Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2023, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (10): 115-128.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2022447
Bo CHEN1(), Yi-fan NIU1, Xiao-yu LIU1, Su-han ZHANG1, Jun-peng NIU2, Zhi-peng GUO2, Chao-qi LIU1, Yong-peng GUO1, Yu-xia GUO1()
Received:
2022-11-14
Revised:
2023-02-02
Online:
2023-10-20
Published:
2023-07-26
Contact:
Yu-xia GUO
Bo CHEN, Yi-fan NIU, Xiao-yu LIU, Su-han ZHANG, Jun-peng NIU, Zhi-peng GUO, Chao-qi LIU, Yong-peng GUO, Yu-xia GUO. An evaluation of the pathogenicity of Fusarium solani and disease resistance of alfalfa varieties[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(10): 115-128.
序号 Number | 品种 Variety | 秋眠级 FDG | 来源 Source | 育成国家 Breeding country |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 2 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 6 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 4 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
5 | 游客Eureka | 8 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
6 | WL354HQ | 4 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 3 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 2 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 1 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 中国China |
11 | Bara310SC | 3 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 7 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 7~8 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 3 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
15 | WL363HQ | 5 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
16 | Paola | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 意大利Italy |
17 | WL168HQ | 2 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 3~5 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 1 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
21 | WL440HQ | 5 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 9 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
Table 1 Testing alfalfa varieties in the experiment and their sources
序号 Number | 品种 Variety | 秋眠级 FDG | 来源 Source | 育成国家 Breeding country |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 2 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 6 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 4 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
5 | 游客Eureka | 8 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
6 | WL354HQ | 4 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 3 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 2 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 1 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 中国China |
11 | Bara310SC | 3 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 美国America |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 7 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 7~8 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 3 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
15 | WL363HQ | 5 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
16 | Paola | 5 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 意大利Italy |
17 | WL168HQ | 2 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 加拿大Canada |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 3~5 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 1 | 酒泉大业种业有限责任公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Co., Ltd | 中国China |
21 | WL440HQ | 5 | 北京正道生态科技有限公司Beijing Rytway Ecological Technology Co., Ltd | 美国America |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 9 | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug (Tianjin) International Grass Co., Ltd | 澳大利亚Australia |
序号Number | 品种 Variety | WA发芽率Germination (%) | PDA发芽率Germination (%) | WA病情指数Disease index | PDA病情指数Disease index | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | ||
