Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2022, Vol. 31 ›› Issue (2): 133-146.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2020519
Yue-yang ZHANG1(), Fang LI1, Wei-wei LIANG2, Yan-zhong LI1()
Received:
2020-11-25
Revised:
2021-01-18
Online:
2022-02-20
Published:
2021-12-22
Contact:
Yan-zhong LI
Yue-yang ZHANG, Fang LI, Wei-wei LIANG, Yan-zhong LI. Disease resistance evaluation of 32 alfalfa varieties in Xinjiang[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(2): 133-146.
编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 生产国 Countries | 来源 Seeds sources | 千粒重 Thousand-grain-weight (g·thousand grains-1) | 播种量 Sowing rate (g·m-2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | WL343HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.59±0.03abc | 4.0 |
2 | WL354HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.87±0.04ab | 4.9 |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.08±0.03de | 2.1 |
4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.95±0.04de | 1.8 |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.96±0.04de | 1.7 |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 1.98±0.08de | 1.9 |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.22±0.09de | 2.2 |
8 | 前景Vision | 加拿大Canada | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.14±0.04de | 2.1 |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 1.80±0.04de | 1.6 |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.37±0.15de | 2.1 |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.12±0.05de | 1.9 |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baiqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development | 3.18±0.07bcde | 3.4 |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.43±0.18de | 2.1 |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baiqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development | 2.80±0.08cde | 2.7 |
15 | WL319 | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 3.96±0.02abcd | 3.8 |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.81±0.04de | 1.8 |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 1.81±0.08de | 1.8 |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 中国China | 内蒙古农业大学Inner Mongolia Agricultural University | 1.85±0.06de | 1.7 |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.81±0.08de | 1.6 |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.98±0.05de | 1.7 |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 美国America | 甘肃猛犸农业公司Gansu Mengma Agricultural Company | 1.82±0.08de | 1.7 |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.89±0.07de | 2.1 |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 中国China | 购自曹致中From CAO Zhi-zhong | 5.45±3.52a | 1.7 |
24 | WL363HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.87±0.04ab | 4.1 |
25 | WL168HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 3.94±0.04abcd | 3.9 |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 新疆农业大学Xinjiang Agricultural University | 2.23±0.04de | 2.0 |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.56±0.08e | 1.5 |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 2.00±0.04de | 1.8 |
29 | SR4030 | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.09±0.00de | 1.8 |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 中国China | 新疆农业大学Xinjiang Agricultural University | 1.78±0.07de | 1.5 |
31 | MF4020 | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.01±0.00de | 1.9 |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.13±0.01de | 2.1 |
Table 1 Alfalfa varieties, seeds sources, thousand-grain-weight and sowing rate
编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 生产国 Countries | 来源 Seeds sources | 千粒重 Thousand-grain-weight (g·thousand grains-1) | 播种量 Sowing rate (g·m-2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | WL343HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.59±0.03abc | 4.0 |
2 | WL354HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.87±0.04ab | 4.9 |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.08±0.03de | 2.1 |
4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.95±0.04de | 1.8 |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.96±0.04de | 1.7 |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 1.98±0.08de | 1.9 |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.22±0.09de | 2.2 |
8 | 前景Vision | 加拿大Canada | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.14±0.04de | 2.1 |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 1.80±0.04de | 1.6 |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.37±0.15de | 2.1 |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.12±0.05de | 1.9 |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baiqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development | 3.18±0.07bcde | 3.4 |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 美国America | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.43±0.18de | 2.1 |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baiqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development | 2.80±0.08cde | 2.7 |
15 | WL319 | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 3.96±0.02abcd | 3.8 |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.81±0.04de | 1.8 |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 1.81±0.08de | 1.8 |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 中国China | 内蒙古农业大学Inner Mongolia Agricultural University | 1.85±0.06de | 1.7 |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.81±0.08de | 1.6 |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.98±0.05de | 1.7 |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 美国America | 甘肃猛犸农业公司Gansu Mengma Agricultural Company | 1.82±0.08de | 1.7 |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 中国China | 中国农业科学院Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.89±0.07de | 2.1 |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 中国China | 购自曹致中From CAO Zhi-zhong | 5.45±3.52a | 1.7 |
24 | WL363HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 4.87±0.04ab | 4.1 |
25 | WL168HQ | 美国America | 北京正道公司Beijing Zhengdao Company | 3.94±0.04abcd | 3.9 |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 美国、加拿大America, Canada | 新疆农业大学Xinjiang Agricultural University | 2.23±0.04de | 2.0 |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 1.56±0.08e | 1.5 |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 中国China | 甘肃省农业科学院Gansu Academy of Agricultural Sciences | 2.00±0.04de | 1.8 |
29 | SR4030 | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.09±0.00de | 1.8 |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 中国China | 新疆农业大学Xinjiang Agricultural University | 1.78±0.07de | 1.5 |
31 | MF4020 | 加拿大Canada | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company | 2.01±0.00de | 1.9 |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 美国America | 北京百斯特公司Beijing Best Company | 2.13±0.01de | 2.1 |
