Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2024, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (12): 175-187.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2024109
Xu-ke ZHANG1(), Hong-fei XIA1, Guo-li CHEN1, De-zhou LI2, Xiao-wei ZHANG2, Ke-mei LI1(), Li-li WANG1()
Received:
2024-04-09
Revised:
2024-05-17
Online:
2024-12-20
Published:
2024-10-09
Contact:
Ke-mei LI,Li-li WANG
Xu-ke ZHANG, Hong-fei XIA, Guo-li CHEN, De-zhou LI, Xiao-wei ZHANG, Ke-mei LI, Li-li WANG. Identification and biological characterisation of Fusarium root rot pathogens of white clover[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(12): 175-187.
地点 Location | 尖孢镰 刀菌F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰 刀菌F. redolens | 燕麦镰 刀菌F. avenaceum | 木贼镰 刀菌F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|
乌鲁木齐市Urumqi | + | - | + | + |
三坪农场Sanping farm | - | - | + | + |
伊宁市Yining | + | + | + | + |
奎屯市Kuitun | + | - | + | - |
新源县Xinyuan | - | + | + | + |
塔城市Tacheng | - | - | + | + |
裕民县Yumin | - | - | + | + |
额敏县Emin | - | - | + | - |
和丰县Hefeng | - | - | + | + |
阿勒泰市Altay | - | - | + | + |
昌吉市Changji | + | - | + | - |
Table 1 Isolation of pathogenic bacteria in different sampling site
地点 Location | 尖孢镰 刀菌F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰 刀菌F. redolens | 燕麦镰 刀菌F. avenaceum | 木贼镰 刀菌F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|
乌鲁木齐市Urumqi | + | - | + | + |
三坪农场Sanping farm | - | - | + | + |
伊宁市Yining | + | + | + | + |
奎屯市Kuitun | + | - | + | - |
新源县Xinyuan | - | + | + | + |
塔城市Tacheng | - | - | + | + |
裕民县Yumin | - | - | + | + |
额敏县Emin | - | - | + | - |
和丰县Hefeng | - | - | + | + |
阿勒泰市Altay | - | - | + | + |
昌吉市Changji | + | - | + | - |
种名 Species | 菌株 Strains | GenBank登录号GenBank accession number | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
ITS | EF1-α | RPB2 | ||
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | NRRL 54939 | OL832320 | OL772892 | JX171663 |
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | YNSF16-66 | - | MK185024 | MK185026 |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | CBS 307.94 | KR071664 | KR071777 | KU604327 |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | MFG 70143 | - | OR634791 | OR727722 |
藤仓镰刀菌F. fujikuroi | CBS 130402 | KU604034 | KU711677 | KU604261 |
藤仓镰刀菌F. fujikuroi | CBS 221.76 | KR071666 | KU604440 | KU603884 |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | CBS 221.49 | - | MH484963 | MH484872 |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | CBS 132475 | KR071660 | KR071771 | KU604313 |
芬芳镰刀菌F. redolens | MFG 70140 | - | OR020714 | OR727752 |
接骨木镰刀菌F. sambucinum | CBS 146.95 | KM231813 | KM231941 | KM232381 |
茄腐镰刀菌F. solani | CBS 102429 | KM231808 | KM231936 | KM232376 |
向日葵链格孢A. helianthi | CBS 134020 | KC609340 | - | KC609352 |
Table 2 Strain information used to construct multi-gene phylogenetic tree
种名 Species | 菌株 Strains | GenBank登录号GenBank accession number | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
ITS | EF1-α | RPB2 | ||
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | NRRL 54939 | OL832320 | OL772892 | JX171663 |
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | YNSF16-66 | - | MK185024 | MK185026 |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | CBS 307.94 | KR071664 | KR071777 | KU604327 |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | MFG 70143 | - | OR634791 | OR727722 |
藤仓镰刀菌F. fujikuroi | CBS 130402 | KU604034 | KU711677 | KU604261 |
藤仓镰刀菌F. fujikuroi | CBS 221.76 | KR071666 | KU604440 | KU603884 |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | CBS 221.49 | - | MH484963 | MH484872 |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | CBS 132475 | KR071660 | KR071771 | KU604313 |