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 100.00±0.00A | 93.00±2.89Aabc | 100.00±8.18A | 96.00±9.28Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 74.00±3.00Abcd | 0.00±0.00B | 81.00±1.73Abcdef |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 100.00±2.94A | 86.00±5.08Babcde | 100.00±0.00A | 60.00±8.66Bg | 0.00±0.00B | 70.33±2.89Acde | 0.00±0.00B | 87.67±2.08Aa |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 100.00±2.94A | 96.00±5.08Aab | 100.00±2.99A | 84.00±2.99Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 66.00±3.00Ae | 0.00±0.00B | 75.33±5.77Aghi |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 100.00±5.26A | 84.00±15.79Abcde | 100.00±2.99A | 91.00±11.95Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 72.67±4.04Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 73.33±2.89Ahi |
5 | 游客Eureka | 100.00±5.97A | 91.00±7.90Aabcd | 100.00±2.94A | 79.00±5.87Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 79.00±2.00Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±0.58Abcdefg |
6 | WL354HQ | 100.00±13.32A | 92.00±11.54Aabcd | 100.00±11.11A | 81.00±8.49Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 73.33±3.06Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±3.21Abcdefg |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 100.00±2.94A | 88.00±2.94Babcd | 100.00±2.99A | 87.00±5.17Babcd | 0.00±0.00B | 74.67±5.03Aabcd | 0.00±0.00B | 73.00±1.73Ai |
8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 100.00±2.99A | 91.00±5.97Aabcd | 100.00±8.18A | 96.00±10.71Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 72.67±6.51Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±2.08Adefghi |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 100.00±0.00A | 91.00±2.89Babcd | 100.00±0.00A | 83.00±7.64Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.67±0.58Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±1.00Aabc |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 100.00±5.26A | 92.00±3.04Aabc | 100.00±5.26A | 71.00±8.04Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 72.33±3.79Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±5.20Aabc |
11 | Bara310SC | 100.00±5.26A | 80.00±3.04Bcdef | 100.00±9.62A | 88.00±5.56Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 76.67±4.51Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.33±0.58Abcdefghi |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 100.00±9.12A | 70.00±8.04Bf | 100.00±5.97A | 72.00±5.17Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 82.00±4.00Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 82.00±4.00Abcd |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 100.00±2.99A | 84.00±7.90Babcde | 100.00±2.94A | 77.00±2.94Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 80.00±2.00Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 75.67±1.15Afghi |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 100.00±0.00A | 73.00±7.64Bef | 100.00±5.26A | 77.00±8.04Bcde | 0.00±0.00B | 79.33±1.53Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 76.33±0.58Aefghi |
15 | WL363HQ | 100.00±2.94A | 84.00±5.87Babcde | 100.00±0.00A | 81.00±7.64Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 75.33±3.51Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±2.89Abcdefg |
16 | Paola | 100.00±0.00A | 70.00±5.00Bf | 100.00±2.94A | 62.00±2.94Bfg | 0.00±0.00B | 77.00±4.58Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 81.00±3.46Abcdef |
17 | WL168HQ | 100.00±2.94A | 83.00±7.77Bbcdef | 100.00±2.94A | 89.00±2.94Babc | 0.00±0.00B | 73.67±4.93Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 81.33±1.15Abcde |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 100.00±3.09A | 80.00±5.36Bcdef | 100.00±3.09A | 75.00±5.36Bdef | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±5.13Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.67±0.58Abcdefgh |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 100.00±0.00A | 78.00±2.89Bdef | 100.00±5.97A | 72.00±5.17Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 79.67±3.51Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 83.67±2.08Aab |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 100.00±2.94A | 98.00±2.94Aa | 100.00±0.00A | 83.00±2.89Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 67.33±4.51Ade | 0.00±0.00B | 79.67±1.53Abcdefg |