抗病植株数 The disease-resistant plant (%) | 抗病级别 Resistance levels | 抗病级别缩写 Abbreviation for resistance levels |
---|---|---|
0~5 | 易感 Susceptible | S |
6~14 | 低抗 Low resistance | LR |
15~30 | 中抗 Medium resistance | MR |
31~50 | 抗性 Resistance | R |
>50 | 高抗 High resistance | HR |
Table 2 The standard of disease resistance levels
抗病植株数 The disease-resistant plant (%) | 抗病级别 Resistance levels | 抗病级别缩写 Abbreviation for resistance levels |
---|---|---|
0~5 | 易感 Susceptible | S |
6~14 | 低抗 Low resistance | LR |
15~30 | 中抗 Medium resistance | MR |
31~50 | 抗性 Resistance | R |
>50 | 高抗 High resistance | HR |
编号Number | 品种名 | 苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病 Alfalfa phoma leaf spot and black stem | 苜蓿白粉病 Alfalfa powdery mildew | 苜蓿黄斑病 Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | 2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | 2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | ||||||||
发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | ||
1 | WL343HQ | 54.46± 9.80abc | R | 97.08± 10.28a | S | 38.21± 13.21abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 16.90± 6.90a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
2 | WL354HQ | 32.14± 6.91abc | HR | 41.67± 24.06abcdef | HR | 8.33± 8.33d | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 17.14± 6.06a | HR | 4.17± 4.17a | HR |
3 | 北极熊 Polar bear | 25.89± 10.25abc | HR | 13.57± 9.43f | HR | 20.71± 11.97abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 14.17± 9.46a | HR | 15.00± 15.00a | HR |
4 | 甘农5号 Gannong No.5 | 65.77± 17.56ab | R | 50.83± 17.81abcdef | R | 7.74± 4.49d | HR | 97.08± 10.28a | S | 15.48± 8.99a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
5 | 甘农9号 Gannong No.9 | 71.13± 11.79a | MR | 29.58± 12.37cdef | HR | 50.71± 10.80abcd | R | 79.11± 22.54a | MR | 11.90± 7.90a | HR | 6.25± 6.25a | HR |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 3.57± 3.57c | HR | 67.86± 23.60abcdef | R | 17.14± 10.17bcd | HR | 98.48± 10.95a | S | 39.05± 16.45a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 64.88± 12.72ab | R | 53.04± 18.35abcdef | R | 19.17± 8.21abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 37.08± 15.37a | HR | 5.21± 3.13a | HR |
8 | 前景Vision | 54.46± 9.80abc | R | 41.96± 15.59abcdef | HR | 19.29± 13.47abcd | HR | 50.00± 28.87a | R | 48.81± 8.81a | HR | 7.14± 7.14a | HR |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 49.70± 16.96abc | HR | 83.04± 10.45abcd | MR | 48.04± 16.48abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 33.81± 13.81a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 37.50± 23.94abc | HR | 24.11± 16.84def | HR | 25.89± 10.25abcd | HR | 80.36± 34.15a | MR | 20.71± 11.97a | HR | 4.55± 4.55a | HR |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 12.50±1 2.50c | HR | 35.12± 20.97abcdef | HR | 20.71± 11.97abcd | HR | 74.11± 27.02a | MR | 22.50± 13.15a | HR | 9.62± 9.62a | HR |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 4.17± 4.17c | HR | 33.75± 19.72abcdef | HR | 34.23± 15.46abcd | HR | 96.19± 13.75a | S | 23.81± 15.79a | HR | 5.56± 5.56a | HR |
13 | 耐盐之星 Salt-tolerant star | 37.50± 14.23abc | HR | 70.24± 20.24abcdef | MR | 10.71± 10.71d | HR | 72.62± 16.54a | MR | 39.05± 8.41a | HR | 25.00± 15.00a | HR |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 46.73± 14.23abc | HR | 48.33± 13.23abcdef | HR | 10.00± 10.00d | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 48.57± 18.18a | HR | 5.43± 5.43a | HR |
15 | WL319 | 47.92± 16.80abc | HR | 92.86± 7.14abc | LR | 52.08± 9.51abcd | R | 84.52± 8.99a | MR | 19.58± 7.08a | HR | 5.21± 5.21a | HR |
16 | 甘农6号 Gannong No.6 | 25.00± 14.43abc | HR | 18.33± 10.67ef | HR | 41.07± 19.80abcd | HR | 92.08± 13.70a | LR | 37.14± 21.79a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
17 | 阿尔冈金 Algonquin | 25.00± 14.43abc | HR | 37.86± 21.93abcdef | HR | 61.79± 13.21a | R | 90.00± 10.00a | LR | 41.67± 15.00a | HR | 4.90± 4.90a | HR |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿 Aohan | 37.50± 23.94abc | HR | 42.14± 21.04abcdef | HR | 49.46± 18.43abcd | HR | 75.00± 25.00a | MR | 30.48± 12.29a | HR | 25.20± 15.07a | HR |
19 | 中苜1号 Zhongmu No.1 | 20.83± 12.50abc | HR | 78.57± 23.74abcde | MR | 29.64± 10.81abcd | HR | 98.75± 11.25a | S | 34.58± 8.91a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
20 | 中苜3号 Zhongmu No.3 | 29.17± 17.18abc | HR | 48.81± 21.85abcdef | HR | 19.05± 11.17abcd | HR | 98.21± 19.37a | S | 50.48± 28.87a | R | 4.81± 4.81a | HR |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 14.58± 8.59bc | HR | 95.83± 4.17ab | S | 22.14± 14.30abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 29.29± 12.36a | HR | 10.00± 10.00a | HR |
22 | 公农5号 Gongnong No.5 | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 30.95± 17.98cdef | HR | 45.71± 10.52abcd | HR | 95.83± 4.17a | S | 32.14± 17.04a | HR | 5.00± 5.00a | HR |
23 | 陇东苜蓿 Longdong | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 20.83± 20.83def | HR | 61.31± 22.47ab | R | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 36.67± 17.80a | HR | 5.21± 5.21a | HR |
24 | WL363HQ | 19.64±1 2.16bc | HR | 64.29± 23.69abcdef | R | 16.96± 10.45bcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 38.81± 10.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
25 | WL168HQ | 3.57± 3.57c | HR | 13.57± 9.43f | HR | 43.04± 16.03abcd | HR | 95.00± 5.00a | S | 33.57± 22.54a | HR | 15.00± 9.57a | HR |
26 | 阿迪娜 Adrenalin | 3.87± 2.25c | HR | 61.07± 18.68abcdef | R | 12.14± 7.23cd | HR | 91.96± 17.40a | LR | 25.48± 8.81a | HR | 5.00± 5.00a | HR |
27 | 甘农4号 Gannong No.4 | 16.67± 16.67bc | HR | 40.00± 23.09abcdef | HR | 16.07± 5.92cd | HR | 70.00± 23.80a | MR | 50.42± 12.59a | R | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
28 | 甘农3号 Gannong No.3 | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 18.57± 14.21ef | HR | 7.14± 7.14d | HR | 86.61± 7.77a | LR | 49.29± 20.71a | HR | 10.71± 10.71a | HR |
29 | SR4030 | 37.80± 15.43abc | HR | 38.69± 22.47abcdef | HR | 55.71± 22.02abc | R | 99.11± 10.95a | S | 26.67± 14.14a | HR | 14.71± 14.71a | HR |
30 | 新牧4号 Xinmu No.4 | 35.42± 22.15abc | HR | 59.29± 21.61abcdef | R | 16.90± 6.90bcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 38.81± 10.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
31 | MF4020 | 26.49± 14.34abc | HR | 50.89± 22.51abcdef | R | 12.50± 12.50cd | HR | 89.58± 6.25a | LR | 25.42± 5.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
32 | 冲击波 Shockwave | 27.38± 16.54abc | HR | 32.86±1 9.11bcdef | HR | 16.07± 11.80cd | HR | 85.00± 9.57a | MR | 57.14± 15.69a | R | 20.00±1 1.55a | HR |
Table 3 Disease rate and resistance levels of the tested alfalfa varieties
编号Number | 品种名 | 苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病 Alfalfa phoma leaf spot and black stem | 苜蓿白粉病 Alfalfa powdery mildew | 苜蓿黄斑病 Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | 2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | 2018年9月 | 2019年9月 | ||||||||