芬芳镰刀菌F. redolens | MFG 70140 | - | OR020714 | OR727752 |
接骨木镰刀菌F. sambucinum | CBS 146.95 | KM231813 | KM231941 | KM232381 |
茄腐镰刀菌F. solani | CBS 102429 | KM231808 | KM231936 | KM232376 |
向日葵链格孢A. helianthi | CBS 134020 | KC609340 | - | KC609352 |
处理 Treatment | 培养条件 Culture condition | 尖孢镰刀菌 F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰刀菌 F. redolens | 燕麦镰刀菌 F. avenaceum | 木贼镰刀菌 F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
温度 Temperature (℃) | 5 | 0.86±0.01e | 0.97±0.05e | 1.47±0.13c | 1.05±0.10f |
10 | 1.68±0.12d | 1.75±0.11d | 2.73±0.17b | 1.85±0.19e | |
15 | 2.76±0.14c | 2.15±0.22d | 4.26±0.31a | 2.49±0.18d | |
20 | 4.78±0.09b | 4.12±0.66b | 4.07±0.07a | 3.49±0.20c | |
25 | 6.82±0.75a | 6.24±0.19a | 3.97±0.94a | 6.17±0.33a | |
30 | 5.09±0.33b | 3.25±0.27c | 2.48±0.19b | 4.31±0.26b | |
35 | 0.98±0.06e | 1.62±0.05d | 1.01±0.01c | 1.00±0.08f | |
pH | 3 | 3.16±0.04e | 2.60±0.03f | 2.14±0.04e | 3.29±0.30e |
4 | 4.56±0.22d | 3.40±0.31e | 2.57±0.13d | 5.00±0.02d | |
5 | 5.58±0.20c | 4.23±0.55d | 3.08±0.03bc | 4.91±0.39d | |
6 | 6.05±0.58b | 5.35±0.30c | 3.36±0.11ab | 5.65±0.24c | |
7 | 6.24±0.17b | 6.05±0.12b | 3.68±0.35a | 6.21±0.11b | |
8 | 6.36±0.26b | 6.34±0.25ab | 3.51±0.13a | 6.74±0.53b | |
9 | 7.40±0.04a | 6.63±0.07a | 3.45±0.29a | 8.04±0.13a | |
10 | 7.26±0.05a | 6.51±0.03ab | 3.01±0.19c | 8.02±0.04a | |
11 | 7.27±0.14a | 6.34±0.10ab | 2.77±0.14cd | 7.94±0.51a | |
光照 Light | 全光照Full light | 6.21±0.10a | 5.81±0.19a | 3.66±0.49a | 4.70±0.79a |
全黑暗Full darkness | 6.48±0.21a | 5.32±0.20a | 3.42±0.37a | 4.10±0.76a | |
12 h光暗交替12 h dark/light | 6.05±0.64a | 5.71±0.36a | 3.32±0.28a | 5.20±0.26a | |
培养基 Media | 马铃薯葡萄糖琼脂Potato dextrose agar | 7.19±0.29a | 5.18±0.24bc | 5.68±0.22a | 4.51±0.89c |
马铃薯蔗糖琼脂Potato sucrose agar | 6.49±0.50bc | 5.07±0.26c | 4.94±0.19ab | 5.10±0.14bc | |
马铃薯胡萝卜琼脂Potato carrot agar | 6.42±0.28bc | 3.00±0.60e | 4.30±0.92b | 3.54±0.12d | |
水琼脂Water agar | 4.90±0.21d | 3.42±0.16e | 2.73±0.52c | 3.52±0.34d | |
玉米粉琼脂Corn meal agar | 5.26±0.18d | 4.47±0.05d | 4.25±0.21b | 5.51±0.23b | |
燕麦片琼脂Oatmeal agar | 6.54±0.23bc | 5.76±0.39b | 4.96±0.26ab | 7.19±0.12a | |
胡萝卜水琼脂Carrot agar | 6.20±0.31c | 5.43±0.40bc | 4.87±0.66ab | 3.56±0.21d | |
查氏培养基Czapek Dox agar | 6.80±0.70ab | 6.50±0.32a | 3.99±1.02b | 7.37±0.21a | |
碳源 Carbon source | 葡萄糖Glucose | 6.60±0.13bc | 6.17±0.31ab | 2.71±0.21bcd | 6.12±0.29b |
麦芽糖Maltose | 6.73±0.09bc | 6.33±0.35a | 3.41±0.62bc | 4.69±0.85de | |
乳糖Lactose | 7.01±0.18ab | 5.77±0.30abc | 2.35±0.31d | 4.00±0.54e | |
菊糖Inulin | 7.39±0.34a | 5.41±0.65bc | 4.55±1.25a | 5.05±0.96cd | |
D-果糖D-fructose | 6.42±0.13cd | 5.95±0.21abc | 2.65±0.21cd | 3.79±0.27e | |
甘露醇Mannitol | 6.60±0.16bc | 6.22±0.75a | 2.54±0.13cd | 7.25±0.25a | |
山梨醇Sorbitol | 6.67±0.28bc | 6.46±0.87a | 3.21±0.22bcd | 6.21±0.20b | |
可溶性淀粉Amylogen | 5.92±0.49e | 5.34±0.12c | 3.21±0.17bcd | 5.29±0.04bcd | |
无碳Carbonless | 6.14±0.04de | 5.97±0.42abc | 3.66±0.12b | 5.70±0.29bc | |
氮源 Nitrogen source | 硫酸铵Ammonia sulfate | 5.94±0.18c | 5.81±0.38cd | 1.75±0.35e | 5.40±0.15e |
氯化铵Ammonium chloride | 5.85±0.11c | 5.79±0.35cd | 1.78±0.20e | 5.52±0.13de | |
蛋白胨Peptone | 6.87±0.10ab | 6.10±0.04abc | 4.65±0.68a | 7.66±0.12a | |
牛肉膏Beef extract | 6.95±0.12a | 6.37±0.02a | 3.67±0.69bc | 7.52±0.36a | |
酵母浸粉Yeast extract | 6.71±0.37ab | 6.14±0.17abc | 2.88±0.21d | 6.99±0.24b | |
甘氨酸Glycine | 6.48±0.09b | 5.89±0.11bcd | 3.00±0.15cd | 5.77±0.26d | |
苯丙氨酸Phenylalanine | 5.86±0.16c | 5.63±0.16d | 3.44±0.21bcd | 4.49±0.17f | |
硝酸钾Potassium nitrate | 6.50±0.27b | 5.83±0.29cd | 3.04±0.67cd | 6.43±0.13c | |
