Acta Prataculturae Sinica ›› 2026, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (8): 65-83.DOI: 10.11686/cyxb2025381
Previous Articles Next Articles
Xia WANG1(
), Meng-yu YAN1, Qian-xi WANG1, Zhen-wu WEI1, Jia WEI1, Zheng-feng CAO1, Yan-yan LV2, Chuan-jie ZHANG1, Xue-yang MIN1(
)
Received:2025-09-22
Revised:2025-11-10
Online:2026-08-20
Published:2026-06-22
Contact:
Xue-yang MIN
Xia WANG, Meng-yu YAN, Qian-xi WANG, Zhen-wu WEI, Jia WEI, Zheng-feng CAO, Yan-yan LV, Chuan-jie ZHANG, Xue-yang MIN. A comparative study of the yield of alfalfa (Medicago sativa) varieties with different fall dormancy in the Yangtze-Huaihe region[J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(8): 65-83.
| 品种Cultivar | FD | 类型Type | 来源Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maverick | 1 | EFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Vernal | 2 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Boja | 3 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Ranger | 3 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Archer | 5 | MFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Abi 700 | 6 | MFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Sutter | 7 | NFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| CUF 101 | 9 | NFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 9+ | ENFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 皇冠 Crown | 2~3 | FD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 8 | NFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 6 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| MF4020 | 4 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 3.5 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 斯贝德Spade | 1 | EFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 1 | EFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 3~4 | MFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3~4 | MFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 1.2~1.6 | FD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 7 | NFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 3 | FD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| WL712 | 10.2 | ENFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL656HQ | 9.3 | ENFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL525HQ | 8 | NFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL358HQ | 4.1 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| 惊喜Surprise | 4 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL298HQ | 3.2 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 8 | NFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 7 | NFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 4.3 | MFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 4 | MFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 燃力士Energizer | 6 | MFD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 5 | MFD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 威龙Weilon | 3 | FD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2 | FD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 天马 Pegasis | 9 | NFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 10 | ENFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 8 | NFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| Bara520YQ | 5 | MFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| Bara416WET | 4 | MFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 2 | FD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 3 | FD | 扬州大学Yangzhou University |
Table 1 Information and sources of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