发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | 发病率 | 抗性级别 | ||
1 | WL343HQ | 54.46± 9.80abc | R | 97.08± 10.28a | S | 38.21± 13.21abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 16.90± 6.90a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
2 | WL354HQ | 32.14± 6.91abc | HR | 41.67± 24.06abcdef | HR | 8.33± 8.33d | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 17.14± 6.06a | HR | 4.17± 4.17a | HR |
3 | 北极熊 Polar bear | 25.89± 10.25abc | HR | 13.57± 9.43f | HR | 20.71± 11.97abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 14.17± 9.46a | HR | 15.00± 15.00a | HR |
4 | 甘农5号 Gannong No.5 | 65.77± 17.56ab | R | 50.83± 17.81abcdef | R | 7.74± 4.49d | HR | 97.08± 10.28a | S | 15.48± 8.99a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
5 | 甘农9号 Gannong No.9 | 71.13± 11.79a | MR | 29.58± 12.37cdef | HR | 50.71± 10.80abcd | R | 79.11± 22.54a | MR | 11.90± 7.90a | HR | 6.25± 6.25a | HR |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 3.57± 3.57c | HR | 67.86± 23.60abcdef | R | 17.14± 10.17bcd | HR | 98.48± 10.95a | S | 39.05± 16.45a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 64.88± 12.72ab | R | 53.04± 18.35abcdef | R | 19.17± 8.21abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 37.08± 15.37a | HR | 5.21± 3.13a | HR |
8 | 前景Vision | 54.46± 9.80abc | R | 41.96± 15.59abcdef | HR | 19.29± 13.47abcd | HR | 50.00± 28.87a | R | 48.81± 8.81a | HR | 7.14± 7.14a | HR |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 49.70± 16.96abc | HR | 83.04± 10.45abcd | MR | 48.04± 16.48abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 33.81± 13.81a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 37.50± 23.94abc | HR | 24.11± 16.84def | HR | 25.89± 10.25abcd | HR | 80.36± 34.15a | MR | 20.71± 11.97a | HR | 4.55± 4.55a | HR |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 12.50±1 2.50c | HR | 35.12± 20.97abcdef | HR | 20.71± 11.97abcd | HR | 74.11± 27.02a | MR | 22.50± 13.15a | HR | 9.62± 9.62a | HR |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 4.17± 4.17c | HR | 33.75± 19.72abcdef | HR | 34.23± 15.46abcd | HR | 96.19± 13.75a | S | 23.81± 15.79a | HR | 5.56± 5.56a | HR |
13 | 耐盐之星 Salt-tolerant star | 37.50± 14.23abc | HR | 70.24± 20.24abcdef | MR | 10.71± 10.71d | HR | 72.62± 16.54a | MR | 39.05± 8.41a | HR | 25.00± 15.00a | HR |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 46.73± 14.23abc | HR | 48.33± 13.23abcdef | HR | 10.00± 10.00d | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 48.57± 18.18a | HR | 5.43± 5.43a | HR |
15 | WL319 | 47.92± 16.80abc | HR | 92.86± 7.14abc | LR | 52.08± 9.51abcd | R | 84.52± 8.99a | MR | 19.58± 7.08a | HR | 5.21± 5.21a | HR |
16 | 甘农6号 Gannong No.6 | 25.00± 14.43abc | HR | 18.33± 10.67ef | HR | 41.07± 19.80abcd | HR | 92.08± 13.70a | LR | 37.14± 21.79a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
17 | 阿尔冈金 Algonquin | 25.00± 14.43abc | HR | 37.86± 21.93abcdef | HR | 61.79± 13.21a | R | 90.00± 10.00a | LR | 41.67± 15.00a | HR | 4.90± 4.90a | HR |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿 Aohan | 37.50± 23.94abc | HR | 42.14± 21.04abcdef | HR | 49.46± 18.43abcd | HR | 75.00± 25.00a | MR | 30.48± 12.29a | HR | 25.20± 15.07a | HR |
19 | 中苜1号 Zhongmu No.1 | 20.83± 12.50abc | HR | 78.57± 23.74abcde | MR | 29.64± 10.81abcd | HR | 98.75± 11.25a | S | 34.58± 8.91a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
20 | 中苜3号 Zhongmu No.3 | 29.17± 17.18abc | HR | 48.81± 21.85abcdef | HR | 19.05± 11.17abcd | HR | 98.21± 19.37a | S | 50.48± 28.87a | R | 4.81± 4.81a | HR |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 14.58± 8.59bc | HR | 95.83± 4.17ab | S | 22.14± 14.30abcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 29.29± 12.36a | HR | 10.00± 10.00a | HR |
22 | 公农5号 Gongnong No.5 | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 30.95± 17.98cdef | HR | 45.71± 10.52abcd | HR | 95.83± 4.17a | S | 32.14± 17.04a | HR | 5.00± 5.00a | HR |
23 | 陇东苜蓿 Longdong | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 20.83± 20.83def | HR | 61.31± 22.47ab | R | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 36.67± 17.80a | HR | 5.21± 5.21a | HR |
24 | WL363HQ | 19.64±1 2.16bc | HR | 64.29± 23.69abcdef | R | 16.96± 10.45bcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 38.81± 10.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
25 | WL168HQ | 3.57± 3.57c | HR | 13.57± 9.43f | HR | 43.04± 16.03abcd | HR | 95.00± 5.00a | S | 33.57± 22.54a | HR | 15.00± 9.57a | HR |
26 | 阿迪娜 Adrenalin | 3.87± 2.25c | HR | 61.07± 18.68abcdef | R | 12.14± 7.23cd | HR | 91.96± 17.40a | LR | 25.48± 8.81a | HR | 5.00± 5.00a | HR |
27 | 甘农4号 Gannong No.4 | 16.67± 16.67bc | HR | 40.00± 23.09abcdef | HR | 16.07± 5.92cd | HR | 70.00± 23.80a | MR | 50.42± 12.59a | R | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
28 | 甘农3号 Gannong No.3 | 18.75± 18.75bc | HR | 18.57± 14.21ef | HR | 7.14± 7.14d | HR | 86.61± 7.77a | LR | 49.29± 20.71a | HR | 10.71± 10.71a | HR |
29 | SR4030 | 37.80± 15.43abc | HR | 38.69± 22.47abcdef | HR | 55.71± 22.02abc | R | 99.11± 10.95a | S | 26.67± 14.14a | HR | 14.71± 14.71a | HR |
30 | 新牧4号 Xinmu No.4 | 35.42± 22.15abc | HR | 59.29± 21.61abcdef | R | 16.90± 6.90bcd | HR | 100.00± 0.00a | S | 38.81± 10.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
31 | MF4020 | 26.49± 14.34abc | HR | 50.89± 22.51abcdef | R | 12.50± 12.50cd | HR | 89.58± 6.25a | LR | 25.42± 5.15a | HR | 0.00± 0.00a | HR |
32 | 冲击波 Shockwave | 27.38± 16.54abc | HR | 32.86±1 9.11bcdef | HR | 16.07± 11.80cd | HR | 85.00± 9.57a | MR | 57.14± 15.69a | R | 20.00±1 1.55a | HR |
病害 Disease | 抗性级别Resistance levels | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
高抗 High resistance | 抗性 Resistance | 中抗 Medium resistance | 低抗 Low resistance | 感病 Susceptible | |
苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病Phoma leaf spot and black stem | 17 | 8 | 4 | 1 | 2 |
苜蓿白粉病Alfalfa powdery mildew | 0 | 1 | 8 | 5 | 18 |
苜蓿黄斑病Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | 29 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Table 4 Frequency distribution of resistance levels of the tested alfalfa varieties
病害 Disease | 抗性级别Resistance levels | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
高抗 High resistance | 抗性 Resistance | 中抗 Medium resistance | 低抗 Low resistance | 感病 Susceptible | |
苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病Phoma leaf spot and black stem | 17 | 8 | 4 | 1 | 2 |
苜蓿白粉病Alfalfa powdery mildew | 0 | 1 | 8 | 5 | 18 |
苜蓿黄斑病Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | 29 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
编号Number | 品种名 Varieties | 苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病 Alfalfa phoma leaf spot and black stem | 苜蓿白粉病 Alfalfa powdery mildew | 苜蓿黄斑病 Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 2019年 | 2018年 | 2019年 | 2018年 | 2019年 | ||