无氮Nitrogen free | 6.83±0.13ab | 6.25±0.14ab | 4.01±0.08ab | 7.14±0.03b |
Table 3 The colony growth diameter of four Fusarium species in different culture conditions (cm)
处理 Treatment | 培养条件 Culture condition | 尖孢镰刀菌 F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰刀菌 F. redolens | 燕麦镰刀菌 F. avenaceum | 木贼镰刀菌 F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
温度 Temperature (℃) | 5 | 0.86±0.01e | 0.97±0.05e | 1.47±0.13c | 1.05±0.10f |
10 | 1.68±0.12d | 1.75±0.11d | 2.73±0.17b | 1.85±0.19e | |
15 | 2.76±0.14c | 2.15±0.22d | 4.26±0.31a | 2.49±0.18d | |
20 | 4.78±0.09b | 4.12±0.66b | 4.07±0.07a | 3.49±0.20c | |
25 | 6.82±0.75a | 6.24±0.19a | 3.97±0.94a | 6.17±0.33a | |
30 | 5.09±0.33b | 3.25±0.27c | 2.48±0.19b | 4.31±0.26b | |
35 | 0.98±0.06e | 1.62±0.05d | 1.01±0.01c | 1.00±0.08f | |
pH | 3 | 3.16±0.04e | 2.60±0.03f | 2.14±0.04e | 3.29±0.30e |
4 | 4.56±0.22d | 3.40±0.31e | 2.57±0.13d | 5.00±0.02d | |
5 | 5.58±0.20c | 4.23±0.55d | 3.08±0.03bc | 4.91±0.39d | |
6 | 6.05±0.58b | 5.35±0.30c | 3.36±0.11ab | 5.65±0.24c | |
7 | 6.24±0.17b | 6.05±0.12b | 3.68±0.35a | 6.21±0.11b | |
8 | 6.36±0.26b | 6.34±0.25ab | 3.51±0.13a | 6.74±0.53b | |
9 | 7.40±0.04a | 6.63±0.07a | 3.45±0.29a | 8.04±0.13a | |
10 | 7.26±0.05a | 6.51±0.03ab | 3.01±0.19c | 8.02±0.04a | |
11 | 7.27±0.14a | 6.34±0.10ab | 2.77±0.14cd | 7.94±0.51a | |
光照 Light | 全光照Full light | 6.21±0.10a | 5.81±0.19a | 3.66±0.49a | 4.70±0.79a |
全黑暗Full darkness | 6.48±0.21a | 5.32±0.20a | 3.42±0.37a | 4.10±0.76a | |
12 h光暗交替12 h dark/light | 6.05±0.64a | 5.71±0.36a | 3.32±0.28a | 5.20±0.26a | |
培养基 Media | 马铃薯葡萄糖琼脂Potato dextrose agar | 7.19±0.29a | 5.18±0.24bc | 5.68±0.22a | 4.51±0.89c |
马铃薯蔗糖琼脂Potato sucrose agar | 6.49±0.50bc | 5.07±0.26c | 4.94±0.19ab | 5.10±0.14bc | |
马铃薯胡萝卜琼脂Potato carrot agar | 6.42±0.28bc | 3.00±0.60e | 4.30±0.92b | 3.54±0.12d | |
水琼脂Water agar | 4.90±0.21d | 3.42±0.16e | 2.73±0.52c | 3.52±0.34d | |
玉米粉琼脂Corn meal agar | 5.26±0.18d | 4.47±0.05d | 4.25±0.21b | 5.51±0.23b | |
燕麦片琼脂Oatmeal agar | 6.54±0.23bc | 5.76±0.39b | 4.96±0.26ab | 7.19±0.12a | |
胡萝卜水琼脂Carrot agar | 6.20±0.31c | 5.43±0.40bc | 4.87±0.66ab | 3.56±0.21d | |
查氏培养基Czapek Dox agar | 6.80±0.70ab | 6.50±0.32a | 3.99±1.02b | 7.37±0.21a | |
碳源 Carbon source | 葡萄糖Glucose | 6.60±0.13bc | 6.17±0.31ab | 2.71±0.21bcd | 6.12±0.29b |
麦芽糖Maltose | 6.73±0.09bc | 6.33±0.35a | 3.41±0.62bc | 4.69±0.85de | |
乳糖Lactose | 7.01±0.18ab | 5.77±0.30abc | 2.35±0.31d | 4.00±0.54e | |
菊糖Inulin | 7.39±0.34a | 5.41±0.65bc | 4.55±1.25a | 5.05±0.96cd | |
D-果糖D-fructose | 6.42±0.13cd | 5.95±0.21abc | 2.65±0.21cd | 3.79±0.27e | |
甘露醇Mannitol | 6.60±0.16bc | 6.22±0.75a | 2.54±0.13cd | 7.25±0.25a | |
山梨醇Sorbitol | 6.67±0.28bc | 6.46±0.87a | 3.21±0.22bcd | 6.21±0.20b | |
可溶性淀粉Amylogen | 5.92±0.49e | 5.34±0.12c | 3.21±0.17bcd | 5.29±0.04bcd | |
无碳Carbonless | 6.14±0.04de | 5.97±0.42abc | 3.66±0.12b | 5.70±0.29bc | |
氮源 Nitrogen source | 硫酸铵Ammonia sulfate | 5.94±0.18c | 5.81±0.38cd | 1.75±0.35e | 5.40±0.15e |
氯化铵Ammonium chloride | 5.85±0.11c | 5.79±0.35cd | 1.78±0.20e | 5.52±0.13de | |
蛋白胨Peptone | 6.87±0.10ab | 6.10±0.04abc | 4.65±0.68a | 7.66±0.12a | |
牛肉膏Beef extract | 6.95±0.12a | 6.37±0.02a | 3.67±0.69bc | 7.52±0.36a | |
酵母浸粉Yeast extract | 6.71±0.37ab | 6.14±0.17abc | 2.88±0.21d | 6.99±0.24b | |
甘氨酸Glycine | 6.48±0.09b | 5.89±0.11bcd | 3.00±0.15cd | 5.77±0.26d | |
苯丙氨酸Phenylalanine | 5.86±0.16c | 5.63±0.16d | 3.44±0.21bcd | 4.49±0.17f | |
硝酸钾Potassium nitrate | 6.50±0.27b | 5.83±0.29cd | 3.04±0.67cd | 6.43±0.13c | |
无氮Nitrogen free | 6.83±0.13ab | 6.25±0.14ab | 4.01±0.08ab | 7.14±0.03b |