| 品种Cultivar | FD | 类型Type | 来源Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maverick | 1 | EFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Vernal | 2 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Boja | 3 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Ranger | 3 | FD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Archer | 5 | MFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Abi 700 | 6 | MFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| Sutter | 7 | NFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| CUF 101 | 9 | NFD | 美国国家种质资源库National Plant Germplasm System |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 9+ | ENFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 皇冠 Crown | 2~3 | FD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 8 | NFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 6 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| MF4020 | 4 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 3.5 | MFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 斯贝德Spade | 1 | EFD | 北京克劳沃种业有限公司Clover (Beijing) Ecological Technology Co., Ltd |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 1 | EFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 3~4 | MFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3~4 | MFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 1.2~1.6 | FD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 7 | NFD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 3 | FD | 酒泉大业种业有限公司Jiuquan Daye Seed Industry Co., Ltd. |
| WL712 | 10.2 | ENFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL656HQ | 9.3 | ENFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL525HQ | 8 | NFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL358HQ | 4.1 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| 惊喜Surprise | 4 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| WL298HQ | 3.2 | MFD | 北京正道种业有限公司Beijing Zhengdao Seed Co., Ltd. |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 8 | NFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 7 | NFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 4.3 | MFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 4 | MFD | 北京佰青源畜牧业科技发展有限公司Beijing Baqingyuan Animal Husbandry Technology Development Co., Ltd. |
| 燃力士Energizer | 6 | MFD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 5 | MFD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 威龙Weilon | 3 | FD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2 | FD | 北京百斯特草业有限公司Beijing Best Grass Industry Co., Ltd. |
| 天马 Pegasis | 9 | NFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 10 | ENFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 8 | NFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| Bara520YQ | 5 | MFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| Bara416WET | 4 | MFD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 2 | FD | 百绿(天津)国际草业有限公司Barenbrug Grass Industry International (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 3 | FD | 扬州大学Yangzhou University |
品种 Cultivar | 出苗期 Seeding stage | 分枝期 Branching period | 返青期 Rejuvenation period | 现蕾期 Budding stage | 初花期Early flowering period | 盛花期 Flowering period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maverick | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-22 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Vernal | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Boja | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| Ranger | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| Archer | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| Abi 700 | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Sutter | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| CUF 101 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-20 | 2024-03-09 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| 皇冠 Crown | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-20 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-18 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| MF4020 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 2023-10-29 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 斯贝德 Spade | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-10 |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL712 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL656HQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL525HQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| WL358HQ | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-28 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| 惊喜Surprise | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-28 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| WL298HQ | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-17 |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 燃力士Energizer | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 威龙Weilon | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-05 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 天马Pegasis | 2023-10-29 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| Bara520YQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-16 |
| Bara416WET | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-17 |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 2023-10-24 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
Table 2 Different growth periods of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
品种 Cultivar | 出苗期 Seeding stage | 分枝期 Branching period | 返青期 Rejuvenation period | 现蕾期 Budding stage | 初花期Early flowering period | 盛花期 Flowering period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maverick | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-22 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Vernal | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Boja | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| Ranger | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| Archer | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| Abi 700 | 2023-10-17 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| Sutter | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| CUF 101 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-20 | 2024-03-09 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-16 |
| 皇冠 Crown | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-20 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-18 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| MF4020 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 2023-10-29 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 斯贝德 Spade | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-10 |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 2023-10-28 | 2023-12-06 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL712 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL656HQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| WL525HQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| WL358HQ | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-28 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| 惊喜Surprise | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-28 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-16 |
| WL298HQ | 2023-11-03 | 2023-11-29 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-17 |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-12 |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 燃力士Energizer | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-11 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 威龙Weilon | 2023-10-28 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2023-11-03 | 2023-12-07 | 2024-03-19 | 2024-05-05 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 天马Pegasis | 2023-10-29 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-01 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-17 |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
| Bara520YQ | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-16 |
| Bara416WET | 2023-10-20 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-10 | 2024-05-17 |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 2023-10-24 | 2023-11-26 | 2024-03-10 | 2024-05-04 | 2024-05-12 | 2024-05-17 |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 2023-10-18 | 2023-11-16 | 2024-03-03 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-29 | 2024-05-10 |