1 | WL343HQ | 77.50±8.29ab | 58.81±15.88ab | 60.42±21.35abc | 61.90±26.15abc | 66.67±23.57a | 0.00±0.00a |
2 | WL354HQ | 47.50±7.25abcde | 16.67±9.62bcd | 8.33±8.33c | 65.83±10.90abc | 43.75±15.73a | 12.20±12.20a |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 45.83±15.77abcde | 18.33±10.67bcd | 35.71±23.69abc | 70.17±10.59abc | 35.42±20.52a | 11.90±11.90a |
4 | 甘农5号 Gannong No.5 | 48.21±20.49abcde | 39.29±14.85abcd | 25.89±17.70abc | 33.33±9.62c | 37.92±24.01a | 0.00±0.00a |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 69.17±3.63abc | 26.67±14.14abcd | 72.62±9.40abc | 44.58±11.85abc | 37.50±23.94a | 12.82±12.82a |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 3.57±3.57e | 46.67±17.64abcd | 28.75±18.07abc | 82.50±6.69ab | 61.04±21.50a | 0.00±0.00a |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 82.50±5.95a | 38.33±16.86abcd | 56.25±18.75abc | 45.42±12.08abc | 65.83±27.90a | 5.00±5.00a |
8 | 前景Vision | 69.17±3.63abc | 28.33±9.57abcd | 39.17±14.17abc | 37.50±21.65bc | 85.42±22.15a | 8.33±8.33a |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 51.79±20.49abcde | 48.33±11.34abcd | 68.75±23.66abc | 55.63±6.49abc | 62.50±23.94a | 0.00±0.00a |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 26.67±16.33bcde | 11.90±7.90cd | 62.50±23.94abc | 50.42±17.08abc | 18.75±11.97a | 18.29±18.29a |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 18.75±18.75cde | 20.83±12.50bcd | 31.25±18.75abc | 43.75±15.73abc | 32.50±19.74a | 6.25±3.61a |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 7.14±7.14e | 23.81±15.79abcd | 43.75±15.73abc | 60.71±5.95abc | 33.75±23.57a | 25.00±25.00a |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 62.50±21.65abcd | 68.75±6.25a | 23.81±15.79abc | 57.92±7.92abc | 70.83±26.68a | 21.67±15.72a |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 71.25±10.87abc | 50.00±0.00abc | 16.67±16.67bc | 69.17±3.63abc | 91.67±22.05a | 12.66±12.66a |
15 | WL319 | 56.25±21.35abcde | 37.50±7.22abcd | 75.00±10.21abc | 63.13±6.88abc | 57.50±21.75a | 12.66±12.66a |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 37.50±21.65abcde | 13.33±8.16cd | 61.67±21.67abc | 62.50±17.18abc | 72.92±44.54a | 0.00±0.00a |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 25.00±14.43cde | 29.17±17.18abcd | 87.50±7.22a | 75.00±2.04abc | 75.00±32.27a | 5.95±5.95a |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 31.25±23.66abcde | 27.92±14.00abcd | 73.33±28.67abc | 61.07±27.79abc | 77.08±43.75a | 18.92±12.22a |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 22.92±15.73cde | 60.83±9.82ab | 62.50±21.65abc | 74.17±2.76abc | 51.67±5.53a | 0.00±0.00a |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 29.17±17.18bcde | 35.83±13.15abcd | 44.05±31.43abc | 85.71±19.73a | 56.67±20.82a | 6.58±6.58a |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 14.58±8.59de | 56.25±6.25abc | 31.67±12.29abc | 57.92±7.92abc | 41.67±14.43a | 6.33±6.33a |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 12.92±5.29de | 21.67±15.72bcd | 82.29±7.29ab | 56.67±10.99abc | 56.25±21.35a | 6.41±6.41a |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 12.50±12.50de | 3.57±3.57d | 84.58±5.42a | 75.00±10.21abc | 70.00±23.80a | 6.67±4.08a |
24 | WL363HQ | 27.50±16.01bcde | 56.25±21.35abc | 27.98±10.40abc | 81.88±6.07ab | 79.79±23.69a | 0.00±0.00a |
25 | WL168HQ | 5.00±5.00e | 12.50±7.22cd | 50.00±20.41abc | 62.92±5.29abc | 75.00±32.27a | 19.11±12.50a |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 5.63±3.29e | 31.25±6.25abcd | 33.04±19.42abc | 56.31±6.23abc | 60.42±21.35a | 12.35±12.35a |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 33.33±33.33abcde | 25.00±14.43abcd | 26.67±16.33abc | 50.00±17.68abc | 76.25±10.28a | 0.00±0.00a |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 25.83±2.76bcde | 18.75±11.97bcd | 33.33±33.33abc | 62.56±7.18abc | 65.83±27.90a | 12.50±12.50a |
29 | SR4030 | 49.58±9.14abcde | 43.75±25.77abcd | 50.42±17.08abc | 81.25±11.97ab | 81.25±31.25a | 6.25±6.25a |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 19.64±6.60cde | 35.71±12.02abcd | 37.50±23.94abc | 56.88±11.43abc | 58.33±14.43a | 0.00±0.00a |
31 | MF4020 | 45.42±8.75abcde | 28.57±14.42abcd | 9.17±5.34c | 68.75±11.97abc | 56.67±4.08a | 0.00±0.00a |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 40.00±24.49abcde | 13.39±7.77cd | 41.67±25.00abc | 52.92±18.86abc | 68.75±11.97a | 18.75±11.97a |
Table 5 Disease indexes of the tested alfalfa varieties
编号Number | 品种名 Varieties | 苜蓿茎点霉叶斑与黑茎病 Alfalfa phoma leaf spot and black stem | 苜蓿白粉病 Alfalfa powdery mildew | 苜蓿黄斑病 Alfalfa yellow leaf blotch | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 2019年 | 2018年 | 2019年 | 2018年 | 2019年 | ||
1 | WL343HQ | 77.50±8.29ab | 58.81±15.88ab | 60.42±21.35abc | 61.90±26.15abc | 66.67±23.57a | 0.00±0.00a |
2 | WL354HQ | 47.50±7.25abcde | 16.67±9.62bcd | 8.33±8.33c | 65.83±10.90abc | 43.75±15.73a | 12.20±12.20a |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 45.83±15.77abcde | 18.33±10.67bcd | 35.71±23.69abc | 70.17±10.59abc | 35.42±20.52a | 11.90±11.90a |
4 | 甘农5号 Gannong No.5 | 48.21±20.49abcde | 39.29±14.85abcd | 25.89±17.70abc | 33.33±9.62c | 37.92±24.01a | 0.00±0.00a |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 69.17±3.63abc | 26.67±14.14abcd | 72.62±9.40abc | 44.58±11.85abc | 37.50±23.94a | 12.82±12.82a |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 3.57±3.57e | 46.67±17.64abcd | 28.75±18.07abc | 82.50±6.69ab | 61.04±21.50a | 0.00±0.00a |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 82.50±5.95a | 38.33±16.86abcd | 56.25±18.75abc | 45.42±12.08abc | 65.83±27.90a | 5.00±5.00a |
8 | 前景Vision | 69.17±3.63abc | 28.33±9.57abcd | 39.17±14.17abc | 37.50±21.65bc | 85.42±22.15a | 8.33±8.33a |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 51.79±20.49abcde | 48.33±11.34abcd | 68.75±23.66abc | 55.63±6.49abc | 62.50±23.94a | 0.00±0.00a |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 26.67±16.33bcde | 11.90±7.90cd | 62.50±23.94abc | 50.42±17.08abc | 18.75±11.97a | 18.29±18.29a |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 18.75±18.75cde | 20.83±12.50bcd | 31.25±18.75abc | 43.75±15.73abc | 32.50±19.74a | 6.25±3.61a |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 7.14±7.14e | 23.81±15.79abcd | 43.75±15.73abc | 60.71±5.95abc | 33.75±23.57a | 25.00±25.00a |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 62.50±21.65abcd | 68.75±6.25a | 23.81±15.79abc | 57.92±7.92abc | 70.83±26.68a | 21.67±15.72a |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 71.25±10.87abc | 50.00±0.00abc | 16.67±16.67bc | 69.17±3.63abc | 91.67±22.05a | 12.66±12.66a |
