Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2023, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (4): 161-172.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2022311
Zhen-fen ZHANG1,2(), Rong HUANG1,2, Bo YAO1,2, Wang-dong ZHANG3, Cheng-de YANG4, Xiu-rong CHEN4
Received:
2022-08-02
Revised:
2022-09-05
Online:
2023-04-20
Published:
2023-01-29
Contact:
Zhen-fen ZHANG
Zhen-fen ZHANG, Rong HUANG, Bo YAO, Wang-dong ZHANG, Cheng-de YANG, Xiu-rong CHEN. Culturable seed-borne bacteria of lucerne imported from Europe and North America and their pathogenicity to plants and animals[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(4): 161-172.
编号 Code | 紫花苜蓿品种 M. sativa variety | 产地 Production region | 生产年份 Production year | 提供者 Seed provider |
---|---|---|---|---|
Lot1 | 皇冠Phabulous | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot2 | SR4030 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot3 | 巨能551 Magnum 551 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot4 | 耐盐之星Magnum Salt | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot5 | 斯贝德Spade | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot6 | 维多利亚Victory | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot7 | 巨能995 Magnum 995 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot8 | 英斯特Inster | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot9 | 威神Vision | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot10 | MT4015 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot11 | 驯鹿Caribou | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot12 | SK3010 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot13 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot14 | MF4020 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot15 | 巨能601 Magnum 601 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot16 | 巨能7-耐湿Magnum 7-Wet | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot17 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot18 | 巨能801 Magnum 801 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot19 | 旱地Handi | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot20 | 金皇后Golden empress | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot21 | 阿尔冈金Algonguin | 北美North America | 2015 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot22 | 梅佐Mezzo | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot23 | 直布罗陀Gibraltar | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot24 | 超新星Super Nova | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot25 | 特蕾莎TEREZA | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot26 | 法多FADO | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot27 | 劲能4.2 Power 4.2 | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot28 | 玛格达Magda | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot29 | 富通Fortune | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot30 | 瑞诺Creno | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot31 | 萨斯卡娅Saskia | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot32 | PS2065MF | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot33 | 希模Sibemol | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot34 | 莎莎Salsa | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Table 1 Origin and information of seed samples tested
编号 Code | 紫花苜蓿品种 M. sativa variety | 产地 Production region | 生产年份 Production year | 提供者 Seed provider |
---|---|---|---|---|
Lot1 | 皇冠Phabulous | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot2 | SR4030 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot3 | 巨能551 Magnum 551 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot4 | 耐盐之星Magnum Salt | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot5 | 斯贝德Spade | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot6 | 维多利亚Victory | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot7 | 巨能995 Magnum 995 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot8 | 英斯特Inster | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot9 | 威神Vision | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot10 | MT4015 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot11 | 驯鹿Caribou | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot12 | SK3010 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot13 | 巨能7 Magnum 7 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot14 | MF4020 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot15 | 巨能601 Magnum 601 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot16 | 巨能7-耐湿Magnum 7-Wet | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot17 | 巨能2 Magnum 2 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot18 | 巨能801 Magnum 801 | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot19 | 旱地Handi | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot20 | 金皇后Golden empress | 北美North America | 2014 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot21 | 阿尔冈金Algonguin | 北美North America | 2015 | 北京克劳沃公司Beijing Clover Company |
Lot22 | 梅佐Mezzo | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot23 | 直布罗陀Gibraltar | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot24 | 超新星Super Nova | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot25 | 特蕾莎TEREZA | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot26 | 法多FADO | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot27 | 劲能4.2 Power 4.2 | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot28 | 玛格达Magda | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot29 | 富通Fortune | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot30 | 瑞诺Creno | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot31 | 萨斯卡娅Saskia | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot32 | PS2065MF | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot33 | 希模Sibemol | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
Lot34 | 莎莎Salsa | 欧洲Europe | 2015 | 丹农种子集团Dannong Seeds Bloc |
编号 Code | 种带细菌总数量 Number of the colony (CFU·g-1) | 种带细菌种群数 The number of bacterial population | 优势种群 (前2位) The top two dominant bacterial population | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
未消毒Non-sterilized | 消毒Surface sterilized | 未消毒Non-sterilized | 消毒Surface sterilized | ||
Lot1 | 1.70×107p * | 3.70×106i | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR17,ZSR18 |
Lot2 | 5.16×107j * | 3.30×106ij | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZF1,ZF23 |
Lot3 | 8.80×106q * | 1.15×106no | 3.33±0.67e | 1.33±0.33b | YCK6,YCK61 |
Lot4 | 1.43×106s | 7.00×105op | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR20,ZSR21 |
Lot5 | 3.50×106r * | 1.70×105p | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.88a | TM1,ZS3 |
Lot6 | 6.30×105t * | 2.20×105p | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZS6,CQ10 |
Lot7 | 1.80×107p * | 2.00×106m | 3.00±0.00e | 2.00±0.58ab | CQ10,ZS6 |
Lot8 | 2.18×108c * | 4.30×107b | 3.33±0.58e | 2.33±0.67ab | ZSR27,ZSR28 |
Lot9 | 5.15×107j * | 8.00×106g | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | YCK4,YCK5 |
Lot10 | 4.80×107k * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | YCK2,ZFSH4 |
Lot11 | 6.52×107g * | 2.70×106kl | 3.67±0.33de * | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR33,ZSR30 |
Lot12 | 3.67×107m * | 9.00×106f | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR18,ZSR31 |
Lot13 | 4.26×107l * | 1.70×106mn | 3.33±0.67e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR19,ZSR32 |
Lot14 | 6.20×107h * | 2.20×106lm | 3.33±0.67e | 3.33±0.88a | ZSR17,ZSR28 |
Lot15 | 3.78×107m * | 2.00×106m | 6.00±0.58bc * | 2.00±0.58ab | ZF1,ZF23 |
Lot16 | 3.80×107m * | 4.30×106h | 7.33±0.33ab * | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR17,ZSR18 |
Lot17 | 5.50×107 i * | 8.00×106g | 5.33±0.33cd * | 3.33±0.33a | ZF23,QH1 |
Lot18 | 5.26×107j * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZF11,CH1 |
Lot19 | 5.52×107i * | 2.70×105p | 3.67±0.67de | 2.33±0.33ab | ZF32,GCKH |
Lot20 | 1.21×108e * | 6.70×107a | 2.67±0.67e | 3.33±0.33a | GCKH,R1 |
Lot21 | 3.37×108b * | 1.16×107e | 3.00±0.58e | 2.00±0.58ab | R1,ZF1 |
Lot22 | 4.50×108a * | 1.50×107d | 2.67±0.67e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR18,ZSR19 |
Lot23 | 6.60×106 r * | 2.00×105p | 7.67±0.88a * | 2.00±0.58ab | YCK5,YCK51 |