品种 Cultivar | 高度Height (cm) | 生长速度Growth rate (cm·d-1) | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-09 | 2024-04-16 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-30 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-14 | |||
| Maverick | 7.54±2.92hij | 27.63±7.48ab | 35.15±9.93bc | 43.37±12.57a | 52.72±11.28b | 55.50±5.04b | 71.76±6.13bc | 1.15±0.06bc | |
| Vernal | 7.48±3.06hij | 27.92±8.20ab | 35.32±12.32abc | 41.66±14.59a | 51.35±13.86b | 57.54±13.57ab | 67.20±11.57c | 1.07±0.15c | |
| Boja | 7.24±2.78ij | 28.69±10.67ab | 39.82±12.84abc | 46.99±15.40a | 58.48±17.11ab | 61.66±17.76ab | 69.03±16.48bc | 1.10±0.25bc | |
| Ranger | 10.10±2.82bcdefghij | 32.11±7.97ab | 42.31±11.18abc | 48.30±16.26a | 60.73±16.07ab | 68.81±14.18ab | 78.83±14.69abc | 1.23±0.22abc | |
| Archer | 10.63±2.94bcdefghij | 31.03±4.21ab | 42.87±6.72abc | 49.14±10.21a | 62.22±9.22ab | 66.99±12.98ab | 78.19±13.18abc | 1.21±0.19abc | |
| Abi 700 | 11.59±1.69abcdefgh | 31.77±8.55ab | 41.64±9.15abc | 50.11±13.42a | 62.91±13.80ab | 66.36±18.77ab | 73.78±13.07bc | 1.11±0.22bc | |
| Sutter | 11.61±2.45abcdefgh | 34.79±6.29ab | 43.82±5.58abc | 47.58±4.58a | 61.62±5.06ab | 64.57±9.82ab | 73.83±9.09bc | 1.11±0.19bc | |
| CUF 101 | 12.08±2.55abcdefg | 30.85±6.66ab | 40.41±10.00abc | 45.00±13.38a | 55.05±14.09ab | 65.92±7.23ab | 75.68±12.96abc | 1.14±0.24bc | |
| 巨能995 Magnum 995 | 9.19±2.08efghij | 30.22±6.18ab | 43.21±6.19abc | 50.15±7.66a | 65.30±8.50ab | 70.38±6.63ab | 81.49±9.59abc | 1.29±0.14abc | |
| 皇冠Crown | 10.12±1.22bcdefghij | 30.99±4.98ab | 42.33±6.76abc | 49.28±11.44a | 63.33±12.29ab | 68.53±5.54ab | 82.32±7.66abc | 1.29±0.14abc | |
| 巨能801 Magnum 801 | 13.98±0.80ab | 35.04±3.64ab | 44.42±4.80abc | 50.36±8.41a | 59.89±7.56ab | 64.16±7.17ab | 74.37±4.82bc | 1.08±0.08c | |
| 巨能601 Magnum 601 | 8.77±0.80efghij | 28.15±3.92ab | 39.42±2.77abc | 47.57±5.51a | 60.37±6.14ab | 66.63±4.76ab | 81.57±6.12abc | 1.30±0.12abc | |
| MF4020 | 9.74±1.89cdefghij | 32.26±9.87ab | 44.50±13.77abc | 51.77±16.24a | 64.31±12.51ab | 69.90±12.24ab | 80.09±14.08abc | 1.26±0.22abc | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 7.91±2.23ghij | 28.35±4.98ab | 38.28±9.03abc | 46.07±13.69a | 58.47±13.01ab | 66.47±10.52ab | 77.87±10.03abc | 1.25±0.14abc | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 8.16±3.44ghij | 29.72±10.63ab | 40.87±14.91abc | 51.28±12.27a | 65.11±10.29ab | 68.65±14.41ab | 83.07±17.00abc | 1.34±0.24abc | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 6.62±0.68i | 26.13±5.71b | 34.94±5.81c | 44.60±10.59a | 55.12±10.97ab | 60.83±11.62ab | 70.66±12.72bc | 1.14±0.22bc | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 10.36±1.34bcdefghij | 35.16±9.00ab | 43.87±8.25abc | 53.23±10.71a | 66.33±10.39ab | 71.47±9.17ab | 85.57±5.22abc | 1.34±0.09abc | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 9.97±2.41bcdefghij | 36.40±5.62ab | 48.69±7.52abc | 55.84±7.34a | 69.96±11.00ab | 77.03±8.24a | 87.08±8.11ab | 1.38±0.11ab | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 8.44±1.99fghij | 30.48±5.05ab | 41.07±5.65abc | 50.03±6.83a | 59.91±8.21ab | 68.76±4.71ab | 80.42±4.40abc | 1.29±0.04abc | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 11.01±0.06bcdefghi | 35.84±4.49ab | 47.09±3.89abc | 56.03±4.30a | 65.95±4.98ab | 73.28±6.89ab | 82.39±5.38abc | 1.27±0.10abc | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 9.40±1.91defghij | 33.23±4.50ab | 42.48±10.25abc | 50.54±13.13a | 62.35±12.61ab | 70.98±10.82ab | 81.51±8.74abc | 1.29±0.13abc | |
| WL712 | 10.29±1.21bcdefghij | 29.81±3.47ab | 41.65±6.31abc | 48.43±11.79a | 60.90±10.43ab | 65.63±11.19ab | 74.95±10.90bc | 1.15±0.17abc | |
| WL656HQ | 12.95±3.80abcde | 36.82±7.63ab | 45.61±5.16abc | 56.14±8.18a | 67.36±9.32ab | 70.87±4.80ab | 81.45±6.26abc | 1.22±0.08abc | |
| WL525HQ | 11.84±2.47abcdefg | 34.83±5.41ab | 45.38±9.33abc | 53.48±12.06a | 67.27±11.11ab | 74.83±8.53ab | 83.82±8.48abc | 1.29±0.11abc | |
| WL358HQ | 8.34±0.55ghij | 28.29±2.32ab | 38.72±5.32abc | 46.45±11.31a | 59.11±10.10ab | 62.17±9.75ab | 79.41±8.57abc | 1.27±0.15abc | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 7.94±1.17ghij | 28.30±5.16ab | 35.00±5.16bc | 42.47±9.60a | 54.87±10.21ab | 58.06±5.18ab | 72.08±7.19bc | 1.15±0.13bc | |