15 | WL319 | 56.25±21.35abcde | 37.50±7.22abcd | 75.00±10.21abc | 63.13±6.88abc | 57.50±21.75a | 12.66±12.66a |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 37.50±21.65abcde | 13.33±8.16cd | 61.67±21.67abc | 62.50±17.18abc | 72.92±44.54a | 0.00±0.00a |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 25.00±14.43cde | 29.17±17.18abcd | 87.50±7.22a | 75.00±2.04abc | 75.00±32.27a | 5.95±5.95a |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 31.25±23.66abcde | 27.92±14.00abcd | 73.33±28.67abc | 61.07±27.79abc | 77.08±43.75a | 18.92±12.22a |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 22.92±15.73cde | 60.83±9.82ab | 62.50±21.65abc | 74.17±2.76abc | 51.67±5.53a | 0.00±0.00a |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 29.17±17.18bcde | 35.83±13.15abcd | 44.05±31.43abc | 85.71±19.73a | 56.67±20.82a | 6.58±6.58a |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 14.58±8.59de | 56.25±6.25abc | 31.67±12.29abc | 57.92±7.92abc | 41.67±14.43a | 6.33±6.33a |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 12.92±5.29de | 21.67±15.72bcd | 82.29±7.29ab | 56.67±10.99abc | 56.25±21.35a | 6.41±6.41a |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 12.50±12.50de | 3.57±3.57d | 84.58±5.42a | 75.00±10.21abc | 70.00±23.80a | 6.67±4.08a |
24 | WL363HQ | 27.50±16.01bcde | 56.25±21.35abc | 27.98±10.40abc | 81.88±6.07ab | 79.79±23.69a | 0.00±0.00a |
25 | WL168HQ | 5.00±5.00e | 12.50±7.22cd | 50.00±20.41abc | 62.92±5.29abc | 75.00±32.27a | 19.11±12.50a |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 5.63±3.29e | 31.25±6.25abcd | 33.04±19.42abc | 56.31±6.23abc | 60.42±21.35a | 12.35±12.35a |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 33.33±33.33abcde | 25.00±14.43abcd | 26.67±16.33abc | 50.00±17.68abc | 76.25±10.28a | 0.00±0.00a |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 25.83±2.76bcde | 18.75±11.97bcd | 33.33±33.33abc | 62.56±7.18abc | 65.83±27.90a | 12.50±12.50a |
29 | SR4030 | 49.58±9.14abcde | 43.75±25.77abcd | 50.42±17.08abc | 81.25±11.97ab | 81.25±31.25a | 6.25±6.25a |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 19.64±6.60cde | 35.71±12.02abcd | 37.50±23.94abc | 56.88±11.43abc | 58.33±14.43a | 0.00±0.00a |
31 | MF4020 | 45.42±8.75abcde | 28.57±14.42abcd | 9.17±5.34c | 68.75±11.97abc | 56.67±4.08a | 0.00±0.00a |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 40.00±24.49abcde | 13.39±7.77cd | 41.67±25.00abc | 52.92±18.86abc | 68.75±11.97a | 18.75±11.97a |
项目 Item | 最小值 Minimum | 最大值 Maximum | 均值Mean |
---|---|---|---|
温度Temperature (℃) | -30.00 | 42.70 | 8.82 |
湿度Humidity(%) | 8.40 | 99.90 | 66.11 |
Table 6 Temperature and humidity of the test field
项目 Item | 最小值 Minimum | 最大值 Maximum | 均值Mean |
---|---|---|---|
温度Temperature (℃) | -30.00 | 42.70 | 8.82 |
湿度Humidity(%) | 8.40 | 99.90 | 66.11 |
编号Number | 品种名 Varieties | 2018年第1茬 First crop of 2018 | 2018年第2茬 Second crop of 2018 | 2019年第1茬 First crop of 2019 | 2019年第2茬 Second crop of 2019 | 2019年第3茬 Third crop of 2019 | 总产量 Sum of yeild |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | WL343HQ | 4.69±0.29a | 4.71±0.54a | 7.08±0.40abcd | 5.58±0.24bcde | 3.62±0.32bc | 25.68±0.93abcd |
2 | WL354HQ | 6.04±1.20a | 4.39±0.29a | 7.09±0.43abcd | 5.96±0.15bcd | 3.64±0.14bc | 27.12±1.11abc |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 6.03±1.25a | 4.00±0.73a | 7.85±0.23abc | 6.18±0.45abc | 3.99±0.40abc | 28.05±1.51abc |
4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 6.48±1.33a | 4.59±0.33a | 6.08±0.22d | 5.30±0.11cde | 3.39±0.30bc | 25.84±1.59abcd |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 5.27±0.87a | 5.20±0.38a | 7.34±0.28abcd | 5.54±0.30bcde | 3.49±0.23bc | 26.84±1.33abcd |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 4.80±0.36a | 4.51±0.24a | 8.08±0.58abc | 5.83±0.46bcd | 3.63±0.22bc | 26.85±1.34abcd |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 5.28±0.55a | 3.79±0.55a | 6.94±0.40abcd | 5.52±0.35bcde | 3.47±0.31bc | 24.99±0.54abcd |
8 | 前景Vision | 4.88±0.47a | 4.06±0.75a | 7.00±0.23abcd | 5.74±0.13bcde | 3.82±0.34bc | 25.50±0.87abcd |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 4.24±0.03a | 4.59±0.44a | 7.51±0.56abcd | 5.57±0.27bcde | 3.61±0.10bc | 25.52±0.36abcd |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 4.39±0.30a | 4.86±0.87a | 7.92±0.49abc | 5.69±0.57bcde | 3.69±0.24bc | 26.55±0.49abcd |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 5.00±1.00a | 4.85±0.66a | 7.31±0.53abcd | 5.26±0.23cdef | 3.53±0.39bc | 25.94±1.05abcd |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 4.80±0.92a | 4.33±0.46a | 7.50±0.21abcd | 5.57±0.38bcde | 3.37±0.47bc | 25.57±0.51abcd |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 4.00±0.28a | 4.58±0.68a | 6.54±0.38cd | 5.19±0.32cdef | 3.53±0.32bc | 23.84±0.49cd |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 5.40±1.25a | 3.93±0.61a | 6.76±0.54bcd | 5.47±0.13bcde | 3.44±0.23bc | 25.00±1.57abcd |
15 | WL319 | 4.87±1.49a | 3.65±0.56a | 7.23±0.31abcd | 5.99±0.15bc | 4.22±0.24abc | 25.95±2.12abcd |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 6.22±1.55a | 3.92±0.52a | 8.43±0.77a | 5.96±0.27bcd | 4.33±0.32abc | 28.86±1.33ab |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 4.81±0.31a | 4.22±0.27a | 8.10±0.21abc | 5.47±0.30bcde | 3.96±0.40abc | 26.55±0.73abcd |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 5.68±1.27a | 4.35±0.70a | 7.58±0.15abcd | 4.58±0.48ef | 3.21±0.18c | 25.39±1.29abcd |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 5.66±1.15a | 4.45±0.62a | 7.79±0.75abc | 5.04±0.36cdef | 4.21±0.39abc | 27.15±1.82abc |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 5.84±1.32a | 4.11±0.54a | 8.22±0.86ab | 5.79±0.29bcd | 4.02±0.33abc | 27.97±1.56abc |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 5.00±1.00a | 4.29±0.61a | 8.14±0.86abc | 7.06±0.27a | 5.03±0.54a | 29.52±1.59a |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 4.80±0.92a | 3.77±0.59a | 6.60±0.06bcd | 4.80±0.20def | 3.92±0.39bc | 23.89±0.64cd |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 4.00±0.28a | 4.34±0.29a | 6.77±0.35bcd | 4.18±0.48f | 3.20±0.33c | 22.48±0.96d |
24 | WL363HQ | 5.40±1.25a | 4.52±0.54a | 7.95±0.48abc | 5.87±0.38bcd | 4.44±0.61ab | 28.18±1.38abc |
25 | WL168HQ | 4.87±1.49a | 3.85±0.55a | 7.04±0.60abcd | 5.12±0.33cdef | 3.79±0.30bc | 24.67±2.07bcd |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 6.22±1.55a | 4.38±0.42a | 7.34±0.58abcd | 6.53±0.28ab | 4.19±0.32abc | 28.66±1.99ab |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 4.81±0.31a | 4.99±0.51a | 6.66±0.22bcd | 5.70±0.46bcde | 3.63±0.31bc | 25.78±0.90abcd |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 5.68±1.27a | 4.79±0.28a | 7.43±0.51abcd | 5.20±0.28cdef | 3.73±0.07bc | 26.83±1.84abcd |
29 | SR4030 | 5.66±1.15a | 5.04±0.10a | 7.96±0.17abc | 5.72±0.30bcde | 3.67±0.09bc | 28.05±0.88abc |
30 | 新牧4号 Xinmu No.4 | 5.84±1.32a | 4.74±0.22a | 7.63±0.43abcd | 5.79±0.39bcd | 3.63±0.34bc | 27.63±0.61abc |
31 | MF4020 | 5.43±1.07a | 4.07±0.53a | 7.10±0.31abcd | 5.60±0.57bcde | 3.90±0.30bc | 26.10±1.38abcd |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 6.01±1.56a | 5.02±0.93a | 6.80±0.27abcd | 5.82±0.19bcd | 3.83±0.43bc | 27.47±1.74abc |