Lot24 | 9.70×106q * | 3.70×105p | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.88ab | ZSR29,ZSR31 |
Lot25 | 2.16×108d * | 3.30×107c | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR30,ZSR32 |
Lot26 | 8.78×107f * | 1.11×106no | 3.33±0.88e | 1.33±0.33b | ZFSH3,ZFSH4 |
Lot27 | 1.67×107p | 9.00×106f | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | TM1,YCK4 |
Lot28 | 3.26×107n * | 1.70×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | TM1,QH1 |
Lot29 | 5.25×107j * | 2.20×106lm | 5.33±0.88cd * | 3.33±0.88a | ZSR22,ZSR23 |
Lot30 | 2.78×107o * | 2.00×106m | 3.00±0.58e | 2.00±0.58ab | ZS3,ZS6 |
Lot31 | 4.80×107k * | 4.30×106h | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.67ab | ZS3,CQ10 |
Lot32 | 5.50×107i * | 8.00×106g | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR23,ZSR24 |
Lot33 | 5.26×107j * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR25,ZSR26 |
Lot34 | 5.53×107i * | 2.70×106jk | 3.67±0.33de | 2.33±0.33ab | CQ10,ZS3 |
Table 2 Seed-borne bacteria population and quantity of different varieties lucerne collected from the different locations
编号 Code | 种带细菌总数量 Number of the colony (CFU·g-1) | 种带细菌种群数 The number of bacterial population | 优势种群 (前2位) The top two dominant bacterial population | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
未消毒Non-sterilized | 消毒Surface sterilized | 未消毒Non-sterilized | 消毒Surface sterilized | ||
Lot1 | 1.70×107p * | 3.70×106i | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR17,ZSR18 |
Lot2 | 5.16×107j * | 3.30×106ij | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZF1,ZF23 |
Lot3 | 8.80×106q * | 1.15×106no | 3.33±0.67e | 1.33±0.33b | YCK6,YCK61 |
Lot4 | 1.43×106s | 7.00×105op | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR20,ZSR21 |
Lot5 | 3.50×106r * | 1.70×105p | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.88a | TM1,ZS3 |
Lot6 | 6.30×105t * | 2.20×105p | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZS6,CQ10 |
Lot7 | 1.80×107p * | 2.00×106m | 3.00±0.00e | 2.00±0.58ab | CQ10,ZS6 |
Lot8 | 2.18×108c * | 4.30×107b | 3.33±0.58e | 2.33±0.67ab | ZSR27,ZSR28 |
Lot9 | 5.15×107j * | 8.00×106g | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | YCK4,YCK5 |
Lot10 | 4.80×107k * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | YCK2,ZFSH4 |
Lot11 | 6.52×107g * | 2.70×106kl | 3.67±0.33de * | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR33,ZSR30 |
Lot12 | 3.67×107m * | 9.00×106f | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR18,ZSR31 |
Lot13 | 4.26×107l * | 1.70×106mn | 3.33±0.67e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR19,ZSR32 |
Lot14 | 6.20×107h * | 2.20×106lm | 3.33±0.67e | 3.33±0.88a | ZSR17,ZSR28 |
Lot15 | 3.78×107m * | 2.00×106m | 6.00±0.58bc * | 2.00±0.58ab | ZF1,ZF23 |
Lot16 | 3.80×107m * | 4.30×106h | 7.33±0.33ab * | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR17,ZSR18 |
Lot17 | 5.50×107 i * | 8.00×106g | 5.33±0.33cd * | 3.33±0.33a | ZF23,QH1 |
Lot18 | 5.26×107j * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZF11,CH1 |
Lot19 | 5.52×107i * | 2.70×105p | 3.67±0.67de | 2.33±0.33ab | ZF32,GCKH |
Lot20 | 1.21×108e * | 6.70×107a | 2.67±0.67e | 3.33±0.33a | GCKH,R1 |
Lot21 | 3.37×108b * | 1.16×107e | 3.00±0.58e | 2.00±0.58ab | R1,ZF1 |
Lot22 | 4.50×108a * | 1.50×107d | 2.67±0.67e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR18,ZSR19 |
Lot23 | 6.60×106 r * | 2.00×105p | 7.67±0.88a * | 2.00±0.58ab | YCK5,YCK51 |
Lot24 | 9.70×106q * | 3.70×105p | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.88ab | ZSR29,ZSR31 |
Lot25 | 2.16×108d * | 3.30×107c | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR30,ZSR32 |
Lot26 | 8.78×107f * | 1.11×106no | 3.33±0.88e | 1.33±0.33b | ZFSH3,ZFSH4 |
Lot27 | 1.67×107p | 9.00×106f | 2.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | TM1,YCK4 |
Lot28 | 3.26×107n * | 1.70×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 3.33±0.33a | TM1,QH1 |
Lot29 | 5.25×107j * | 2.20×106lm | 5.33±0.88cd * | 3.33±0.88a | ZSR22,ZSR23 |
Lot30 | 2.78×107o * | 2.00×106m | 3.00±0.58e | 2.00±0.58ab | ZS3,ZS6 |
Lot31 | 4.80×107k * | 4.30×106h | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.67ab | ZS3,CQ10 |