处理 Treatment | 培养条件 Culture condition | 尖孢镰刀菌 F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰刀菌 F. redolens | 燕麦镰刀菌 F. avenaceum | 木贼镰刀菌 F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
温度 Temperature (℃) | 5 | 0.83±0.88d | 0.03±0.06d | 0.05±0.05b | 0.17±0.29bc |
10 | 0.88±0.10d | 6.50±1.09c | 0.00±0.00b | 0.00±0.00c | |
15 | 3.28±0.62d | 9.93±3.78c | 0.00±0.00b | 0.00±0.00c | |
20 | 11.40±2.72c | 18.03±7.63b | 0.10±0.00b | 0.17±0.08bc | |
25 | 39.77±4.42a | 9.30±1.69c | 2.33±1.27b | 0.95±0.05b | |
30 | 30.20±5.98b | 25.33±3.15a | 10.48±5.13a | 0.13±0.23bc | |
35 | 4.10±0.13d | 3.97±0.50cd | 0.05±0.09b | 2.63±1.16a | |
pH | 3 | 27.35±5.80bc | 31.93±5.13ab | 0.18±0.10a | 0.00±0.00b |
4 | 15.87±4.10cde | 31.44±1.14ab | 0.10±0.09ab | 0.25±0.15b | |
5 | 21.70±1.50cd | 26.10±3.83bc | 0.00±0.00b | 0.32±0.06b | |
6 | 50.63±6.67a | 23.18±9.46cd | 0.07±0.03b | 1.20±0.48b | |
7 | 33.18±3.23b | 37.38±2.05a | 0.05±0.05b | 0.32±0.13b | |
8 | 21.37±9.53cd | 24.05±1.99cd | 0.02±0.03b | 8.52±3.61a | |
9 | 36.10±12.12b | 18.20±2.99d | 0.08±0.06b | 0.57±0.29b | |
10 | 12.36±2.87ef | 3.83±0.57e | 0.00±0.00b | 0.83±0.98b | |
11 | 7.13±0.96f | 1.19±0.84e | 0.00±0.00b | 0.23±0.08b | |
光照 Light | 全光照Full light | 21.98±3.10c | 7.55±0.94b | 1.73±0.87a | 1.10±0.92a |
全黑暗Full darkness | 44.88±3.70b | 7.07±1.34b | 1.80±0.77a | 0.58±0.06a | |
12 h光暗交替12 h dark/light | 54.08±1.68a | 26.60±7.13a | 0.68±0.58a | 1.90±0.65a | |
培养基 Media | 马铃薯葡萄糖琼脂Potato dextrose agar | 39.37±2.18a | 20.42±3.12a | 1.24±0.39cd | 0.22±0.08bc |
马铃薯蔗糖琼脂Potato sucrose agar | 43.01±6.91a | 22.90±4.91a | 1.77±1.25bc | 0.08±0.03c | |
马铃薯胡萝卜琼脂Potato carrot agar | 3.80±0.77c | 0.43±0.16b | 0.15±0.13cd | 0.27±0.12bc | |
水琼脂Water agar | 0.50±0.25c | 0.43±0.30b | 0.00±0.00d | 0.18±0.08bc | |
玉米粉琼脂Corn meal agar | 41.83±2.96a | 18.93±3.45a | 1.35±0.33bcd | 3.08±0.73a | |
燕麦片琼脂Oatmeal agar | 16.32±0.48b | 4.07±0.38b | 4.87±1.11a | 0.63±0.25b | |
胡萝卜水琼脂Carrot agar | 1.62±0.90c | 1.10±0.79b | 0.03±0.06d | 0.00±0.00c | |
查氏培养基Czapek Dox agar | 12.77±2.57b | 1.17±0.59b | 2.92±1.76b | 0.00±0.00c | |
碳源 Carbon source | 葡萄糖Glucose | 17.08±5.06a | 3.73±1.28a | 10.27±7.01b | 0.08±0.03b |
麦芽糖Maltose | 11.12±1.49bcd | 4.16±0.88a | 0.85±0.87d | 0.22±0.10b | |
乳糖Lactose | 14.48±3.21ab | 0.30±0.04e | 1.72±0.56cd | 0.13±0.06b | |
菊糖Inulin | 6.90±1.22d | 2.43±0.88bc | 6.82±2.19bc | 0.07±0.06b | |
D-果糖D-fructose | 12.67±2.67abc | 1.58±0.26cd | 2.22±1.92cd | 0.05±0.00b | |
甘露醇Mannitol | 10.95±0.71bcd | 1.10±0.66de | 0.05±0.09d | 0.08±0.08b | |
山梨醇Sorbitol | 8.73±0.97cd | 1.65±0.48cd | 19.23±3.81a | 0.05±0.05b | |
可溶性淀粉Amylogen | 15.47±5.39ab | 3.28±0.35ab | 0.00±0.00d | 0.45±0.26a | |
无碳Carbonless | 7.47±0.76cd | 0.15±0.05e | 0.37±0.25d | 0.13±0.08b | |
氮源 Nitrogen source | 硫酸铵Ammonia sulfate | 5.40±2.13def | 5.20±0.28b | 0.05±0.05c | 0.00±0.00b |
氯化铵Ammonium chloride | 3.65±0.30ef | 1.68±0.84b | 0.05±0.09c | 0.00±0.00b | |
蛋白胨Peptone | 0.50±0.46f | 3.35±2.14b | 4.41±0.98b | 0.15±0.26b | |
牛肉膏Beef extract | 13.67±2.12c | 4.43±1.58b | 5.55±0.61b | 0.22±0.38b | |
酵母浸粉Yeast extract | 10.25±2.34cd | 17.35±7.39a | 0.00±0.00c | 0.82±0.64a | |
甘氨酸Glycine | 5.82±0.60de | 0.82±0.66b | 0.27±0.03c | 0.25±0.05b | |
苯丙氨酸Phenylalanine | 3.47±1.01ef | 15.23±5.65a | 0.00±0.00c | 0.10±0.13b | |
硝酸钾Potassium nitrate | 32.93±6.46a | 0.83±0.23b | 29.38±6.28a | 0.34±0.53ab | |
无氮Nitrogen free | 1.08±0.29ef | 0.55±0.22b | 0.12±0.20c | 0.17±0.12b |
Table 4 The sporulation of four Fusarium species in different culture conditions (×106 spore·mL-1)
处理 Treatment | 培养条件 Culture condition | 尖孢镰刀菌 F. oxysporum | 芬芳镰刀菌 F. redolens | 燕麦镰刀菌 F. avenaceum | 木贼镰刀菌 F. equiseti |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
温度 Temperature (℃) | 5 | 0.83±0.88d | 0.03±0.06d | 0.05±0.05b | 0.17±0.29bc |