21 | WL440HQ | 100.00±3.27A | 84.00±5.66Babcde | 100.00±6.30A | 78.00±8.33Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±4.04Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.00±6.00Acdefghi |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 100.00±5.26A | 87.00±12.15Aabcd | 100.00±2.94A | 79.00±2.94Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 76.33±6.66Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±1.00Aabc |
Table 2 Effects of F. solani on relative germination percentage and disease index of 22 alfalfa cultivars
序号Number | 品种 Variety | WA发芽率Germination (%) | PDA发芽率Germination (%) | WA病情指数Disease index | PDA病情指数Disease index | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | ||
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 100.00±0.00A | 93.00±2.89Aabc | 100.00±8.18A | 96.00±9.28Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 74.00±3.00Abcd | 0.00±0.00B | 81.00±1.73Abcdef |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 100.00±2.94A | 86.00±5.08Babcde | 100.00±0.00A | 60.00±8.66Bg | 0.00±0.00B | 70.33±2.89Acde | 0.00±0.00B | 87.67±2.08Aa |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 100.00±2.94A | 96.00±5.08Aab | 100.00±2.99A | 84.00±2.99Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 66.00±3.00Ae | 0.00±0.00B | 75.33±5.77Aghi |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 100.00±5.26A | 84.00±15.79Abcde | 100.00±2.99A | 91.00±11.95Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 72.67±4.04Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 73.33±2.89Ahi |
5 | 游客Eureka | 100.00±5.97A | 91.00±7.90Aabcd | 100.00±2.94A | 79.00±5.87Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 79.00±2.00Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±0.58Abcdefg |
6 | WL354HQ | 100.00±13.32A | 92.00±11.54Aabcd | 100.00±11.11A | 81.00±8.49Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 73.33±3.06Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±3.21Abcdefg |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 100.00±2.94A | 88.00±2.94Babcd | 100.00±2.99A | 87.00±5.17Babcd | 0.00±0.00B | 74.67±5.03Aabcd | 0.00±0.00B | 73.00±1.73Ai |
8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 100.00±2.99A | 91.00±5.97Aabcd | 100.00±8.18A | 96.00±10.71Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 72.67±6.51Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±2.08Adefghi |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 100.00±0.00A | 91.00±2.89Babcd | 100.00±0.00A | 83.00±7.64Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.67±0.58Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±1.00Aabc |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 100.00±5.26A | 92.00±3.04Aabc | 100.00±5.26A | 71.00±8.04Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 72.33±3.79Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±5.20Aabc |
11 | Bara310SC | 100.00±5.26A | 80.00±3.04Bcdef | 100.00±9.62A | 88.00±5.56Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 76.67±4.51Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.33±0.58Abcdefghi |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 100.00±9.12A | 70.00±8.04Bf | 100.00±5.97A | 72.00±5.17Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 82.00±4.00Aa | 0.00±0.00B | 82.00±4.00Abcd |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 100.00±2.99A | 84.00±7.90Babcde | 100.00±2.94A | 77.00±2.94Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 80.00±2.00Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 75.67±1.15Afghi |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 100.00±0.00A | 73.00±7.64Bef | 100.00±5.26A | 77.00±8.04Bcde | 0.00±0.00B | 79.33±1.53Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 76.33±0.58Aefghi |
15 | WL363HQ | 100.00±2.94A | 84.00±5.87Babcde | 100.00±0.00A | 81.00±7.64Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 75.33±3.51Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 80.33±2.89Abcdefg |
16 | Paola | 100.00±0.00A | 70.00±5.00Bf | 100.00±2.94A | 62.00±2.94Bfg | 0.00±0.00B | 77.00±4.58Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 81.00±3.46Abcdef |