Lot32 | 5.50×107i * | 8.00×106g | 3.33±0.88e | 3.33±0.33a | ZSR23,ZSR24 |
Lot33 | 5.26×107j * | 1.60×106mn | 3.33±0.33e | 2.33±0.33ab | ZSR25,ZSR26 |
Lot34 | 5.53×107i * | 2.70×106jk | 3.67±0.33de | 2.33±0.33ab | CQ10,ZS3 |
菌株 Strain | 大小 Size (μm) | 革兰氏染色 Gram stain | NCBI中相似菌株 Similar strain | 相似度 Similarity (%) | 登录号 Genebank accession |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ZSR17 | 0.37~0.60×0.78~2.28 | - | 不动杆菌属Acinetobacter sp. | 99 | KY312517 |
ZSR18 | 0.60~1.10×0.89~2.34 | - | 假单胞菌属Pseudomonas sp. | 99 | KY312518 |
ZSR19 | 0.19~0.57×0.35~3.61 | - | 肠杆菌属Enterobacter sp. | 99 | KY436203 |
ZSR20 | 0.31~0.66×0.78~3.05 | + | 萎缩芽孢杆菌Bacillus atrophaeus | 99 | KY436204 |
ZSR21 | 0.34~0.69×0.43~1.65 | + | 微杆菌属Microbacterium sp. | 99 | KY436205 |
ZSR22 | 0.38~0.84×0.54~2.77 | + | 奇异假芽孢杆菌Fictibacillus barbaricus | 99 | KY436206 |
ZSR23 | 0.43~0.89×0.82~4.19 | + | 耐寒短芽孢杆菌Brevibacillus frigoritolerans | 99 | KY436207 |
ZSR24 | 0.38~0.69×0.78~2.34 | - | 浅黄假单胞菌Pseudomonas luteola | 99 | KY436208 |
ZSR25 | 0.26~0.49×0.42~1.12 | - | 埃希氏菌属Escherichia sp. | 99 | KY436209 |
ZSR26 | 0.60~1.20×1.65~6.67 | + | 内生芽孢杆菌Bacillus endophyticus | 99 | KY436210 |
ZSR27 | 0.69~1.39×1.57~11.54 | + | 嗜盐土地芽孢杆菌Terribacillus saccharophilus | 99 | KY436211 |
ZSR28 | 0.25~0.56×0.69~2.86 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌Bacillus simplex | 100 | KY436212 |
ZSR29 | 0.54~1.20×2.04~5.96 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436213 |
ZSR30 | 0.53~1.03×1.84×7.73 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436214 |
ZSR31 | 0.62~1.33×2.72~7.57 | + | 奇异假芽孢杆菌F. barbaricus | 99 | KY436215 |
ZSR32 | 0.46~0.94×1.52~5.77 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436216 |
ZSR33 | 0.60~1.62×1.46~3.46 | + | 耐寒短芽孢杆菌B. frigoritolerans | 99 | KY436217 |
ZF9 | 0.73~1.17×3.84~11.09 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌Bacillus cereus | 99 | KX784910 |
ZFSH2 | 0.38~0.73×1.30~5.74 | + | 短小芽孢杆菌Bacillus pumilus | 99 | KX784911 |
ZF1 | 0.57~1.40×1.62~7.00 | - | 欧文氏菌属Erwinia sp. | 99 | KX784912 |
ZF23 | 1.28~3.83×2.10~4.78 | + | 地衣芽孢杆菌Bacillus licheniformis | 99 | KX784914 |
QH1 | 0.65~1.53×1.84~7.32 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784915 |
ZF11 | 0.50~1.03×0.57~1.82 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784916 |
CH1 | 0.49~0.73×1.49~3.50 | + | 葡萄球菌属Staphylococcus sp. | 99 | KX784917 |
ZF32 | 0.45~0.85×1.27~4.23 | + | 枯草芽孢杆菌Bacillus subtilis | 99 | KX784918 |
GCKH | 0.34~0.99×0.49~1.50 | + | 红球菌属Rhodococcus sp. | 99 | KX784919 |
R1 | 0.36~0.85×0.68~2.75 | - | 变异马赛菌Massilia varians | 99 | KX784920 |
YCK61 | 0.36~0.69×0.61~2.14 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784921 |
YCK6 | 0.30~0.58×0.57~1.40 | + | 氧化假节杆菌Pseudarthrobacter oxydans | 99 | KX784922 |
YCK51 | 0.37~0.66×0.99~2.69 | + | 硬结假节杆菌Pseudarthrobacter scleromae | 99 | KX784923 |
YCK5 | 0.36~0.85×0.69~1.87 | - | 短杆状马赛菌Massilia brevitalea | 99 | KX784924 |
YCK4 | 0.46~1.21×1.02~3.20 | - | 栖稻假单胞菌Pseudomonas oryzihabitans | 99 | KX784925 |
YCK2 | 0.31~0.55×0.43~1.63 | + | 土壤短芽孢杆菌Brevibacillus agri | 99 | KX784926 |
ZFSH4 | 0.34~0.55×0.62~2.95 | - | 恶臭假单胞菌Pseudomonas putida | 99 | KX784927 |
ZFSH3 | 0.26~0.60×0.94~3.54 | - | 蒂莫内马赛菌Massilia timonae | 99 | KX676495 |
TM1 | 0.46~0.86×0.84~1.96 | - | 铜绿假单胞菌Pseudomonas aeruginosa | 99 | KY305014 |
ZS3 | 0.31~0.55×0.43~1.63 | - | 大黄欧文氏菌Erwinia rhapontici | 99 | KY495782 |
ZS6 | 0.34~0.55×0.62~2.65 | - | 成团泛菌Pantoea agglomerans | 99 | KT454095 |
CQ10 | 0.46~0.86×0.84~1.96 | - | 泛菌属Pantoea sp. | 99 | KT355269 |
Table 3 Identification of 39 bacterial strains from alfalfa seeds
菌株 Strain | 大小 Size (μm) | 革兰氏染色 Gram stain | NCBI中相似菌株 Similar strain | 相似度 Similarity (%) | 登录号 Genebank accession |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ZSR17 | 0.37~0.60×0.78~2.28 | - | 不动杆菌属Acinetobacter sp. | 99 | KY312517 |
ZSR18 | 0.60~1.10×0.89~2.34 | - | 假单胞菌属Pseudomonas sp. | 99 | KY312518 |
ZSR19 | 0.19~0.57×0.35~3.61 | - | 肠杆菌属Enterobacter sp. | 99 | KY436203 |
ZSR20 | 0.31~0.66×0.78~3.05 | + | 萎缩芽孢杆菌Bacillus atrophaeus | 99 | KY436204 |