| WL298HQ | 8.55±1.37fghij | 29.25±3.64ab | 38.66±3.33abc | 48.63±3.74a | 59.90±4.27ab | 65.52±4.54ab | 77.29±1.37abc | 1.23±0.00abc | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 13.51±2.22abcd | 37.20±6.78ab | 48.77±11.76abc | 55.49±15.06a | 66.38±12.28ab | 70.97±11.27ab | 84.45±9.43abc | 1.27±0.13abc | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 11.69±1.90abcdefgh | 30.53±5.82ab | 43.13±6.55abc | 47.50±11.08a | 63.07±9.53ab | 64.57±7.16ab | 81.03±4.11abc | 1.24±0.07abc | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 13.83±3.18abc | 38.01±8.24ab | 51.46±9.36ab | 60.41±11.59a | 75.16±13.34a | 77.20±8.51a | 94.90±10.60a | 1.45±0.13a | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 9.64±2.35cdefghij | 31.90±4.64ab | 44.86±3.15abc | 54.50±5.55a | 68.48±8.49ab | 71.45±5.97ab | 83.31±8.83abc | 1.32±0.12abc | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 15.16±2.35a | 39.49±7.28a | 51.69±7.26a | 58.18±9.89a | 70.43±9.69ab | 76.71±10.29a | 87.98±9.97ab | 1.30±0.15abc | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 10.44±3.04bcdefghij | 30.94±10.31ab | 42.65±12.46abc | 51.79±14.18a | 63.47±13.58ab | 74.91±16.68ab | 80.57±15.32abc | 1.25±0.22abc | |
| 威龙Weilon | 9.63±1.44cdefghij | 31.45±4.31ab | 41.24±3.47abc | 49.71±3.93a | 61.64±4.61ab | 65.46±2.37ab | 74.89±4.32bc | 1.17±0.07abc | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 9.10±1.12efghij | 29.14±2.08ab | 39.70±5.42abc | 46.27±9.59a | 58.22±10.64ab | 65.54±5.99ab | 77.80±3.86abc | 1.23±0.08abc | |
| 天马Pegasis | 14.11±2.23ab | 35.73±8.23ab | 43.92±9.60abc | 50.39±12.17a | 60.90±15.10ab | 66.34±12.37ab | 77.75±11.52abc | 1.14±0.17bc | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 13.78±1.98abc | 37.09±3.81ab | 46.43±6.63abc | 53.94±11.87a | 65.59±11.78ab | 75.18±7.33ab | 83.11±6.26abc | 1.24±0.09abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 12.63±1.13abcdef | 34.46±3.28ab | 42.97±5.94abc | 51.38±10.61a | 62.06±8.65ab | 66.61±6.24ab | 79.96±6.86abc | 1.20±0.10abc | |
| Bara520YQ | 10.62±1.67bcdefghij | 34.97±5.47ab | 43.91±4.35abc | 53.94±5.53a | 63.73±7.84ab | 71.10±5.50ab | 80.91±5.38abc | 1.26±0.07abc | |
| Bara416WET | 8.58±0.86fghij | 32.63±2.94ab | 44.44±5.21abc | 53.07±8.60a | 64.70±6.53ab | 74.58±3.63ab | 83.15±3.41abc | 1.33±0.07abc | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 11.18±0.29abcdefghi | 33.04±2.70ab | 43.18±2.78abc | 49.54±8.90a | 62.71±9.91ab | 72.98±2.16ab | 81.44±4.51abc | 1.25±0.08abc | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 10.06±1.27bcdefghij | 30.99±6.11ab | 40.01±5.21abc | 48.71±9.50a | 62.84±3.59ab | 63.95±5.01ab | 81.45±4.71abc | 1.27±0.07abc | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0* | |||||||
| 日期Date (D) | 0* | ||||||||
| 品种×日期C×D | 1 | ||||||||
Table 3 Comparison of spring growth dynamics of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
品种 Cultivar | 高度Height (cm) | 生长速度Growth rate (cm·d-1) | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-03-19 | 2024-04-09 | 2024-04-16 | 2024-04-23 | 2024-04-30 | 2024-05-07 | 2024-05-14 | |||
| Maverick | 7.54±2.92hij | 27.63±7.48ab | 35.15±9.93bc | 43.37±12.57a | 52.72±11.28b | 55.50±5.04b | 71.76±6.13bc | 1.15±0.06bc | |
| Vernal | 7.48±3.06hij | 27.92±8.20ab | 35.32±12.32abc | 41.66±14.59a | 51.35±13.86b | 57.54±13.57ab | 67.20±11.57c | 1.07±0.15c | |
| Boja | 7.24±2.78ij | 28.69±10.67ab | 39.82±12.84abc | 46.99±15.40a | 58.48±17.11ab | 61.66±17.76ab | 69.03±16.48bc | 1.10±0.25bc | |
| Ranger | 10.10±2.82bcdefghij | 32.11±7.97ab | 42.31±11.18abc | 48.30±16.26a | 60.73±16.07ab | 68.81±14.18ab | 78.83±14.69abc | 1.23±0.22abc | |
| Archer | 10.63±2.94bcdefghij | 31.03±4.21ab | 42.87±6.72abc | 49.14±10.21a | 62.22±9.22ab | 66.99±12.98ab | 78.19±13.18abc | 1.21±0.19abc | |
| Abi 700 | 11.59±1.69abcdefgh | 31.77±8.55ab | 41.64±9.15abc | 50.11±13.42a | 62.91±13.80ab | 66.36±18.77ab | 73.78±13.07bc | 1.11±0.22bc | |