10 | 0.88±0.10d | 6.50±1.09c | 0.00±0.00b | 0.00±0.00c | |
15 | 3.28±0.62d | 9.93±3.78c | 0.00±0.00b | 0.00±0.00c | |
20 | 11.40±2.72c | 18.03±7.63b | 0.10±0.00b | 0.17±0.08bc | |
25 | 39.77±4.42a | 9.30±1.69c | 2.33±1.27b | 0.95±0.05b | |
30 | 30.20±5.98b | 25.33±3.15a | 10.48±5.13a | 0.13±0.23bc | |
35 | 4.10±0.13d | 3.97±0.50cd | 0.05±0.09b | 2.63±1.16a | |
pH | 3 | 27.35±5.80bc | 31.93±5.13ab | 0.18±0.10a | 0.00±0.00b |
4 | 15.87±4.10cde | 31.44±1.14ab | 0.10±0.09ab | 0.25±0.15b | |
5 | 21.70±1.50cd | 26.10±3.83bc | 0.00±0.00b | 0.32±0.06b | |
6 | 50.63±6.67a | 23.18±9.46cd | 0.07±0.03b | 1.20±0.48b | |
7 | 33.18±3.23b | 37.38±2.05a | 0.05±0.05b | 0.32±0.13b | |
8 | 21.37±9.53cd | 24.05±1.99cd | 0.02±0.03b | 8.52±3.61a | |
9 | 36.10±12.12b | 18.20±2.99d | 0.08±0.06b | 0.57±0.29b | |
10 | 12.36±2.87ef | 3.83±0.57e | 0.00±0.00b | 0.83±0.98b | |
11 | 7.13±0.96f | 1.19±0.84e | 0.00±0.00b | 0.23±0.08b | |
光照 Light | 全光照Full light | 21.98±3.10c | 7.55±0.94b | 1.73±0.87a | 1.10±0.92a |
全黑暗Full darkness | 44.88±3.70b | 7.07±1.34b | 1.80±0.77a | 0.58±0.06a | |
12 h光暗交替12 h dark/light | 54.08±1.68a | 26.60±7.13a | 0.68±0.58a | 1.90±0.65a | |
培养基 Media | 马铃薯葡萄糖琼脂Potato dextrose agar | 39.37±2.18a | 20.42±3.12a | 1.24±0.39cd | 0.22±0.08bc |
马铃薯蔗糖琼脂Potato sucrose agar | 43.01±6.91a | 22.90±4.91a | 1.77±1.25bc | 0.08±0.03c | |
马铃薯胡萝卜琼脂Potato carrot agar | 3.80±0.77c | 0.43±0.16b | 0.15±0.13cd | 0.27±0.12bc | |
水琼脂Water agar | 0.50±0.25c | 0.43±0.30b | 0.00±0.00d | 0.18±0.08bc | |
玉米粉琼脂Corn meal agar | 41.83±2.96a | 18.93±3.45a | 1.35±0.33bcd | 3.08±0.73a | |
燕麦片琼脂Oatmeal agar | 16.32±0.48b | 4.07±0.38b | 4.87±1.11a | 0.63±0.25b | |
胡萝卜水琼脂Carrot agar | 1.62±0.90c | 1.10±0.79b | 0.03±0.06d | 0.00±0.00c | |
查氏培养基Czapek Dox agar | 12.77±2.57b | 1.17±0.59b | 2.92±1.76b | 0.00±0.00c | |
碳源 Carbon source | 葡萄糖Glucose | 17.08±5.06a | 3.73±1.28a | 10.27±7.01b | 0.08±0.03b |
麦芽糖Maltose | 11.12±1.49bcd | 4.16±0.88a | 0.85±0.87d | 0.22±0.10b | |
乳糖Lactose | 14.48±3.21ab | 0.30±0.04e | 1.72±0.56cd | 0.13±0.06b | |
菊糖Inulin | 6.90±1.22d | 2.43±0.88bc | 6.82±2.19bc | 0.07±0.06b | |
D-果糖D-fructose | 12.67±2.67abc | 1.58±0.26cd | 2.22±1.92cd | 0.05±0.00b | |
甘露醇Mannitol | 10.95±0.71bcd | 1.10±0.66de | 0.05±0.09d | 0.08±0.08b | |
山梨醇Sorbitol | 8.73±0.97cd | 1.65±0.48cd | 19.23±3.81a | 0.05±0.05b | |
可溶性淀粉Amylogen | 15.47±5.39ab | 3.28±0.35ab | 0.00±0.00d | 0.45±0.26a | |
无碳Carbonless | 7.47±0.76cd | 0.15±0.05e | 0.37±0.25d | 0.13±0.08b | |
氮源 Nitrogen source | 硫酸铵Ammonia sulfate | 5.40±2.13def | 5.20±0.28b | 0.05±0.05c | 0.00±0.00b |
氯化铵Ammonium chloride | 3.65±0.30ef | 1.68±0.84b | 0.05±0.09c | 0.00±0.00b | |
蛋白胨Peptone | 0.50±0.46f | 3.35±2.14b | 4.41±0.98b | 0.15±0.26b | |
牛肉膏Beef extract | 13.67±2.12c | 4.43±1.58b | 5.55±0.61b | 0.22±0.38b | |
酵母浸粉Yeast extract | 10.25±2.34cd | 17.35±7.39a | 0.00±0.00c | 0.82±0.64a | |
甘氨酸Glycine | 5.82±0.60de | 0.82±0.66b | 0.27±0.03c | 0.25±0.05b | |
苯丙氨酸Phenylalanine | 3.47±1.01ef | 15.23±5.65a | 0.00±0.00c | 0.10±0.13b | |
硝酸钾Potassium nitrate | 32.93±6.46a | 0.83±0.23b | 29.38±6.28a | 0.34±0.53ab | |
无氮Nitrogen free | 1.08±0.29ef | 0.55±0.22b | 0.12±0.20c | 0.17±0.12b |
菌株 Strain | 温度Temperature | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
45 ℃ | 50 ℃ | 51 ℃ | 52 ℃ | 53 ℃ | 54 ℃ | 55 ℃ | 60 ℃ | 61 ℃ | 62 ℃ | 63 ℃ | 64 ℃ | |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | - |
芬芳镰刀菌F. redolens | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | - |
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | + | + | + | + | + | + | - | - | - | - | - | - |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | + | + | + | + | + | + | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Table 5 The lethal temperature of 4 kinds of Fusarium mycelium