ZSR21 | 0.34~0.69×0.43~1.65 | + | 微杆菌属Microbacterium sp. | 99 | KY436205 |
ZSR22 | 0.38~0.84×0.54~2.77 | + | 奇异假芽孢杆菌Fictibacillus barbaricus | 99 | KY436206 |
ZSR23 | 0.43~0.89×0.82~4.19 | + | 耐寒短芽孢杆菌Brevibacillus frigoritolerans | 99 | KY436207 |
ZSR24 | 0.38~0.69×0.78~2.34 | - | 浅黄假单胞菌Pseudomonas luteola | 99 | KY436208 |
ZSR25 | 0.26~0.49×0.42~1.12 | - | 埃希氏菌属Escherichia sp. | 99 | KY436209 |
ZSR26 | 0.60~1.20×1.65~6.67 | + | 内生芽孢杆菌Bacillus endophyticus | 99 | KY436210 |
ZSR27 | 0.69~1.39×1.57~11.54 | + | 嗜盐土地芽孢杆菌Terribacillus saccharophilus | 99 | KY436211 |
ZSR28 | 0.25~0.56×0.69~2.86 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌Bacillus simplex | 100 | KY436212 |
ZSR29 | 0.54~1.20×2.04~5.96 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436213 |
ZSR30 | 0.53~1.03×1.84×7.73 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436214 |
ZSR31 | 0.62~1.33×2.72~7.57 | + | 奇异假芽孢杆菌F. barbaricus | 99 | KY436215 |
ZSR32 | 0.46~0.94×1.52~5.77 | + | 简单芽孢杆菌B. simplex | 99 | KY436216 |
ZSR33 | 0.60~1.62×1.46~3.46 | + | 耐寒短芽孢杆菌B. frigoritolerans | 99 | KY436217 |
ZF9 | 0.73~1.17×3.84~11.09 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌Bacillus cereus | 99 | KX784910 |
ZFSH2 | 0.38~0.73×1.30~5.74 | + | 短小芽孢杆菌Bacillus pumilus | 99 | KX784911 |
ZF1 | 0.57~1.40×1.62~7.00 | - | 欧文氏菌属Erwinia sp. | 99 | KX784912 |
ZF23 | 1.28~3.83×2.10~4.78 | + | 地衣芽孢杆菌Bacillus licheniformis | 99 | KX784914 |
QH1 | 0.65~1.53×1.84~7.32 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784915 |
ZF11 | 0.50~1.03×0.57~1.82 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784916 |
CH1 | 0.49~0.73×1.49~3.50 | + | 葡萄球菌属Staphylococcus sp. | 99 | KX784917 |
ZF32 | 0.45~0.85×1.27~4.23 | + | 枯草芽孢杆菌Bacillus subtilis | 99 | KX784918 |
GCKH | 0.34~0.99×0.49~1.50 | + | 红球菌属Rhodococcus sp. | 99 | KX784919 |
R1 | 0.36~0.85×0.68~2.75 | - | 变异马赛菌Massilia varians | 99 | KX784920 |
YCK61 | 0.36~0.69×0.61~2.14 | + | 蜡样芽孢杆菌B. cereus | 99 | KX784921 |
YCK6 | 0.30~0.58×0.57~1.40 | + | 氧化假节杆菌Pseudarthrobacter oxydans | 99 | KX784922 |
YCK51 | 0.37~0.66×0.99~2.69 | + | 硬结假节杆菌Pseudarthrobacter scleromae | 99 | KX784923 |
YCK5 | 0.36~0.85×0.69~1.87 | - | 短杆状马赛菌Massilia brevitalea | 99 | KX784924 |
YCK4 | 0.46~1.21×1.02~3.20 | - | 栖稻假单胞菌Pseudomonas oryzihabitans | 99 | KX784925 |
YCK2 | 0.31~0.55×0.43~1.63 | + | 土壤短芽孢杆菌Brevibacillus agri | 99 | KX784926 |
ZFSH4 | 0.34~0.55×0.62~2.95 | - | 恶臭假单胞菌Pseudomonas putida | 99 | KX784927 |
ZFSH3 | 0.26~0.60×0.94~3.54 | - | 蒂莫内马赛菌Massilia timonae | 99 | KX676495 |
TM1 | 0.46~0.86×0.84~1.96 | - | 铜绿假单胞菌Pseudomonas aeruginosa | 99 | KY305014 |
ZS3 | 0.31~0.55×0.43~1.63 | - | 大黄欧文氏菌Erwinia rhapontici | 99 | KY495782 |
ZS6 | 0.34~0.55×0.62~2.65 | - | 成团泛菌Pantoea agglomerans | 99 | KT454095 |
CQ10 | 0.46~0.86×0.84~1.96 | - | 泛菌属Pantoea sp. | 99 | KT355269 |
菌株 Strain | 紫花苜蓿Lucerne | 小白鼠 Mice | |
---|---|---|---|
皿内发芽Petri plate germination | 盆栽Pot culture | ||
ZSR17 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZSR18 | - | - | - |
ZSR19 | - | - | - |
ZSR20 | - | - | - |
ZSR21 | - | - | - |
ZSR22 | - | - | - |
ZSR23 | - | - | - |
ZSR25 | - | - | +腹泻、寒颤Diarrhea, shivering |
ZSR27 | - | - | - |
ZF9 | - | - | - |
ZF1 | +萎蔫Wilt | +萎蔫Wilt | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
CH1 | - | - | - |
GCKH | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | - |
R1 | - | - | +腹泻、寒颤Diarrhea, shivering |
YCK6 | - | - | - |
YCK5 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZFSH3 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
TM1 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZS3 | +萎蔫Wilt | +萎蔫Wilt | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZS6 | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
CQ10 | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
Table 4 The pathogenicity of tested bacterial strains
菌株 Strain | 紫花苜蓿Lucerne | 小白鼠 Mice | |
---|---|---|---|
皿内发芽Petri plate germination | 盆栽Pot culture | ||
ZSR17 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZSR18 | - | - | - |
ZSR19 | - | - | - |
ZSR20 | - | - | - |
ZSR21 | - | - | - |
ZSR22 | - | - | - |
ZSR23 | - | - | - |
ZSR25 | - | - | +腹泻、寒颤Diarrhea, shivering |