| Sutter | 11.61±2.45abcdefgh | 34.79±6.29ab | 43.82±5.58abc | 47.58±4.58a | 61.62±5.06ab | 64.57±9.82ab | 73.83±9.09bc | 1.11±0.19bc | |
| CUF 101 | 12.08±2.55abcdefg | 30.85±6.66ab | 40.41±10.00abc | 45.00±13.38a | 55.05±14.09ab | 65.92±7.23ab | 75.68±12.96abc | 1.14±0.24bc | |
| 巨能995 Magnum 995 | 9.19±2.08efghij | 30.22±6.18ab | 43.21±6.19abc | 50.15±7.66a | 65.30±8.50ab | 70.38±6.63ab | 81.49±9.59abc | 1.29±0.14abc | |
| 皇冠Crown | 10.12±1.22bcdefghij | 30.99±4.98ab | 42.33±6.76abc | 49.28±11.44a | 63.33±12.29ab | 68.53±5.54ab | 82.32±7.66abc | 1.29±0.14abc | |
| 巨能801 Magnum 801 | 13.98±0.80ab | 35.04±3.64ab | 44.42±4.80abc | 50.36±8.41a | 59.89±7.56ab | 64.16±7.17ab | 74.37±4.82bc | 1.08±0.08c | |
| 巨能601 Magnum 601 | 8.77±0.80efghij | 28.15±3.92ab | 39.42±2.77abc | 47.57±5.51a | 60.37±6.14ab | 66.63±4.76ab | 81.57±6.12abc | 1.30±0.12abc | |
| MF4020 | 9.74±1.89cdefghij | 32.26±9.87ab | 44.50±13.77abc | 51.77±16.24a | 64.31±12.51ab | 69.90±12.24ab | 80.09±14.08abc | 1.26±0.22abc | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 7.91±2.23ghij | 28.35±4.98ab | 38.28±9.03abc | 46.07±13.69a | 58.47±13.01ab | 66.47±10.52ab | 77.87±10.03abc | 1.25±0.14abc | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 8.16±3.44ghij | 29.72±10.63ab | 40.87±14.91abc | 51.28±12.27a | 65.11±10.29ab | 68.65±14.41ab | 83.07±17.00abc | 1.34±0.24abc | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 6.62±0.68i | 26.13±5.71b | 34.94±5.81c | 44.60±10.59a | 55.12±10.97ab | 60.83±11.62ab | 70.66±12.72bc | 1.14±0.22bc | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 10.36±1.34bcdefghij | 35.16±9.00ab | 43.87±8.25abc | 53.23±10.71a | 66.33±10.39ab | 71.47±9.17ab | 85.57±5.22abc | 1.34±0.09abc | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 9.97±2.41bcdefghij | 36.40±5.62ab | 48.69±7.52abc | 55.84±7.34a | 69.96±11.00ab | 77.03±8.24a | 87.08±8.11ab | 1.38±0.11ab | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 8.44±1.99fghij | 30.48±5.05ab | 41.07±5.65abc | 50.03±6.83a | 59.91±8.21ab | 68.76±4.71ab | 80.42±4.40abc | 1.29±0.04abc | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 11.01±0.06bcdefghi | 35.84±4.49ab | 47.09±3.89abc | 56.03±4.30a | 65.95±4.98ab | 73.28±6.89ab | 82.39±5.38abc | 1.27±0.10abc | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 9.40±1.91defghij | 33.23±4.50ab | 42.48±10.25abc | 50.54±13.13a | 62.35±12.61ab | 70.98±10.82ab | 81.51±8.74abc | 1.29±0.13abc | |
| WL712 | 10.29±1.21bcdefghij | 29.81±3.47ab | 41.65±6.31abc | 48.43±11.79a | 60.90±10.43ab | 65.63±11.19ab | 74.95±10.90bc | 1.15±0.17abc | |
| WL656HQ | 12.95±3.80abcde | 36.82±7.63ab | 45.61±5.16abc | 56.14±8.18a | 67.36±9.32ab | 70.87±4.80ab | 81.45±6.26abc | 1.22±0.08abc | |
| WL525HQ | 11.84±2.47abcdefg | 34.83±5.41ab | 45.38±9.33abc | 53.48±12.06a | 67.27±11.11ab | 74.83±8.53ab | 83.82±8.48abc | 1.29±0.11abc | |
| WL358HQ | 8.34±0.55ghij | 28.29±2.32ab | 38.72±5.32abc | 46.45±11.31a | 59.11±10.10ab | 62.17±9.75ab | 79.41±8.57abc | 1.27±0.15abc | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 7.94±1.17ghij | 28.30±5.16ab | 35.00±5.16bc | 42.47±9.60a | 54.87±10.21ab | 58.06±5.18ab | 72.08±7.19bc | 1.15±0.13bc | |
| WL298HQ | 8.55±1.37fghij | 29.25±3.64ab | 38.66±3.33abc | 48.63±3.74a | 59.90±4.27ab | 65.52±4.54ab | 77.29±1.37abc | 1.23±0.00abc | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 13.51±2.22abcd | 37.20±6.78ab | 48.77±11.76abc | 55.49±15.06a | 66.38±12.28ab | 70.97±11.27ab | 84.45±9.43abc | 1.27±0.13abc | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 11.69±1.90abcdefgh | 30.53±5.82ab | 43.13±6.55abc | 47.50±11.08a | 63.07±9.53ab | 64.57±7.16ab | 81.03±4.11abc | 1.24±0.07abc | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 13.83±3.18abc | 38.01±8.24ab | 51.46±9.36ab | 60.41±11.59a | 75.16±13.34a | 77.20±8.51a | 94.90±10.60a | 1.45±0.13a | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 9.64±2.35cdefghij | 31.90±4.64ab | 44.86±3.15abc | 54.50±5.55a | 68.48±8.49ab | 71.45±5.97ab | 83.31±8.83abc | 1.32±0.12abc | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 15.16±2.35a | 39.49±7.28a | 51.69±7.26a | 58.18±9.89a | 70.43±9.69ab | 76.71±10.29a | 87.98±9.97ab | 1.30±0.15abc | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 10.44±3.04bcdefghij | 30.94±10.31ab | 42.65±12.46abc | 51.79±14.18a | 63.47±13.58ab | 74.91±16.68ab | 80.57±15.32abc | 1.25±0.22abc | |