菌株 Strain | 温度Temperature | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
45 ℃ | 50 ℃ | 51 ℃ | 52 ℃ | 53 ℃ | 54 ℃ | 55 ℃ | 60 ℃ | 61 ℃ | 62 ℃ | 63 ℃ | 64 ℃ | |
尖孢镰刀菌F. oxysporum | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | - |
芬芳镰刀菌F. redolens | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | + | - |
燕麦镰刀菌F. avenaceum | + | + | + | + | + | + | - | - | - | - | - | - |
木贼镰刀菌F. equiseti | + | + | + | + | + | + | - | - | - | - | - | - |
1 | Zhao G Q, Wang S M, Ren J Z. Research progress on genetic transformation and ecological adaptability in white clover. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2004, 24(3): 592-598. |
赵桂琴, 王锁民, 任继周. 白三叶转基因及其生态适应性研究进展. 生态学报, 2004, 24(3): 592-598. | |
2 | Nan Z B. Leguminous root rot. Animal Science Abroad-Grassland and Forage Grass, 1991(2): 5-11. |
南志标. 豆科牧草根腐病. 国外畜牧学-草原与牧草, 1991(2): 5-11. | |
3 | Skipp R A, Christensen M J, Biao N Z. Invasion of red clover (Trifolium pratense) roots by soilborne fungi. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 1986, 29(2): 305-313. |
4 | Gong G S, Xu Q, Zhang M, et al. A simple method for single fungal spore isolation. Journal of Maize Sciences, 2010, 18(1): 126-127, 134. |
龚国淑, 徐琴, 张敏, 等. 一种简便的病原真菌单孢分离方法研究. 玉米科学, 2010, 18(1): 126-127, 134. | |
5 | Wang G C, Zheng Z, Ye Q M, et al. Guidelines for identification of common Fusarium. Beijing: China Agricultural Science and Technology Press, 1996. |
王拱辰, 郑重, 叶琪明, 等. 常见镰刀菌鉴定指南. 北京: 中国农业科技出版社, 1996. | |
6 | Yi R H, Zhu X R, Zhou E X. Simplified CTAB method for rapid micro-extraction of filamentous fungal DNA. Journal of Zhanjiang Ocean University, 2003, 23(6): 72-73. |
易润华, 朱西儒, 周而勋. 简化CTAB法快速微量提取丝状真菌DNA. 湛江海洋大学学报, 2003, 23(6): 72-73. | |
7 | White T J, Bruns T, Lee S, et al. Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics//PCR protocols. New York: Academic Press, 1990: 315-322. |
8 | Jaklitsch W M, Komon M, Kubicek C P, et al. Hypocrea voglmayrii sp. nov. from the Austrian Alps represents a new phylogenetic clade in Hypocrea/Trichoderma. Mycologia, 2005, 97(6): 1365-1378. |
9 | O’Donnell K, Sarver B A J, Brandt M, et al. Phylogenetic diversity and microsphere array-based genotyping of human pathogenic Fusaria, including isolates from the multistate contact lens-associated US keratitis outbreaks of 2005 and 2006. Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 2007, 45(7): 2235-2248. |
10 | Fang X L, Zhang C X, Nan Z B. Research advances in Fusarium root rot of alfalfa (Medicago sativa). Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(12): 169-183. |
方香玲, 张彩霞, 南志标. 紫花苜蓿镰刀菌根腐病研究进展. 草业学报, 2019, 28(12): 169-183. | |
11 | Zhang L L, Luo T, Li Y Z. Identification and biological characteristics of Colletotrichum americae-borealis causing alfalfa anthracnose in Heilongjiang. Pratacultural Science, 2020, 37(10): 2057-2068. |
张梨梨, 罗庭, 李彦忠. 黑龙江苜蓿炭疽病病原鉴定及其生物学特性. 草业科学, 2020, 37(10): 2057-2068. | |
12 | Pan L Q, Zhang L, Yang C D, et al. Identification and biological characteristics of Fusarium sporotrichioide isolated from Medicago sativa root. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(10): 88-98. |
潘龙其, 张丽, 杨成德, 等. 紫花苜蓿根腐病原菌拟枝孢镰刀菌的鉴定及其生物学特性研究. 草业学报, 2015, 24(10): 88-98. | |
13 | Wang H F. Study on pathogens of alfalfa root rot in Yunnan Province. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2020. |
王慧菲. 云南省紫花苜蓿根腐病病原的研究. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2020. | |
14 | Wang L, Zhang Y Y, Wang N, et al. Colonial growth and sporulation conditions of 12 Fusarium spp. in alfalfa. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2023, 45(6): 103-116. |