Table 7 Yield of different alfalfa varieties (t·hm-2)
编号Number | 品种名 Varieties | 2018年第1茬 First crop of 2018 | 2018年第2茬 Second crop of 2018 | 2019年第1茬 First crop of 2019 | 2019年第2茬 Second crop of 2019 | 2019年第3茬 Third crop of 2019 | 总产量 Sum of yeild |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | WL343HQ | 4.69±0.29a | 4.71±0.54a | 7.08±0.40abcd | 5.58±0.24bcde | 3.62±0.32bc | 25.68±0.93abcd |
2 | WL354HQ | 6.04±1.20a | 4.39±0.29a | 7.09±0.43abcd | 5.96±0.15bcd | 3.64±0.14bc | 27.12±1.11abc |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 6.03±1.25a | 4.00±0.73a | 7.85±0.23abc | 6.18±0.45abc | 3.99±0.40abc | 28.05±1.51abc |
4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 6.48±1.33a | 4.59±0.33a | 6.08±0.22d | 5.30±0.11cde | 3.39±0.30bc | 25.84±1.59abcd |
5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 5.27±0.87a | 5.20±0.38a | 7.34±0.28abcd | 5.54±0.30bcde | 3.49±0.23bc | 26.84±1.33abcd |
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 4.80±0.36a | 4.51±0.24a | 8.08±0.58abc | 5.83±0.46bcd | 3.63±0.22bc | 26.85±1.34abcd |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 5.28±0.55a | 3.79±0.55a | 6.94±0.40abcd | 5.52±0.35bcde | 3.47±0.31bc | 24.99±0.54abcd |
8 | 前景Vision | 4.88±0.47a | 4.06±0.75a | 7.00±0.23abcd | 5.74±0.13bcde | 3.82±0.34bc | 25.50±0.87abcd |
9 | 雷霆Instict | 4.24±0.03a | 4.59±0.44a | 7.51±0.56abcd | 5.57±0.27bcde | 3.61±0.10bc | 25.52±0.36abcd |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 4.39±0.30a | 4.86±0.87a | 7.92±0.49abc | 5.69±0.57bcde | 3.69±0.24bc | 26.55±0.49abcd |
11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 5.00±1.00a | 4.85±0.66a | 7.31±0.53abcd | 5.26±0.23cdef | 3.53±0.39bc | 25.94±1.05abcd |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 4.80±0.92a | 4.33±0.46a | 7.50±0.21abcd | 5.57±0.38bcde | 3.37±0.47bc | 25.57±0.51abcd |
13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 4.00±0.28a | 4.58±0.68a | 6.54±0.38cd | 5.19±0.32cdef | 3.53±0.32bc | 23.84±0.49cd |
14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 5.40±1.25a | 3.93±0.61a | 6.76±0.54bcd | 5.47±0.13bcde | 3.44±0.23bc | 25.00±1.57abcd |
15 | WL319 | 4.87±1.49a | 3.65±0.56a | 7.23±0.31abcd | 5.99±0.15bc | 4.22±0.24abc | 25.95±2.12abcd |
16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 6.22±1.55a | 3.92±0.52a | 8.43±0.77a | 5.96±0.27bcd | 4.33±0.32abc | 28.86±1.33ab |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 4.81±0.31a | 4.22±0.27a | 8.10±0.21abc | 5.47±0.30bcde | 3.96±0.40abc | 26.55±0.73abcd |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 5.68±1.27a | 4.35±0.70a | 7.58±0.15abcd | 4.58±0.48ef | 3.21±0.18c | 25.39±1.29abcd |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 5.66±1.15a | 4.45±0.62a | 7.79±0.75abc | 5.04±0.36cdef | 4.21±0.39abc | 27.15±1.82abc |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 5.84±1.32a | 4.11±0.54a | 8.22±0.86ab | 5.79±0.29bcd | 4.02±0.33abc | 27.97±1.56abc |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 5.00±1.00a | 4.29±0.61a | 8.14±0.86abc | 7.06±0.27a | 5.03±0.54a | 29.52±1.59a |
22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 4.80±0.92a | 3.77±0.59a | 6.60±0.06bcd | 4.80±0.20def | 3.92±0.39bc | 23.89±0.64cd |
23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 4.00±0.28a | 4.34±0.29a | 6.77±0.35bcd | 4.18±0.48f | 3.20±0.33c | 22.48±0.96d |
24 | WL363HQ | 5.40±1.25a | 4.52±0.54a | 7.95±0.48abc | 5.87±0.38bcd | 4.44±0.61ab | 28.18±1.38abc |
25 | WL168HQ | 4.87±1.49a | 3.85±0.55a | 7.04±0.60abcd | 5.12±0.33cdef | 3.79±0.30bc | 24.67±2.07bcd |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 6.22±1.55a | 4.38±0.42a | 7.34±0.58abcd | 6.53±0.28ab | 4.19±0.32abc | 28.66±1.99ab |
27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 4.81±0.31a | 4.99±0.51a | 6.66±0.22bcd | 5.70±0.46bcde | 3.63±0.31bc | 25.78±0.90abcd |
28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 5.68±1.27a | 4.79±0.28a | 7.43±0.51abcd | 5.20±0.28cdef | 3.73±0.07bc | 26.83±1.84abcd |
29 | SR4030 | 5.66±1.15a | 5.04±0.10a | 7.96±0.17abc | 5.72±0.30bcde | 3.67±0.09bc | 28.05±0.88abc |
30 | 新牧4号 Xinmu No.4 | 5.84±1.32a | 4.74±0.22a | 7.63±0.43abcd | 5.79±0.39bcd | 3.63±0.34bc | 27.63±0.61abc |
31 | MF4020 | 5.43±1.07a | 4.07±0.53a | 7.10±0.31abcd | 5.60±0.57bcde | 3.90±0.30bc | 26.10±1.38abcd |
32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 6.01±1.56a | 5.02±0.93a | 6.80±0.27abcd | 5.82±0.19bcd | 3.83±0.43bc | 27.47±1.74abc |
编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 综合评价得分 Comprehensive evaluation score | 排序 Rank number | 编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 综合评价得分 Comprehensive evaluation score | 排序 Rank number |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 0.942 | 1 | 16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 0.791 | 17 |
24 | WL363HQ | 0.897 | 2 | 11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 0.791 | 18 |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 0.877 | 3 | 22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.785 | 19 |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 0.853 | 4 | 14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 0.783 | 20 |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 0.850 | 5 | 4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 0.774 | 21 |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 0.838 | 6 | 5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.773 | 22 |
31 | MF4020 | 0.836 | 7 | 27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 0.755 | 23 |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.824 | 8 | 8 | 前景Vision | 0.753 | 24 |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 0.821 | 9 | 15 | WL319 | 0.741 | 25 |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 0.820 | 10 | 28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.741 | 26 |
29 | SR4030 | 0.817 | 11 | 25 | WL168HQ | 0.738 | 27 |
2 | WL354HQ | 0.805 | 12 | 23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 0.721 | 28 |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 0.800 | 13 | 9 | 雷霆Instict | 0.718 | 29 |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 0.800 | 14 | 32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 0.699 | 30 |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 0.798 | 15 | 1 | WL343HQ | 0.679 | 31 |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 0.795 | 16 | 13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 0.650 | 32 |
Table 8 Comprehensive evaluation score and ranking of the tested alfalfa varieties
编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 综合评价得分 Comprehensive evaluation score | 排序 Rank number | 编号 Number | 品种名 Varieties | 综合评价得分 Comprehensive evaluation score | 排序 Rank number |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 | 皇冠Phabulous | 0.942 | 1 | 16 | 甘农6号Gannong No.6 | 0.791 | 17 |
