 32-36. |
[1] | Xin-you WANG, Wen-xia CAO, Xiao-jun WANG, Yu-zhen LIU, Rui GAO, Shi-lin WANG, Hai-tao AN, Xiu-xia DENG, Wen-hu WANG. Herbage production and forage quality responses to cutting height and fertilization of legume-grass mixtures in the Hexi region [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(4): 99-110. |
[2] | ZHENG Wei, Jianaerguli, TANG Gaorong, ZHU Jinzhong. Determination and comparison of community stability in different legume-grass mixes [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(3): 155-167. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||