王乐, 张园园, 王娜, 等. 紫花苜蓿12种镰刀菌的菌落生长和产孢条件. 中国草地学报, 2023, 45(6): 103-116. | |
15 | Nursimangul·A, Aigoamarie·A, Sun Y M, et al. Identification and biological characteristics of the pathogens causing marigold wilt in Xinjiang. Acta Horticulturae Sinica, 2023, 50(12): 2723-2734. |
努尔斯曼姑丽·艾海提, 阿依加玛丽·阿卜杜扎伊尔, 孙永民, 等. 新疆万寿菊枯萎病病原菌鉴定及生物学特性研究. 园艺学报, 2023, 50(12): 2723-2734. | |
16 | Xu X F, Li H X, Ni C H, et al. Molecular biological identification and regional distribution of pathogens causing root rot of Codonopsis pilosula in Gansu Province. Plant Protection, 2022, 48(2): 130-138. |
徐雪芬, 李惠霞, 倪春辉, 等. 甘肃省党参根腐病菌的分子生物学鉴定及区域分布. 植物保护, 2022, 48(2): 130-138. | |
17 | Charest P M, Ouellette G B, Pauzé F J. Cytological observations of early infection process by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. radicis-lycopersici in tomato plants. Canadian Journal of Botany, 1984, 62(6): 1232-1244. |
18 | Dong W Z, Xu F, Yang X M, et al. Identification and characterization of the pathogen causing stem rot of bearded iris Iris germanica. Journal of Plant Protection, 2022, 49(3): 917-926. |
董文志, 许凤, 杨秀梅, 等. 德国鸢尾茎基腐病病原菌鉴定及生物学特性分析. 植物保护学报, 2022, 49(3): 917-926. | |
19 | Gai X T, Lu C H, Hu Y X, et al. Identification of pathogens causing tobacco Fusarium root rot in Yunnan tobacco. Acta Tabacaria Sinica, 2023, 29(3): 74-83. |
盖晓彤, 卢灿华, 户艳霞, 等. 云南省烟草镰刀菌根腐病病原鉴定. 中国烟草学报, 2023, 29(3): 74-83. | |
20 | Li J Q, Li C Q. Microscopic and ultrastructural characteristics of the root of Potentilla anserine infected by Fusarium avenaceum. Acta Phytopathologica Sinica, 2023, 53(5): 841-851. |
李军乔, 李晨芹. 燕麦镰刀菌侵染蕨麻根部的显微及超微结构观察. 植物病理学报, 2023, 53(5): 841-851. | |
21 | Cao X, Liu N N, Hu Y P, et al. Identification and biological characteristics of the pathogen of lily bulb rot disease. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2018, 47(12): 96-101. |
曹兴, 刘南南, 胡燕佩, 等. 百合鳞茎腐烂病病原菌的鉴定及生物学特性研究. 河南农业科学, 2018, 47(12): 96-101. | |
22 | Kong Q Q, Ruan L, Liu D X, et al. Biological characteristics of Fusarium causing alfalfa root rot in Hebei Province. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2018, 23(8): 59-76. |
孔前前, 阮柳, 刘东霞, 等. 河北苜蓿镰孢菌根腐病病原生物学特性研究. 中国农业大学学报, 2018, 23(8): 59-76. | |
23 | Bi W, Zhou J M, Huang Y N, et al. Biological characterization and pathogen identification of Polygonatum odoratum root rot in Hunan, China. Modern Chinese Medicine, 2014, 16(2): 133-137. |
毕武, 周佳民, 黄艳宁, 等. 湖南地区玉竹根腐病病原鉴定及其生物学特性研究. 中国现代中药, 2014, 16(2): 133-137. | |
24 | Niu S Q, Zhang X Y, Li J, et al. Isolation, identification and biological characteristics of the pathogens of Angelica sinensis root rot in Minxian County. Journal of Northwest Normal University (Natural Science), 2021, 57(1): 77-83. |
牛世全, 张雪莹, 李静, 等. 岷县当归根腐病病原菌的分离鉴定及生物学特性研究. 西北师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2021, 57(1): 77-83. | |
25 | Lu W J, Yin G F, Wang Y Q, et al. Identification and biological characteristics of pathogen causing stem blight of buckwheat in Yunnan Province. Southwest China Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 35(11): 2564-2570. |
卢文洁, 尹桂芳, 王艳青, 等. 云南省荞麦茎枯病病原鉴定及其生物学特性研究. 西南农业学报, 2022, 35(11): 2564-2570. |
[1] | Ya-jing MENG, Guo-qiang WU, Ming WEI. Genome-wide identification of the Beta vulgaris ABF (BvABF) gene family and analysis of the expression pattern in sugar beet under ABA treatment [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(9): 94-110. |
[2] | Xiao-lu ZOU, Wen-jing ZHANG, Hong LYU, Nan QIN, Xiao-jun ZHAO, Hui YIN, Lu REN. Biological characteristics and plant growth-promoting and biocontrol properties of endophytic bacterium ZJ1 from Buddleja lindleyana [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(5): 106-114. |