ZSR27 | - | - | - |
ZF9 | - | - | - |
ZF1 | +萎蔫Wilt | +萎蔫Wilt | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
CH1 | - | - | - |
GCKH | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | - |
R1 | - | - | +腹泻、寒颤Diarrhea, shivering |
YCK6 | - | - | - |
YCK5 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZFSH3 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
TM1 | - | - | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZS3 | +萎蔫Wilt | +萎蔫Wilt | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
ZS6 | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
CQ10 | +叶斑Leaf spot | +叶斑Leaf spot | +厌食、寒颤Anorexia, shivering |
1 | Qi Z Q, Yu Y X, Hu Y G, et al. Current status and future tasks of the Medicago sativa industry in China. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2008, 17(1): 107-113. |
戚志强, 玉永雄, 胡跃高, 等. 当前我国苜蓿产业发展的形势与任务. 草业学报, 2008, 17(1): 107-113. | |
2 | Phelan P, Moloney A P, Mcgeough E J, et al. Forage legumes for grazing and conserving in ruminant production systems. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 2015, 34(1/2/3): 281-326. |
3 | Guo Y X, Nan Z B, Wang C Z, et al. Progress in research on root invading fungi of Medicago sativa. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2009, 18(5): 243-249. |
郭玉霞, 南志标, 王成章, 等. 苜蓿根部入侵真菌研究进展. 草业学报, 2009, 18(5): 243-249. | |
4 | Xia S Y, Wang C Z. The bioactivities of alfalfa and its applications status. Food and Nutrition in China, 2010(2): 27-30. |
夏素银, 王成章. 紫花苜蓿生物活性与应用的研究现状. 中国食物与营养, 2010(2): 27-30. | |
5 | Wu H Y. Research progress on the chemical components of alfalfa. Inner Mongolia Petrochemical, 2010, 36(24): 18-19. |
武海燕.紫花苜蓿化学成分的研究进展. 内蒙古石油化工, 2010, 36(24): 18-19. | |
6 | Zhao X X, Yang C. International trade patterns and prediction of import and export of grass seeds in China. Pratacultural Science, 2020, 37(8): 1646-1655. |
赵馨馨, 杨春. 我国草种子国际贸易格局及进出口量预测. 草业科学, 2020, 37(8): 1646-1655. | |
7 | Liu Y Z, Wang M L, Yang C, et al. Study on the international trade pattern of herbage seeds in China and its enlightenment. Pratacultural Science, 2012, 29(7): 1176-1181. |
刘亚钊, 王明利, 杨春, 等. 中国牧草种子国际贸易格局研究及启示. 草业科学, 2012, 29(7): 1176-1181. | |
8 | Liu J W. Rapid development of the grass seeds career in China. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2016, 24(3): 483-484. |
刘加文. 大力发展中国草种业. 草地学报, 2016, 24(3): 483-484. | |
9 | Nan Z B. Alfalfa disease and its comprehensive control system in China. Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2001(4): 81-84. |
南志标. 我国的苜蓿病害及其综合防治体系. 动物科学与动物医学, 2001(4): 81-84. | |
10 | Barak J D, Schroeder B K. Interrelationships of food safety and plant pathology: The life cycle of human pathogens on plants. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 2012, 50: 241-266. |
11 | Yao B, Huang R, Zhang Z, et al. Seed-borne Erwinia persicina affects the growth and physiology of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). Frontiers in Microbiology, 2022, DOI: 10.3389/fmicb.2022.891188. |
12 | Nemeth J, Laszlo E, Emodyl. Clavibacter michiganensis ssp. insidiosus. EPPO Bulletin, 2010, 40: 353-364. |
13 | Zhang Z F, Nan Z B. First report of Erwinia persicinus causing wilting of Medicago sativa sprouts in China. Plant Disease, 2012, 96: 454. |
14 | Zhang Z F, Nan Z B. Occurrence of lucerne seedborne Enterobacter cloacae sprouts decay in Gansu Province of China. European Journal of Plant Pathology, 2013, 135: 5-9. |
15 | Fu H L, Li Y, Du D D, et al. Gene analysis of Salmonella enteritidis on three type secrete systemfrom calves. Journal of Shandong Agricultural University (Natural Science), 2013, 44(2): 181-184. |
付红蕾, 李彦, 杜冬冬, 等. 牛源性肠炎沙门氏菌的三型分泌系统基因分析. 山东农业大学学报(自然科学版), 2013, 44(2): 181-184. | |
16 | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Multistate outbreak of Salmonella reading and Salmonella abony infections linked to alfalfa sprouts (Final Update). https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/reading-08-16/index.html, 2016-09-30/2021-11-15. |