17 | WL168HQ | 100.00±2.94A | 83.00±7.77Bbcdef | 100.00±2.94A | 89.00±2.94Babc | 0.00±0.00B | 73.67±4.93Abcde | 0.00±0.00B | 81.33±1.15Abcde |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 100.00±3.09A | 80.00±5.36Bcdef | 100.00±3.09A | 75.00±5.36Bdef | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±5.13Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.67±0.58Abcdefgh |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 100.00±0.00A | 78.00±2.89Bdef | 100.00±5.97A | 72.00±5.17Befg | 0.00±0.00B | 79.67±3.51Aab | 0.00±0.00B | 83.67±2.08Aab |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 100.00±2.94A | 98.00±2.94Aa | 100.00±0.00A | 83.00±2.89Babcde | 0.00±0.00B | 67.33±4.51Ade | 0.00±0.00B | 79.67±1.53Abcdefg |
21 | WL440HQ | 100.00±3.27A | 84.00±5.66Babcde | 100.00±6.30A | 78.00±8.33Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 77.33±4.04Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 78.00±6.00Acdefghi |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 100.00±5.26A | 87.00±12.15Aabcd | 100.00±2.94A | 79.00±2.94Bbcde | 0.00±0.00B | 76.33±6.66Aabc | 0.00±0.00B | 83.00±1.00Aabc |
序号 Number | 品种 Variety | WA | PDA | 综合评价值 D value | 排名 Rank | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | ||||
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 1.00±0.16A | 0.80±0.18Bbcd | 1.00±0.23A | 0.44±0.13Bdefg | 0.588 | 5 |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 1.00±0.14A | 0.80±0.20Bbcd | 1.00±0.20A | 0.46±0.12Bbcdef | 0.497 | 9 |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 1.00±0.13A | 0.89±0.25Bab | 1.00±0.15A | 0.54±0.15Bab | 0.760 | 1 |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 1.00±0.16A | 0.64±0.17Be | 1.00±0.22A | 0.45±0.11Bcdefg | 0.470 | 13 |
5 | 游客Eureka | 1.00±0.12A | 0.74±0.20Bde | 1.00±0.19A | 0.47±0.14Bbcdef | 0.508 | 8 |
6 | WL354HQ | 1.00±0.14A | 0.64±0.16Be | 1.00±0.12A | 0.56±0.20Ba | 0.488 | 11 |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 1.00±0.24A | 0.93±0.30Aa | 1.00±0.19A | 0.52±0.11Babc | 0.609 | 4 |
8 | 中苜1号 Zhongmu No.1 | 1.00±0.19A | 0.77±0.21Bcd | 1.00±0.19A | 0.45±0.11Bcdefg | 0.641 | 2 |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 1.00±0.16A | 0.76±0.17Bcd | 1.00±0.16A | 0.46±0.12Bbcdef | 0.348 | 20 |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 1.00±0.15A | 0.87±0.23Babc | 1.00±0.23A | 0.51±0.18Babcd | 0.463 | 15 |
11 | Bara310SC | 1.00±0.18A | 0.81±0.18Bbcd | 1.00±0.22A | 0.43±0.11Befg | 0.613 | 3 |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.17Bcd | 1.00±0.18A | 0.41±0.17Bfg | 0.352 | 19 |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.26Bcd | 1.00±0.18A | 0.39±0.12Bfg | 0.410 | 17 |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 1.00±0.19A | 0.71±0.15Bde | 1.00±0.16A | 0.40±0.15Bfg | 0.362 | 18 |
15 | WL363HQ | 1.00±0.18A | 0.63±0.16Be | 1.00±0.24A | 0.41±0.10Bfg | 0.477 | 12 |
16 | Paola | 1.00±0.18A | 0.77±0.15Bcd | 1.00±0.17A | 0.41±0.13Bfg | 0.275 | 22 |
17 | WL168HQ | 1.00±0.14A | 0.76±0.16Bcd | 1.00±0.17A | 0.41±0.09Bfg | 0.469 | 14 |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 1.00±0.21A | 0.64±0.16Be | 1.00±0.22A | 0.46±0.13Bbcdef | 0.491 | 10 |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 1.00±0.15A | 0.76±0.16Bcd | 1.00±0.15A | 0.43±0.10Bdefg | 0.278 | 21 |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 1.00±0.12A | 0.78±0.16Bbcd | 1.00±0.16A | 0.37±0.08Bg | 0.524 | 7 |
21 | WL440HQ | 1.00±0.18A | 0.70±0.15Bde | 1.00±0.19A | 0.51±0.24Babcd | 0.427 | 16 |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.19Bbcd | 1.00±0.20A | 0.42±0.10Bfg | 0.537 | 6 |
Table 3 Effects of F. solani on relative root-shoot ratio of 22 alfalfa cultivars and comprehensive evaluation
序号 Number | 品种 Variety | WA | PDA | 综合评价值 D value | 排名 Rank | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | 对照组 Control group | 接菌组 Inoculation group | ||||
1 | 金皇后Golden-queen | 1.00±0.16A | 0.80±0.18Bbcd | 1.00±0.23A | 0.44±0.13Bdefg | 0.588 | 5 |
2 | 塔苜F6 TARIMU F6 | 1.00±0.14A | 0.80±0.20Bbcd | 1.00±0.20A | 0.46±0.12Bbcdef | 0.497 | 9 |
3 | 塔苜5S TARIMU 5S | 1.00±0.13A | 0.89±0.25Bab | 1.00±0.15A | 0.54±0.15Bab | 0.760 | 1 |
4 | 乐寒F4 OPTIMUS F4 | 1.00±0.16A | 0.64±0.17Be | 1.00±0.22A | 0.45±0.11Bcdefg | 0.470 | 13 |
5 | 游客Eureka | 1.00±0.12A | 0.74±0.20Bde | 1.00±0.19A | 0.47±0.14Bbcdef | 0.508 | 8 |
6 | WL354HQ | 1.00±0.14A | 0.64±0.16Be | 1.00±0.12A | 0.56±0.20Ba | 0.488 | 11 |
7 | 乐寒F3 OPTIMUS F3 | 1.00±0.24A | 0.93±0.30Aa | 1.00±0.19A | 0.52±0.11Babc | 0.609 | 4 |