[3] | Hao LIU, Xian-yang LI, Fei HE, Xue WANG, Ming-na LI, Rui-cai LONG, Jun-mei KANG, Qing-chuan YANG, Lin CHEN. Identification of the alfalfa SAUR gene family and its expression pattern under abiotic stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(4): 135-153. |
[4] | Ping MU, Ji-kuan CHAI, Wei-juan SU, Hai-long ZHANG, Gui-qin ZHAO. Phenotype and genetic variation analysis of forward and reverse hybrid progeny from different oat crosses [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(4): 73-86. |
[5] | Xian-fei SHI, Yu GAO, Xu-sheng HUANG, Ya-li ZHOU, Gui-ping CAI, Xin-ru LI, Run-zhi LI, Jin-ai XUE. Functional characterization of Cyperus esculentus CeWRKY transcription factors in response to abiotic stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(8): 186-201. |
[6] | Jia-qi DONG, Yan-ting YANG, Wen-qiang FAN, Jia-ni WANG, Feng-ling SHI. Identification of Medicago ruthenica hybrids and heterosis analysis of main agronomic traits in F1 and F2 [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(7): 229-239. |
[7] | Yan-peng LI, Na WEI, Qing-yan ZHAI, Hang LI, Ji-yu ZHANG, Wen-xian LIU. Genome-wide identification of members of the TCP gene family in Melilotus albus and their expression patterns under drought stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(4): 101-111. |
[8] | Yan-lan ZHAO, Xin-yi ZENG, Jin-chao GONG, Xiang-jun LI, Xu-xu LI, Shan LIU, Xin-quan ZHANG, Ji-qiong ZHOU. Effect of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on the salt tolerance of Trifolium repens [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 179-188. |
[9] | Xue-meng WANG, Xin HE, Han ZHANG, Rui SONG, Pei-sheng MAO, Shan-gang JIA. Non-destructive identification of artificially aged alfalfa seeds using multispectral imaging analysis [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(7): 197-208. |
[10] | Chen-qin LI, Jun-qiao LI, Xin-ci WANG, Yong-kun NIU, Jun-ru QU. Isolation, identification, and biological characteristics of Fusarium perseae isolated from Potentilla anserina roots [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(4): 113-123. |
[11] | Li-juan GAO, Zheng-she ZHANG, Yu WEN, Xi-fang ZONG, Qi YAN, Li-yan LU, Xian-feng YI, Ji-yu ZHANG. Genome-wide identification and expression analysis of the bHLH transcription factor family in Cenchrus purpureus [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(3): 47-59. |
[12] | Guo-xiang ZHANG, Wei-leng GUO, Ming-yu BI, Li-shuang ZHANG, Dan WANG, Chang-hong GUO. Identification of CAX gene family and expression profile analysis of response to abiotic stress in alfalfa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(12): 106-117. |
[13] | Jing-jing JIANG, Hui DU, Ai-chang CHEN, Xue-ping LI, Min-quan LI, Yong-hong QI. Identification and biological characterization of the pathogens responsible for sclerotinia rot in Codonopsis pilosula [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(12): 181-190. |
[14] | Zi-li LI, Shang-li SHI, Yun A, Hui-hui ZHANG, Xiao-long LI. Identification and physiological study of variation in reproductive fertility in clonal lines of Medicago sativa cultivar ‘Qingshui’ [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(10): 135-144. |
[15] | Guo-fang WU, Xiao-xia YU, Zhuo YU, Dong-sheng YANG, Qian-qian LU. Screening and identification of target fragments with low cyanide traits of sorghum-sudangrass hybrid using BSA-SSR [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(7): 82-92. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||