17 | Xia X X, Liu J, Wang Y S, et al. Novel biological products for prevention and control of bacterial zoonoses I. establishment of the hybridoma producing monoclonal antibodies against enterohemorrhagic E. coli O157∶H7. Jiangsu Agricultural Journal, 2009, 25(2): 291-295. |
夏兴霞, 刘洁, 王永山, 等. 动物源性人兽共患细菌病防控生物新制剂的研究Ⅰ.分泌抗大肠杆菌O157∶H7单克隆抗体杂交瘤细胞株的建立. 江苏农业学报, 2009, 25(2): 291-295. | |
18 | Zhang Z F, Shi S L. Identification and biological attributes of seed-borne bacteria isolated from lucerne cv. Gannong No.3. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2018, 27(1): 152-160. |
张振粉, 师尚礼. 甘农三号紫花苜蓿种带细菌的生物功能分析及鉴定. 草业学报, 2018, 27(1): 152-160. | |
19 | Hong Q H, Chi J, Qi Y, et al. Analysing reasons of influencing results of Gram staining. Experimental Technology and Management, 2011, 28(5): 41-43. |
洪庆华, 迟杰, 齐云, 等. 影响革兰氏染色结果的原因分析. 实验技术与管理, 2011, 28(5): 41-43. | |
20 | Chen Z B, Xia Z Y, Lei L P, et al. Study on population density and distribution characteristics of endophytic bacteria in tobacco in Yunnan. Southwest China Journal of Agricultural Science, 2014, 27(2): 682-687. |
陈泽斌, 夏振远, 雷丽萍, 等.云南烟草内生细菌菌群密度及分布特征. 西南农业学报, 2014, 27(2): 682-687. | |
21 | Zhang G X, Mao Q, He Z Y, et al. Detection of nitrogenase activity and phosphorus dissolving ability of endophytic isolates from Oryza rufipogon in Lingshui. Chinese Journal of Applied and Environmental Biology, 2006(4): 457-460. |
张国霞, 茅庆, 何忠义, 等. 陵水普通野生稻(Oryza rufipogon)内生菌的固氮及溶磷特性. 应用与环境生物学报, 2006(4): 457-460. | |
22 | Zhang Z F, Su J, Yang C D, et al. Preliminary study on isolation and identification of seed-borne Cronobacter sakazakii from lucerne (Medicago sativa) and determination of its pathogenicity. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2018, 27(8): 130-141. |
张振粉, 苏静, 杨成德, 等. 紫花苜蓿种带阪崎克罗诺杆菌的分离鉴定及其致病性初步研究. 草业学报, 2018, 27(8): 130-141. | |
23 | Pagotto F J, Nazarowec-white M, Bidawid S, et al. Enterobacter sakazakii: Infectivity and enterotoxin production in vitro and in vivo. Journal of Food Protection, 2003, 66(3): 370-375. |
24 | Wang L L. Study of seed-borne microbial diversity and plasma disinfection method in tomato seeds. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, 2018. |
王玲玲. 番茄(Solanum lycopersicum L.)种带微生物多样性和等离子体消毒技术研究. 北京: 中国农业科学院, 2018. | |
25 | Deng Z X, Chen F, Wang Y J, et al. Microbiology (second version). Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2021: 204. |
邓子新, 陈峰, 王玉炯, 等. 微生物学(第2版). 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2021: 204. | |
26 | Zhang Z F. Seed-borne bacteria of lucerne (Medicago sativa) and their pathogenicity. Lanzhou: Lanzhou University, 2013. |
张振粉. 紫花苜蓿种带细菌及其致病性. 兰州: 兰州大学, 2013. | |
27 | American Phytopathological Society. Common names of plant diseases. https://www.apsnet.org/edcenter/resources/commonnames/Pages/Alfalfa.aspx, 2014-06-25/2021-11-15. |
28 | Yu D F, Fang Z D. A preliminary list of plant pathogenic bacteria in China. Agricultural Journal, 1956, 7(3): 359-363. |
俞大绂, 方中达. 中国植物病原细菌的初步名录. 农业学报, 1956, 7(3): 359-363. | |
29 | Fang Z D, Ren X Z. Additional notes on the list of bacterial plant pathogens. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University, 1981(3): 29-32. |
方中达, 任欣正. 我国植物细菌病害名录补志. 南京农业大学学报, 1981(3): 29-32. | |
30 | Pringle J. Outbreak of Salmonella serotype saintpaul infections associated with eating alfalfa sprouts-United States, 2009. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 2009, 58: 1-4. |
31 | Bruun T, Sorensen G, Forshell L P, et al. An Outbreak of Salmonella typhimurium infections in Denmark, Norway and Sweden, 2008. Eurosurveillance, 2009, 14(10): 3. |
32 | Rimhanen-finne R, Niskanen T, Lienemanne T, et al. A nationwide outbreak of Salmonella bovismorbificans associated with sprouted alfalfa seeds in Finland, 2009. Zoonoses and Public Health, 2011, 58: 589-596. |
33 | Fisher M C, Henk D A, Briggs C J, et al. Emerging fungal threats to animal, plant and ecosystem health. Nature Review, 2012, 484: 186-194. |
34 | Cao H, Krishnan G, Goumnerov B, et al. A quorum sensing-associated virulence gene of Pseudomonas aeruginosa encodes a LysR-like transcription regulator with a unique self-regulatory mechanism. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2001, 98(25): 14613-14618. |