8 | 中苜1号 Zhongmu No.1 | 1.00±0.19A | 0.77±0.21Bcd | 1.00±0.19A | 0.45±0.11Bcdefg | 0.641 | 2 |
9 | 龙牧803 Longmu 803 | 1.00±0.16A | 0.76±0.17Bcd | 1.00±0.16A | 0.46±0.12Bbcdef | 0.348 | 20 |
10 | 塔苜F5 TARIMU F5 | 1.00±0.15A | 0.87±0.23Babc | 1.00±0.23A | 0.51±0.18Babcd | 0.463 | 15 |
11 | Bara310SC | 1.00±0.18A | 0.81±0.18Bbcd | 1.00±0.22A | 0.43±0.11Befg | 0.613 | 3 |
12 | 赛迪7 Sardi 7 | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.17Bcd | 1.00±0.18A | 0.41±0.17Bfg | 0.352 | 19 |
13 | 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.26Bcd | 1.00±0.18A | 0.39±0.12Bfg | 0.410 | 17 |
14 | 中兰2号Zhonglan No.2 | 1.00±0.19A | 0.71±0.15Bde | 1.00±0.16A | 0.40±0.15Bfg | 0.362 | 18 |
15 | WL363HQ | 1.00±0.18A | 0.63±0.16Be | 1.00±0.24A | 0.41±0.10Bfg | 0.477 | 12 |
16 | Paola | 1.00±0.18A | 0.77±0.15Bcd | 1.00±0.17A | 0.41±0.13Bfg | 0.275 | 22 |
17 | WL168HQ | 1.00±0.14A | 0.76±0.16Bcd | 1.00±0.17A | 0.41±0.09Bfg | 0.469 | 14 |
18 | 大业1号Daye No.1 | 1.00±0.21A | 0.64±0.16Be | 1.00±0.22A | 0.46±0.13Bbcdef | 0.491 | 10 |
19 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 1.00±0.15A | 0.76±0.16Bcd | 1.00±0.15A | 0.43±0.10Bdefg | 0.278 | 21 |
20 | 公农1号Gongnong No.1 | 1.00±0.12A | 0.78±0.16Bbcd | 1.00±0.16A | 0.37±0.08Bg | 0.524 | 7 |
21 | WL440HQ | 1.00±0.18A | 0.70±0.15Bde | 1.00±0.19A | 0.51±0.24Babcd | 0.427 | 16 |
22 | 天马Pegasis | 1.00±0.17A | 0.78±0.19Bbcd | 1.00±0.20A | 0.42±0.10Bfg | 0.537 | 6 |
1 | Nan Z B. Alfalfa disease and its comprehensive prevention and management system. Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2001, 18(4): 81-84. |
南志标. 我国的苜蓿病害及其综合防治体系. 动物科学与动物医学, 2001, 18(4): 81-84. | |
2 | Guo Y X, Nan Z B, Wang C Z, et al. Progress in research on root invading fungi of Medicago sativa. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2009, 18(5): 243-249. |
郭玉霞, 南志标, 王成章, 等. 苜蓿根部入侵真菌研究进展. 草业学报, 2009, 18(5): 243-249. | |
3 | Fang X L, Zhang C X, Nan Z B. Research advances in Fusarium root rot of alfalfa (Medicago sativa). Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(12): 169-183. |
方香玲, 张彩霞, 南志标. 紫花苜蓿镰刀菌根腐病研究进展. 草业学报, 2019, 28(12): 169-183. | |
4 | Liu D X, Yang L, Song L Z, et al. Comparative study on pathogenicity of three Fusarium strains to different alfalfa varieties. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2022, 30(4): 909-918. |
刘东霞, 杨莉, 宋连昭, 等. 三种镰孢菌对不同苜蓿品种致病性的比较研究. 草地学报, 2022, 30(4): 909-918. | |
5 | The Ministry of Agriculture of China. Opinions of the Ministry of Agriculture on speeding up agricultural S & T innovation and agro-tech extension set down by No.1 Document for 2012 issued by the CPC Central Committee and the State Council. Ministry of Agriculture of the People’s Republic of China, 2012(7): 6-11. |
中国农业部. 农业部关于深入贯彻落实中央1号文件加快农业科技创新与推广的实施意见. 中华人民共和国农业部公报, 2012(7): 6-11. | |
6 | Guo Y X, Guan Y Z, Zhang J F, et al. Effects of inoculating root rot Fusarium on alfalfa seedlings. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2015, 23(3): 623-631. |
郭玉霞, 管永卓, 张金锋, 等. 根腐病原镰刀菌-苜蓿品种-土壤水分互作对种苗生长的影响. 草地学报, 2015, 23(3): 623-631. | |
7 | Wang Z, Tian H, Zhang C, et al. Occurrence of Macrophomina phaseolina causing root and crown rot on alfalfa (Medicago sativa) in China. Plant Disease, 2020, 104(9): 2521. |
8 | Chen Y, Min J C, Xiao F, et al. New records of fungal forage disease in Xinjiang. Grassland of China, 1989(2): 71-73. |
陈耀, 闵继淳, 肖凤, 等. 新疆苜蓿根腐病研究初报. 中国草地, 1989(2): 71-73. | |
9 | Meng Y, Li M Q. Research progress on alfalfa crown and root rot pathogeny and their control. Pratacultural Science, 2005, 22(5): 89-92. |
孟嫣, 李敏权. 苜蓿根和根颈腐烂病病原及防治研究进展. 草业科学, 2005, 22(5): 89-92. | |
10 | Chen Y J, Liu X M, Cui G W, et al. Research progress in root rot of alfalfa. Grassland of China, 2000(1): 52-57. |
陈雅君, 刘学敏, 崔国文, 等. 紫花苜蓿根腐病的研究进展. 中国草地, 2000(1): 52-57. | |
11 | Chen Y J, Cui G W. Investigation on root rot of alfalfa in Heilongjiang Province and separation of pathogens. Grassland of China, 2001, 23(3): 79-80. |
陈雅君, 崔国文. 黑龙江省紫花苜蓿根腐病调查及病原分离. 中国草地, 2001, 23(3): 79-80. | |
12 | Cong L L, Kang J M, Zhang T J, et al. Identification and pathogenicity test of pathogenic Fusarium of alfalfa root rot. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2017, 25(4): 857-865. |