24 | WL363HQ | 0.897 | 2 | 11 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 0.791 | 18 |
20 | 中苜3号Zhongmu No.3 | 0.877 | 3 | 22 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.785 | 19 |
18 | 敖汉苜蓿Aohan | 0.853 | 4 | 14 | 骑士T DSA01-T | 0.783 | 20 |
7 | 旱地Dryland | 0.850 | 5 | 4 | 甘农5号Gannong No.5 | 0.774 | 21 |
30 | 新牧4号Xinmu No.4 | 0.838 | 6 | 5 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.773 | 22 |
31 | MF4020 | 0.836 | 7 | 27 | 甘农4号Gannong No.4 | 0.755 | 23 |
19 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.824 | 8 | 8 | 前景Vision | 0.753 | 24 |
10 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 0.821 | 9 | 15 | WL319 | 0.741 | 25 |
21 | 龙威3010 Longwei 3010 | 0.820 | 10 | 28 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.741 | 26 |
29 | SR4030 | 0.817 | 11 | 25 | WL168HQ | 0.738 | 27 |
2 | WL354HQ | 0.805 | 12 | 23 | 陇东苜蓿Longdong | 0.721 | 28 |
12 | 康赛Kangsai | 0.800 | 13 | 9 | 雷霆Instict | 0.718 | 29 |
3 | 北极熊Polar bear | 0.800 | 14 | 32 | 冲击波Shockwave | 0.699 | 30 |
26 | 阿迪娜Adrenalin | 0.798 | 15 | 1 | WL343HQ | 0.679 | 31 |
17 | 阿尔冈金Algonquin | 0.795 | 16 | 13 | 耐盐之星Salt-tolerant star | 0.650 | 32 |
1 | Luo Y H, Jing X M, Xu M H, et al. The research progress of Medicago sativa root rot. Contemporary Animal Husbandry, 2019(4): 39-40. |
罗英花, 敬雪敏, 许美花, 等. 紫花苜蓿镰刀菌根腐病的研究进展. 当代畜牧, 2019(4): 39-40. | |
2 | Namu J L, Xu G F, Wu L Y. Trial on over-wintering of Medicago sativa in Delinha area. Qinghai Prataculture, 2002(4): 12-13. |
娜木吉力, 徐公芳, 乌兰英. 德令哈地区紫花苜蓿越冬试验报告. 青海草业, 2002(4): 12-13. | |
3 | Zhu J Z, Zhao Q, Abudoureyimu A, et al. Study on sustainable development of alfalfa production in Xinjiang. Journal of Xinjiang Agricultural University, 2006, 29(1): 36-39. |
朱进忠, 赵清, 阿不来提·阿不都热依木, 等. 新疆苜蓿生产可持续发展研究. 新疆农业大学学报, 2006, 29(1): 36-39. | |
4 | Yang Q C, Kang J M, Zhang T J, et al. Distribution, breeding and utilization of alfalfa germplasm resources. Chinese Science Bulletin, 2016, 61(2): 261-270. |
杨青川, 康俊梅, 张铁军, 等. 苜蓿种质资源的分布、育种与利用. 科学通报, 2016, 61(2): 261-270. | |
5 | Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. Plan of national alfalfa industry development in China. China Agricultural Informatics, 2017(4): 9-13. |
中华人民共和国农业农村部. 全国苜蓿产业发展规划. 中国农业信息, 2017(4): 9-13. | |
6 | Qin G, Wang H C, Liu H W, et al. A brief discussion on the application of alfalfa in livestock production in China. Livestock and Poultry Industry, 2006(14): 20-23. |
秦刚, 王海超, 刘华伟, 等. 浅谈苜蓿在我国畜牧生产中的应用. 畜禽业, 2006(14): 20-23. | |
7 | Li X F, Wang N, Wu S H. Applied values of alfalfa and prospect. Journal of Ningxia Agricultural College, 2003, 24(1): 76-82. |
李雪枫, 王宁, 吴韶寰. 苜蓿的应用价值及展望. 宁夏农学院学报, 2003, 24(1): 76-82. | |
8 | Nan Z B. Establishing sustainable management system for diseases of pasture crops in China. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2000, 9(2): 1-9. |
南志标. 建立中国的牧草病害可持续管理体系. 草业学报, 2000, 9(2): 1-9. | |
9 | Gray F A. Assessment of foliage diseases of alfalfa in Wyoming. Plant Disease, 1983, 67(10): 1156-1158. |
10 | James W C, Teng P S, Nutter F W. CRC handbook of pest management in agriculture. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1981. |
11 | Zhang L, Pan L Q, Yuan Q H, et al. Resistance evaluation of different alfalfa materials on phoma leaf spot. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2016, 24(3): 652-657. |
张丽, 潘龙其, 袁庆华, 等. 不同苜蓿种质材料对茎点霉叶斑病的抗性评价. 草地学报, 2016, 24(3): 652-657. | |
12 | Wang Y, Liu Y, Zhou B B, et al. An evaluation of the resistance of alfalfa cultivars to stemphylium and phoma leaf spot diseases. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(7): 155-162. |
王瑜, 刘怡, 周彬彬, 等. 苜蓿对匍柄霉叶斑病与茎点霉叶斑病的抗性评价研究. 草业学报, 2015, 24(7): 155-162. | |
13 | Li K M, Zhao L, Sun H Y. Progress and prospect on alfalfa disease in Xinjiang. Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences, 2010, 47(7): 1348-1352. |
李克梅, 赵莉, 孙红艳. 新疆苜蓿病害研究现状与展望. 新疆农业科学, 2010, 47(7): 1348-1352. | |
14 | Obert D E, Skinner D Z, Stuteville D L. Association of AFLP markers with downy mildew resistance in autotetraploid alfalfa. Molecular Breeding, 2000, 6(3): 287-294. |
15 | Yuan Q H, Zhang W S. Screening for resistance to common leaf spot in alfalfa germplasms. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2000, 9(4): 52-58. |
袁庆华, 张文淑. 苜蓿对褐斑病抗性筛选研究. 草业学报, 2000, 9(4): 52-58. | |
16 | Li C J, Nan Z B, Wang Y W, et al. Evaluation of resistance to downy mildew of alfalfa germplasm under alpine grassland conditions. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2000, 9(4): 44-51. |
李春杰, 南志标, 王贇文, 等. 高山草原条件下苜蓿种质抗霜霉性评价. 草业学报, 2000, 9(4): 44-51. | |
17 | Nan Z B, Yuan B H. Alfalfa disease in Altay region of Xinjiang. Pratacultural Science, 1994, 11(4): 14-18. |
南志标, 员宝华. 新疆阿勒泰地区苜蓿病害. 草业科学, 1994, 11(4): 14-18. | |
18 | Nan Z B, Li C J. List of fungal diseases of forage in China. Pratacultural Science, 1994, 11(supple1): 25-28. |
南志标, 李春杰. 中国牧草真菌病害名录. 草业科学, 1994, 11(增刊1): 25-28. | |
19 | Wang X W, Yu N L, Ma D C, et al. The preliminary study of the types and distributions of lucerne diseases in Xinjiang. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 1998, 7(2): 49-53. |
王雪薇, 喻宁莉, 马德成, 等. 新疆苜蓿病害种类和分布的初步研究. 草业学报, 1998, 7(2): 49-53. | |
20 | Su S C, Wang X W, Wang C L, et al. Occurrence of common leaf spot of alfalfa in Xinjiang. Pratacultural Science, 1997, 14(5): 32-34. |
苏生昌, 王雪薇, 王纯利, 等. 苜蓿褐斑病在新疆的发生. 草业科学, 1997, 14(5): 32-34. | |
21 | Li K, Zhu J Z. Screening test of 26 alfalfa varieties introduction. Grassland and Turf, 2006, 6(4): 25-31. |
李科, 朱进忠. 26个苜蓿品种引种筛选试验. 草原与草坪, 2006, 6(4): 25-31. | |
22 | Meng J M, Yin J L. Study on introduction and screening of alfalfa in Xinjiang. Grassland and Turf, 2006(2): 59-61. |
孟季蒙, 尹君亮. 新疆紫花苜蓿引种筛选研究. 草原与草坪, 2006(2): 59-61. | |
23 | Zhang H H, Zhang X Z, Ke M, et al. Evaluation of production performance of 25 alfalfa varieties in the desert area of Northern Xinjiang Plain. Grass-Feeding Livestock, 2019(2): 36-42. |
张荟荟, 张学洲, 柯梅, 等. 25个紫花苜蓿品种在北疆平原荒漠区的生产性能评价. 草食家畜, 2019(2): 36-42. | |
24 | Fang Z D. Methods of plant disease research. Beijing: China Agricultural Press, 1998. |
方中达. 植病研究方法. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 1998. | |
25 | Li Y Z, Nan Z B. The method of diagnose, investigation and loss evaluation for forage diseases. Nanjing: Jiangsu Phoenix Science and Technology Press, 2015. |
李彦忠, 南志标. 牧草病害诊断调查与损失评定方法. 南京: 江苏凤凰科学技术出版社, 2015. | |
26 | Zhang Y Y. Evaluation on the disease resistance of 32 alfalfa varieties in Changji, Xinjiang. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2021. |
张岳阳. 新疆昌吉32个紫花苜蓿品种的抗病性评价. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2021. | |
27 | Song Y Y. Evaluation of the resistance of forty varieties of alfalfa to stem and leaf fungal diseases. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2016. |