[1] | Shi-long LEI, Li-rong LIAO, Jie WANG, Lu ZHANG, Zhen-cheng YE, Guo-bin LIU, Chao ZHANG. The diversity-Godron stability relationship of alpine grassland and its environmental drivers [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 1-12. |
[2] | Chun-yan LI, Yan WANG, Xin-rui LI, Ying-zhu LI, Ming-feng LI, Li-li CHEN, Xiong LEI, Li-jun YAN, Ming-hong YOU, Xiao-fei JI, Chang-bing ZHANG, Qi WU, Wen-long GOU, Da-xu LI, Jia-jun YAN, Shi-qie BAI. Morphological diversity and germplasm utilization potential of wild Elymus sibiricus [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(3): 67-79. |
[3] | Qi WANG, Jia-hua ZHENG, Meng-li ZHAO, Jun ZHANG. Effects of mowing intensity on community characteristics and soil physicochemical properties of Stipa grandis steppe, Inner Mongolia, China [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(2): 26-34. |
[4] | Jiang-wen LI, Bang-yin HE, Cai LI, Hong-yan HUI, Bo LIU, Xiao-xi ZHANG, Hui FAN, Wen-yu SU. Analysis of grassland community-level plant functional traits and functional diversity at different times during restoration [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(1): 16-25. |
[5] | Ya-ling HU, Eerdun HASI, Liang MAN, Yi YANG, Ping ZHANG. Vegetation responses to sand source and supply volume in Caragana microphylla shrubland [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2023, 32(1): 26-35. |
[6] | Jin-yuan CHEN, Wei-bo DU, Xu SU. A taxonomic inventory of national key protected wild plants in Qinghai Province, based on the national checklist of key protected wild plants (2021) [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(9): 1-12. |
[7] | Li-miao ZHANG, Xue TAN, Zhi DONG, Jie ZHENG, Zhong-xun YUAN, Chang-xiao LI. Effects of Alternanthera philoxeroides invasion on plant diversity in the riparian zones of downtown Chongqing in the Three Gorges Reservoir area [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(9): 13-25. |
[8] | Shi-long MA, Xiao-wei LI, Xiang LI, Shu-qiong XIE, Yi-li LIU, Jiao TANG, Ming-feng JIANG. Assessment of genetic structure of 3 Maiwa yak preserved populations based on genotyping-by-sequencing technology [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(9): 183-194. |
[9] | Yan PENG, Jing-yuan SUN, Su-jie MA, Xiang-tao WANG, Xue-hong WEI, Lei SUN. Plant community composition and soil nutrient status of degraded alpine meadow sites in Northern Tibet [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(8): 49-60. |
[10] | Jing TIAN, Xiang YIN, Yang FAN, Xin-qin LI, Jian-guo ZHANG. Effects of wilting and additives on the fermentation quality and dominant microbial genera in Napier grass silage at different temperatures [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(7): 76-84. |
[11] | Rui GAO, Ning AI, Guang-quan LIU, Chang-hai LIU, Fang-fang QIANG. Characteristics of understory herb communities across time during restoration in coal mine reclamation areas and their coupling with soil properties [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(6): 61-68. |
[12] | Xiao-lei ZHOU, Yue-e YAN, Jing ZHANG, Xu-jiao ZHOU, Yong-qin YAN, Fu-qiang YANG, Xue-ping CAO, An ZHAO, Yan-li ZHAO, Jing-yi SU. Vegetation community structure and diversity in a burned area of Picea asperata-Abies fabri forest on different aspects on the northeastern margin of the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(5): 144-155. |
[13] | Hong-jian WEI, Jie DING, Ju-ming ZHANG, Wen YANG, Yong-qi WANG, Tian-zeng LIU. Changes in soil fungal community structure under bermudagrass turf in response to traffic stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(4): 102-112. |
[14] | Huan ZHANG, Yi-xiao MU, Gui-jie ZHANG. Effects of Lycium barbarum by-products on fermentation quality and microbial diversity of alfalfa silage [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(4): 136-144. |
[15] | Xin LI, Xue WEI, Chang-ting WANG, Xiao REN, Peng-fei WU. Effects of exogenous nutrient addition on alpine meadow soil arthropod communities [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(4): 155-164. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||