丛丽丽, 康俊梅, 张铁军, 等. 苜蓿镰刀菌根腐病病原菌的分离鉴定与致病性分析. 草地学报, 2017, 25(4): 857-865. | |
13 | Yang M, Cao J, Zheng Y, et al. First report of Fusarium root rot of tobacco caused by Fusarium solani in Lincang, China. Plant Disease, 2020, 104(5): 1541. |
14 | Wang R Y, Gao B, Li X H, et al. First report of Fusarium solani causing Fusarium root rot and stem canker on storage roots of sweet potato in China. Plant Disease, 2014, 98(1): 160. |
15 | Erazo J, Palacios S, Pastor N, et al. Biocontrol mechanisms of Trichoderma harzianum ITEM 3636 against peanut brown root rot caused by Fusarium solani RC 386. Biological Control, 2021, 164: 104774. |
16 | Pérez-Hernández A, Rocha L O, Porcel-Rodriguez E, et al. Pathogenic, morphological, and phylogenetic characterization of Fusarium solani f. sp. cucurbitae isolates from cucurbits in Almería Province, Spain. Plant Disease, 2020, 104(5): 1465-1476. |
17 | Ruan Z, Ding J Y, Tang G H, et al. Pathogen identification of root rot of Zanthoxylum bungeanum and screening of fungicides. Acta Phytopathologica Sinica, 2022, 52(4): 630-637. |
阮钊, 丁俊园, 唐光辉, 等. 花椒根腐病的病原鉴定与防治药剂筛选. 植物病理学报, 2022, 52(4): 630-637. | |
18 | Zhou J, Zhang L L, Yuan J R, et al. Isolation and identification of Fusarium solani from ginger rhizomes and establishment of a rapid PCR detection method. Acta Phytopathologica Sinica, 2022, 52(4): 681-690. |
周洁, 张玲玲, 袁继荣, 等. 生姜腐皮镰刀菌的分离鉴定及PCR快速检测方法构建. 植物病理学报, 2022, 52(4): 681-690. | |
19 | Shivanna R, Garampalli R H. Evaluation of fungistatic potential of lichen extracts against Fusarium solani (Mart.) Sacc. causing rhizome rot disease in Ginger. Journal of Applied Pharmaceutical Science, 2015, 5(10): 67-72. |
20 | Staten G, Leyendecker P J. A root rot disease of alfalfa caused by Fusarium solani. Plant Disease, 1949, 33: 254-255. |
21 | McDonald W C. The distribution and pathogenicity of the fungi associated with crown and root rotting of alfalfa in Manitoba. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Science, 1955, 35(3): 309-321. |
22 | Uddin W, Knous T R. Fusarium species associated with crown rot of alfalfa in Nevada. Plant Disease, 1991, 75(1): 51-56. |
23 | Cao L X, Zhao C H, Bai Q J, et al. Identification of the pathogens causing root rot of alfalfa in Inner Mongolia. Acta Agriculturae Boreali-Sinica, 2008, 23(6): 105-107. |
曹丽霞, 赵存虎, 白全江, 等. 内蒙古中部地区苜蓿根腐病病原研究. 华北农学报, 2008, 23(6): 105-107. | |
24 | Zhang J N, Wang T M, Liu Z X, et al. Identification of root rot pathogen in western Inner Mongolia//Proceedings of the 3rd (2014) China Grass Industry Conference. Hohhot: China Animal Husbandry Association, 2014: 6. |
张静妮, 王铁梅, 刘自学, 等. 内蒙古西部地区苜蓿根腐病病原菌鉴定//第三届(2014)中国草业大会论文集. 呼和浩特: 中国畜牧业协会, 2014: 6. | |
25 | Wang D C, Meng Y R, Li W M, et al. Isolation and identification of the pathogens causing root rot disease of Medicago sativa. Pratacultural Science, 2005, 22(10): 78-81. |
王多成, 孟有儒, 李文明, 等. 苜蓿根腐病病原菌的分离及鉴定. 草业科学, 2005, 22(10): 78-81. | |
26 | An H L. Study on pathogen of alfalfa root rot in Gansu Province. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2016. |
安欢乐. 甘肃省紫花苜蓿根腐病的病原研究. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2016. | |
27 | Kong Q Q, Ruan L, Liu D X, et al. Biological characteristics of Fusarium causing alfalfa root rot in Hebei Province. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2018, 23(8): 59-76. |
孔前前, 阮柳, 刘东霞, 等. 河北苜蓿镰孢菌根腐病病原生物学特性研究. 中国农业大学学报, 2018, 23(8): 59-76. | |
28 | Ruan L, Ma Z H, Liu Z Y, et al. Isolation, identification and toxicity determination of pathogens causing alfalfa root rot. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2016, 21(6): 56-67. |
阮柳, 马占鸿, 刘振宇, 等. 苜蓿根腐病的病原分离、鉴定与杀菌剂毒力测定. 中国农业大学学报, 2016, 21(6): 56-67. | |
29 | Guo Y X, Wang C Z, Yan X B, et al. Root-invading fungi of different alfalfa varieties. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2009, 17(6): 723-730. |
郭玉霞, 王成章, 严学兵, 等. 不同紫花苜蓿品种根部入侵真菌研究. 草地学报, 2009, 17(6): 723-730. | |
30 | Wang Y, Yuan Q H, Miao L H, et al. The major types and epidemic trends of alfalfa diseases in Northeast and North China. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2016, 25(3): 52-59. |
王瑜, 袁庆华, 苗丽宏, 等. 东北与华北地区紫花苜蓿病害调查与主要病害流行规律研究. 草业学报, 2016, 25(3): 52-59. | |