宋雨阳. 紫花苜蓿40个品种对茎叶真菌病害的抗性评价. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2016. | |
28 | Fan Q. Study on pathogenic mechanism of Phoma medicaginis on alfalfa. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2018. |
樊秦. 苜蓿茎点霉对苜蓿的致病机理研究. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2018. | |
29 | Wang H, Fan J X, Li K M. Study on biological characteristics on alfalfa yellow leaf blotch from Xinjiang// The 2018 Annual Conference of the Chinese Society of Plant Pathology of the Conference Proceedings. Beijing: China Agricultural Science and Technology Press, 2018: 98. |
王慧, 范钧星, 李克梅. 新疆苜蓿黄斑病菌生物学特性研究//中国植物病理学会2018年学术年会论文集. 北京: 中国农业科学技术出版社, 2018: 98. | |
30 | Wang H. Preliminary study on alfalfa yellow leaf blotch and determination of the treatment effect of fungicides on alfalfa seed. Urumchi: Xinjiang Agricultural University, 2017. |
王慧. 苜蓿黄斑病的初步研究及杀菌剂对苜蓿种带真菌的处理效果测定. 乌鲁木齐: 新疆农业大学, 2017. | |
31 | Schwab P M, Barnes D K, Sheaffer C C. The relationship between field winter injury and fall growth score for 251 alfalfa cultivars. Crop Science, 1996, 36(2): 418-426. |
32 | Wang Y T, Yu L Q, Sa R. Research progress of alfalfa cold resistance in China. Grassland and Turf, 2012, 32(3): 91-96. |
王运涛, 于林清, 萨仁. 苜蓿抗寒性研究进展. 草原与草坪, 2012, 32(3): 91-96. | |
33 | Sun Q Z, Wang Y Q, Hou X Y. Alfalfa winter survival research summary. Pratacultural Science, 2004, 21(3): 21-25. |
孙启忠, 王育青, 侯向阳. 紫花苜蓿越冬性研究概述. 草业科学, 2004, 21(3): 21-25. | |
34 | Mckenzie J S, Paquin R, Duke S H. Cold and heat tolerance. Alfalfa and Alfalfa Improvement, 1988(29): 259-302. |
35 | Zhao G W, Mijiti K. Study on over winterring of sixteen Medicago sativa varieties in Barkol Xinjiang. Grass-Feeding Livestock, 2018(4): 35-40. |
赵国伟, 凯撒·米吉提. 十六个紫花苜蓿品种在新疆巴里坤县越冬性研究. 草食家畜, 2018(4): 35-40. | |
36 | Peng H C, Niu D L, Li X M, et al. The seasonal dynamics of biomass of the Medicagosativa communities on the adandoned arable land of Chaidamu Basin. Acta Agrectia Sinica, 2001, 9(3): 218-222, 242. |
彭宏春, 牛东玲, 李晓明, 等. 柴达木盆地弃耕盐碱地紫花苜蓿生物量季节动态. 草地学报, 2001, 9(3): 218-222, 242. | |
37 | Larson S R, Mayland H F. Comparative mapping of fiber, protein, and mineral content QTL in two Leymus wildrye full-sib families. Molecular Breeding, 2007, 20(4): 331-347. |
38 | Liu D X, Liu G H, Yang Z M. The effects of planting and harvesting factors on hay yield and stem-leaf ratio of Medicago sativa. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(3): 48-57. |
刘东霞, 刘贵河, 杨志敏. 种植及收获因子对紫花苜蓿干草产量和茎叶比的影响. 草业学报, 2015, 24(3): 48-57. | |
39 | Huang N, Lu X S. Research and resistance evaluation progress on alfalfa leaf and root diseases. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2012, 28(5): 1-7. |
黄宁, 卢欣石. 苜蓿叶部与根部病害研究的评价进展. 中国农学通报, 2012, 28(5): 1-7. | |
40 | Broscious S C, Kirby H W. Economic evaluation of fungicides for control of alfalfa foliar diseases. Phytopathology, 1988, 78(7): 934-939. |
41 | Nan Z B. Alfalfa disease and its comprehensive control system in China. Animal Science & Veterinary Medicine, 2001, 18(4): 81-84. |
南志标. 我国的苜蓿病害及其综合防治体系. 动物科学与动物医学, 2001, 18(4): 81-84. | |
42 | Hwang S F, Wang H, Gossen B D, et al. Impact of foliar diseases on photosynthesis, protein content and seed yield of alfalfa and efficacy of fungicide application. European Journal of Plant Pathology, 2006, 115(4): 389-399. |
43 | Twizeyimana M, Ojiambo P S, Sonder K, et al. Pathogenic variation of Phakopsora pachyrhizi infecting soybean in Nigeria. Phytopathology, 2009, 99(4): 353-361. |
[1] | Rui-zhi XU, Xiao-juan WU, Hui-min YANG. Effect of topdressing after cutting on alfalfa growth and production [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(1): 195-204. |
[2] | Ying ZHAO, Xia-qing XIN, Xiao-hong WEI. Effects of nitric oxide on nitrogen metabolism in alfalfa under drought stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(9): 86-96. |
[3] | Qian-qian ZHOU, Ya-jian ZHANG, Jing ZHANG, Tu-tong YIN, Xia-fang SHENG, Lin-yan HE. Isolation of a beneficial hydrogen sulfide-producing bacterial strain that reduces lead uptake by Medicago sativa and aids remediation of Pb-contaminated soil [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(7): 44-52. |
[4] | Xiao-fang ZHANG, Xiao-hong WEI, Fang LIU, Xue-mei ZHU. Endogenous hormone responses to nitric oxide in alfalfa seedlings under PEG stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(4): 160-169. |
[5] | Wan-jun XIAO, Feng-xia GUO, Yuan CHEN, Lan-lan LIU, Yong-zhong CHEN, Xu-sheng JIAO, Bi-quan ZHANG, Gang BAI, Jian-qin JIN. Effect of organic fertilizer application on the medicinal character, yield and disease resistance of Angelica sinensis [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(3): 189-199. |
[6] | Xin MA, Zhu-zhu LUO, Yao-quan ZHANG, Jia-he LIU, Yi-ning NIU, Li-qun CAI. Distribution characteristics and ecological function predictions of soil bacterial communities in rainfed alfalfa fields on the Loess Plateau [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(3): 54-67. |
[7] | Xiao-jing LIU, Ya-jiao ZHAO, Feng HAO, Chang-chun TONG. Detection and characterization of nitrogen efficiency in alfalfa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(12): 90-102. |
[8] | Qian MA, Qi YAN, Zheng-she ZHANG, Fan WU, Ji-yu ZHANG. Identification, evolution and expression analysis of the CCoAOMT family genes in Medicago sativa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(11): 144-156. |
[9] | Ru-yue WANG, Wu-wu WEN, En-hua ZHAO, Peng ZHOU, Yuan AN. Cloning and salt-tolerance analysis of MsWRKY11 in alfalfa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(11): 157-169. |
[10] | FANG Xiang-ling, ZHANG Cai-xia, NAN Zhi-biao. Research advances in Fusarium root rot of alfalfa (Medicago sativa) [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(12): 169-183. |
[11] | ZHANG Yong-Mei, MA Hui-Ling, TANG Yun-Zhi. Structural changes in leaves in Medicago sativa infected with Erysiphe pisi [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2017, 26(2): 88-94. |
[12] | LI Chun-Jie, CHEN Tai-Xiang, ZHAO Gui-Qin, NAN Zhi-Biao. Progress in research on diseases of Avena sativa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2017, 26(12): 203-222. |
[13] | LI Jie, FENG Li-Dan, YANG Cheng-De, WANG You-Ke, HE Jing, ZHANG Bao-Lin, CHEN Xiu-Rong. EffectsofkeyenzymesandproductsinphenylpropanoidpathwayofLyciuminfectedbyFusariumoxysporum [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2016, 25(5): 87-94. |
[14] | WANG Yu, LIU Yi, ZHOU Bin-Bin, YUAN Qing-Hua, ZHANG Li, PAN Long-Qi. An evaluation of the resistance of alfalfa cultivars to Stemphylium and Phoma leaf spot diseases [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(7): 155-162. |
[15] | ZHAO Meng, WEI Xiao-Hong. Effects of nitric oxide on Medicago sativa seed germination under imbibitional chilling [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2015, 24(4): 87-94. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||