31 | Wang H F. Study on pathogens of alfalfa root rot in Yunnan Province. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2020. |
王慧菲. 云南省紫花苜蓿根腐病病原的研究. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2020. | |
32 | Zhang H, Zhang Z, Xu J S, et al. A rapid and simple method for obtaining single-spore isolates of Fusarium species-agar dilution lineation separation. Plant Protection, 2008, 34(6): 134-136. |
张昊, 张争, 许景升, 等. 一种简单快速的赤霉病菌单孢分离方法-平板稀释画线分离法. 植物保护, 2008, 34(6): 134-136. | |
33 | Barnett H L, Hunter B B. Illustrated genera of imperfect fungi. Beijing: Science Press, 1977. |
巴尼特H L, 亨特B B. 半知菌属图解. 北京: 科学出版社, 1977. | |
34 | Wang G C, Zheng Z, Ye Q M, et al. Common guidebook for identification of Fusarium. Beijing: China Agriculture Science and Technology Press, 1996. |
王拱辰, 郑重, 叶琪明, 等. 常见镰刀菌鉴定指南. 北京: 中国农业科技出版社, 1996. | |
35 | Lu J Y. Plant pathogenic mycology. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2001. |
陆家云. 植物病原真菌学. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2001. | |
36 | Booth C. The genus Fusarium. Beijing: Agriculture Press, 1988. |
布斯C. 镰刀菌属. 北京: 农业出版社, 1988. | |
37 | Nelson P E, Toussoun T A, Marasas W F O. Fusarium species: An illustrated manual for identification. America: The Pennsylvania State University Press, 1983. |
38 | Guo Y X, Guo Z P, Zhang J X, et al. Study on pathogenicity of Fusarium acuminatum and disease resistance of alfalfa varieties. Acta Phytopathologica Sinica, 2018, 48(2): 213-222. |
郭玉霞, 郭志鹏, 张靖雪, 等. 锐顶镰孢致病性及苜蓿品种间的抗病性研究. 植物病理学报, 2018, 48(2): 213-222. | |
39 | Li C J, Nan Z B. Seed-borne fungi of lucerne and their pathogenicity to lucerne seed and seedling. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2000, 9(1): 27-36. |
李春杰, 南志标. 苜蓿种带真菌及其致病性测定. 草业学报, 2000, 9(1): 27-36 | |
40 | Turner V, Van Alfen N K. Crown rot of alfalfa in Utah. Phytopathology, 1983, 73(9): 1333-1337. |
41 | Gui X H. Study on biological characteristics of the pathogen of Fusarium causing alfalfa root-rot. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2019. |
贵晓荷. 紫花苜蓿根腐病病原镰刀菌的生物学特性研究. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2019. | |
42 | Bailey K, Lazarovits G. Suppressing soil-borne diseases with residue management and organic amendments. Soil and Tillage Research, 2003, 72(2): 169-180. |
43 | Li Y Z, Yu J Q, Li M. Preliminary evaluation of 48 alfalfa varieties for resistance to three diseases. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2021, 30(9): 62-75. |
李彦忠, 喻军强, 李明. 48个苜蓿品种对3种病害抗性的初步评价. 草业学报, 2021, 30(9): 62-75. | |
44 | Zhi X X, Zhang F, Yang Q C, et al. Evaluation of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) germplasm accessions resistance to Fusarium root rot. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2022, 44(4): 104-112. |
支旭欣, 张帆, 杨青川, 等. 紫花苜蓿镰刀菌根腐病抗病种质资源筛选. 中国草地学报, 2022, 44(4): 104-112. | |
45 | Guo Y X. Root-invading fungi of alfalfa and their pathogenicity in different ecologic areas. Zhengzhou: Henan Agricultural University, 2010. |
郭玉霞. 不同生态区苜蓿根部入侵真菌研究. 郑州: 河南农业大学, 2010. | |
46 | Ding S Y. Studied on alfalfa varieties resistance and induced resistance to Fusarium. Lanzhou: Gansu Agricultural University, 2010. |
丁守彦. 不同苜蓿品种对镰刀菌的抗性鉴定及诱导抗性研究. 兰州: 甘肃农业大学, 2010. | |
47 | Jiang D, Xu C, Han W, et al. Identification of fungal pathogens and analysis of genetic diversity of Fusarium tricinctum causing root rots of alfalfa in north-east China. Plant Pathology, 2021, 70(4): 804-814. |
48 | Dobosz R, Krawczyk R. Precrop effect of red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) on the population development of the northern root-knot nematode Meloidogyne hapla Chitwood, 1949 and on succeeding crops-A pot study. Agronomy, 2021, 11(4): 722. |
49 | Hong C, Moorman G. Plant pathogens in irrigation water: Challenges and opportunities. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 2005, 24(3): 189-208. |
50 | Abbas A, Mubeen M, Sohail M A, et al. Root rot a silent alfalfa killer in China: Distribution, fungal, and oomycete pathogens, impact of climatic factors and its management. Frontiers in Microbiology, 2022, 13: 961794. |
51 | Rubiales D, Fondevilla S, Chen W, et al. Achievements and challenges in legume breeding for pest and disease resistance. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 2015, 34(1/2/3): 195-236. |
[1] | Xuan-shuai LIU, Yan-liang SUN, Chun-hui MA, Qian-bing ZHANG. Dry matter yield and spatial distribution characteristics of phosphorus in alfalfa under bacterial-phosphorus coupling [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(9): 104-115. |
[2] | Yong-hong SHI, Peng GAO, Zhi-hong FANG, Xiang ZHAO, Wei HAN, Jiang-ming WEI, Lin LIU, Jin-zhen LI. Evaluation of resistance to Colletotrichum cereale and analysis of loss in a field of fifteen imported oat cultivars [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(9): 130-142. |
[3] | Rui XU, Zheng WANG, Yi-ming WANG, Lian-tai SU, Li GAO, Peng ZHOU, Yuan AN. Effect of alfalfa on the yield and sucrose metabolism of rice in an alfalfa-rice rotation system [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(8): 129-140. |
[4] | Bao-qiang WANG, Wen-jing MA, Xian WANG, Xiao-lin ZHU, Ying ZHAO, Xiao-hong WEI. Nitric oxide regulation of secondary metabolite accumulation in Medicago sativa seedlings under drought stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(8): 141-151. |
[5] | Jing-jing JIANG, Ai-chang CHEN, Zhou-quan WEI, Xing-ming SUN, Mei-rong XU, Xue-ping LI, Hui DU, Yong-hong QI. Identification of Fusarium species from Scutellaria baicalensis root rot in Longxi, Gansu Province and effects on element contents of root [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(7): 109-121. |
[6] | Wen-qing LING, Lei ZHANG, Jue LI, Qi-xian FENG, Yan LI, Yi ZHOU, Yi-jia LIU, Fu-lin YANG, Jing ZHOU. Effects of Lentilactobacillus buchneri combined with different sugars on nutrient composition, fermentation quality, rumen degradation rate, and aerobic stability of alfalfa silage [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(7): 122-134. |
[7] | Rui-jie YANG, Shu-qin HE, Shu-feng ZHOU, Jing-yue YANG, Yu-xian JIN, Zi-cheng ZHENG. Root regulation of soil scourability in hybrid sorghum grass during the growing period [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(7): 149-159. |
[8] | Shao-peng WANG, Jia LIU, Jun HONG, Ji-zhen LIN, Yi ZHANG, Kun SHI, Zan WANG. Cloning and function analysis of MsPPR1 in alfalfa under drought stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(7): 49-60. |
[9] | Wen-juan WANG, Shang-li SHI, Long HE, Bei WU, Chan-chan LIU. Accumulation and functions of polyamines in plants under drought stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(6): 186-202. |
[10] | Xiao-xia AN, Ying-ying ZHANG, Chun-hui MA, Man LI, Qian-bing ZHANG. Effects of phosphorus application and inoculation with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on alfalfa yield and phosphorus use efficiency [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(6): 71-84. |
[11] | Ting YE, Xiao-juan WU, Yi-xiao LU, Sheng-juan LIU, Zhuo-hui JIANG, Hui-min YANG. Effect of planting ratio on the stability of forage yield and population density in two alfalfa-grass mixtures [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(5): 127-137. |
[12] | Shi-min ZHANG, Jiao-yang ZHAO, Hui-sen ZHU, Kai WEI, Yong-xin WANG. Effects of selenium on metabolic transformation and morphogenesis in different varieties of alfalfa during the germination stage [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(4): 79-90. |
[13] | Yuan WANG, Jing WANG, Shu-xia LI. Cloning of MsBBX24 from alfalfa (Medicago sativa) and determination of its role in salt tolerance [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 107-117. |
[14] | Shou-jiang SUN, Yi-han TANG, Wen MA, Man-li LI, Pei-sheng MAO. Response of the mitochondrial AsA-GSH cycle during alfalfa seed germination under low temperature stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 152-162. |
[15] | Xuan-shuai LIU, Yan-liang SUN, Xiao-xia AN, Chun-hui MA, Qian-bing ZHANG. Effects of phosphorus application and inoculation with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and phosphorus-solubilizing bacteria on the photosynthetic characteristics and biomass of alfalfa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 189-199. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||