| 威龙Weilon | 9.63±1.44cdefghij | 31.45±4.31ab | 41.24±3.47abc | 49.71±3.93a | 61.64±4.61ab | 65.46±2.37ab | 74.89±4.32bc | 1.17±0.07abc | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 9.10±1.12efghij | 29.14±2.08ab | 39.70±5.42abc | 46.27±9.59a | 58.22±10.64ab | 65.54±5.99ab | 77.80±3.86abc | 1.23±0.08abc | |
| 天马Pegasis | 14.11±2.23ab | 35.73±8.23ab | 43.92±9.60abc | 50.39±12.17a | 60.90±15.10ab | 66.34±12.37ab | 77.75±11.52abc | 1.14±0.17bc | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 13.78±1.98abc | 37.09±3.81ab | 46.43±6.63abc | 53.94±11.87a | 65.59±11.78ab | 75.18±7.33ab | 83.11±6.26abc | 1.24±0.09abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 12.63±1.13abcdef | 34.46±3.28ab | 42.97±5.94abc | 51.38±10.61a | 62.06±8.65ab | 66.61±6.24ab | 79.96±6.86abc | 1.20±0.10abc | |
| Bara520YQ | 10.62±1.67bcdefghij | 34.97±5.47ab | 43.91±4.35abc | 53.94±5.53a | 63.73±7.84ab | 71.10±5.50ab | 80.91±5.38abc | 1.26±0.07abc | |
| Bara416WET | 8.58±0.86fghij | 32.63±2.94ab | 44.44±5.21abc | 53.07±8.60a | 64.70±6.53ab | 74.58±3.63ab | 83.15±3.41abc | 1.33±0.07abc | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 11.18±0.29abcdefghi | 33.04±2.70ab | 43.18±2.78abc | 49.54±8.90a | 62.71±9.91ab | 72.98±2.16ab | 81.44±4.51abc | 1.25±0.08abc | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 10.06±1.27bcdefghij | 30.99±6.11ab | 40.01±5.21abc | 48.71±9.50a | 62.84±3.59ab | 63.95±5.01ab | 81.45±4.71abc | 1.27±0.07abc | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0* | |||||||
| 日期Date (D) | 0* | ||||||||
| 品种×日期C×D | 1 | ||||||||
品种 Cultivar | 茬次Cut | 全年 Annual | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||
| Maverick | 3.41±1.56fgh | 1.46±0.63fgh | 1.28±0.15hijklm | 0.14±0.07bc | 0.08±0.10cd | 6.36±2.28abc | |
| Vernal | 4.04±1.22defgh | 1.37±0.54gh | 0.81±0.52jklm | 0.25±0.27bc | 6.49±2.63abc | ||
| Boja | 2.03±0.98i | 1.13±0.24h | 0.71±0.21lm | 0.16±0.05bc | 0.08±0.07cd | 4.12±1.43c | |
| Ranger | 2.27±1.01hi | 1.18±0.58h | 0.68±0.11m | 0.08±0.06c | 0.08±0.03d | 4.26±1.73bc | |
| Archer | 4.56±0.97bcdefgh | 2.20±0.65defgh | 1.38±0.67ghijklm | 0.37±0.42bc | 0.47±0.44cd | 8.82±2.68a | |
| Abi 700 | 4.31±2.32cdefgh | 2.41±0.44cdefgh | 1.11±0.31ijklm | 0.16±0.10bc | 0.10±0.07cd | 8.06±3.15ab | |
| Sutter | 3.88±0.64efgh | 2.36±0.44cdefgh | 1.54±0.36fghijklm | 0.46±0.21bc | 0.29±0.15cd | 8.52±1.29a | |
| CUF 101 | 3.11±0.83gh | 1.98±1.41efgh | 0.65±0.15m | 0.23±0.15bc | 0.18±0.12cd | 6.15±2.60abc | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 3.54±1.04abcde | 2.01±0.44abcd | 1.26±0.33abcdefg | 0.33±0.06bc | 0.21±0.06cd | 7.35±1.36abc | |
| 皇冠Crown | 3.37±0.38abcde | 1.84±0.32abcde | 1.15±0.06abcdefghi | 0.26±0.06bc | 0.23±0.05bcd | 6.85±0.74abc | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 2.86±0.79abcdefg | 1.76±0.49abcde | 1.11±0.07abcdefghi | 0.37±0.13abc | 0.33±0.11abcd | 6.43±1.13abc | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 3.26±0.16abcdef | 1.63±0.12abcdef | 1.13±0.08abcdefghi | 0.24±0.04bc | 0.13±0.08cd | 6.40±0.01abc | |
| MF4020 | 3.71±0.43abcd | 2.09±0.42abc | 1.70±0.13a | 0.39±0.24abc | 0.20±0.10cd | 8.10±0.86a | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 3.02±0.70abcdefg | 1.51±0.63abcdefg | 1.19±0.31abcdefgh | 0.25±0.02bc | 0.17±0.11cd | 6.15±1.66abc | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 3.26±1.59abcdef | 1.35±0.61bcdefgh | 0.87±0.47efghijklm | 0.07±0.07bc | 0.07±0.04cd | 5.59±2.75abc | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 2.78±1.01abcdefg | 0.99±0.20efgh | 0.37±0.12klm | 0.04±0.04c | 0.04±0.05cd | 4.22±1.01c | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 3.47±0.15abcde | 1.70±0.43abcde | 1.02±0.20bcdefghi | 0.25±0.10bc | 0.21±0.02cd | 6.65±0.64abc | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3.89±0.37ab | 1.62±0.08abcdef | 0.96±0.25cdefghijkl | 0.16±0.17bc | 0.10±0.07cd | 6.73±0.86abc | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 3.54±0.46abcde | 1.40±0.36bcdefgh | 0.92±0.24defghijklm | 0.21±0.19bc | 0.14±0.16cd | 6.21±0.88abc | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 3.79±0.13abc | 1.74±0.32abcde | 0.98±0.24cdefghijkl | 0.10±0.13bc | 0.07±0.08cd | 6.68±0.66abc | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 3.89±0.71ab | 1.52±0.33abcdefg | 1.02±0.34bcdefghi | 0.21±0.19bc | 0.19±0.22cd | 6.82±1.58abc | |
| WL712 | 3.53±0.10abcde | 1.93±0.07abcd | 1.31±0.20abcdef | 0.41±0.15abc | 0.28±0.14abcd | 7.46±0.38abc | |
| WL656HQ | 3.27±0.53abcdef | 1.83±0.27abcde | 1.12±0.23abcdefghi | 0.32±0.13bc | 0.30±0.12cd | 6.84±1.18abc | |
| WL525HQ | 3.58±0.15abcde | 2.39±0.18a | 1.62±0.47ab | 0.70±0.32bc | 0.53±0.26a | 8.82±1.21a | |
| WL358HQ | 3.07±0.42abcdefg | 1.27±0.20cdefgh | 1.32±0.10abcdef | 0.29±0.14bc | 0.23±0.09bcd | 6.18±0.54abc | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 3.22±0.73abcdef | 1.54±0.10abcdefg | 0.95±0.20cdefghijklm | 0.16±0.07bc | 0.11±0.06cd | 5.98±0.94abc | |
| WL298HQ | 3.74±0.45abc | 2.26±0.35ab | 1.55±0.24abc | 0.38±0.10abc | 0.22±0.13cd | 8.16±0.50a | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 3.48±0.77abcde | 1.89±0.45abcde | 1.13±0.32abcdefghi | 0.27±0.21bc | 0.30±0.02abcd | 6.97±1.79abc | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 3.03±0.32abcdefg | 1.84±0.49abcde | 1.05±0.44bcdefghi | 0.19±0.25bc | 0.16±0.20cd | 6.26±1.65abc | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 3.95±0.79ab | 2.05±0.28abc | 1.28±0.12abcdefg | 0.28±0.10bc | 0.20±0.09cd | 7.75±0.95abc | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 3.61±0.12abcde | 1.83±0.11abcde | 1.47±0.15abcde | 0.39±0.18abc | 0.26±0.10abcd | 7.56±0.32abc | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 3.58±0.45abcde | 2.27±0.25ab | 1.46±0.07abcdef | 0.29±0.14bc | 0.16±0.05cd | 7.76±0.60abc | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 3.18±0.52abcdefg | 1.83±0.15abcde | 1.63±0.24ab | 0.44±0.23ab | 0.35±0.21abc | 7.42±0.80abc | |
| 威龙Weilon | 3.16±0.59abcdefg | 1.35±0.54bcdefgh | 1.18±0.19abcdefgh | 0.25±0.13bc | 0.14±0.07cd | 6.07±1.26abc | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2.96±0.29abcdefg | 1.43±0.19bcdefgh | 1.38±0.15abcdef | 0.21±0.12bc | 0.16±0.09cd | 6.14±0.47abc | |
| 天马Pegasis | 3.28±0.91abcdef | 1.97±0.42abcd | 1.39±0.27abcdef | 0.35±0.13abc | 0.33±0.10abcd | 7.31±1.75abc | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 3.34±0.80abcdef | 1.74±0.38abcde | 1.19±0.15abcdefgh | 0.35±0.11abc | 0.29±0.08abcd | 6.91±1.38abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 3.16±0.39abcdefg | 1.68±0.36abcde | 1.03±0.13bcdefghi | 0.26±0.14bc | 0.25±0.09abcd | 6.38±0.66abc | |
| Bara520YQ | 3.73±0.17abc | 1.97±0.41abcd | 1.28±0.24abcdefg | 0.35±0.19abc | 0.22±0.16cd | 7.54±1.03abc | |
| Bara416WET | 4.31±1.12a | 1.66±0.48abcde | 1.50±0.11abcd | 0.35±0.16abc | 0.32±0.13abcd | 8.14±1.08a | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 3.46±0.63abcde | 1.86±0.26abcde | 1.30±0.11abcdef | 0.28±0.07bc | 0.20±0.09cd | 7.10±0.87abc | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 3.56±0.54abcde | 1.50±0.19abcdefg | 1.13±0.10abcde | 0.42±0.10abc | 0.52±0.18ab | 7.14±0.51abc | |
| P | 品种Cultivar | 0* | |||||
| 茬次Cut | 0* | ||||||
| 品种×茬次Cultivar×cut | 0* | ||||||
Table 4 Comparison of fresh grass yield of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test across different cuts (kg·m-2)
品种 Cultivar | 茬次Cut | 全年 Annual | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||
| Maverick | 3.41±1.56fgh | 1.46±0.63fgh | 1.28±0.15hijklm | 0.14±0.07bc | 0.08±0.10cd | 6.36±2.28abc | |
| Vernal | 4.04±1.22defgh | 1.37±0.54gh | 0.81±0.52jklm | 0.25±0.27bc | 6.49±2.63abc | ||
| Boja | 2.03±0.98i | 1.13±0.24h | 0.71±0.21lm | 0.16±0.05bc | 0.08±0.07cd | 4.12±1.43c | |
| Ranger | 2.27±1.01hi | 1.18±0.58h | 0.68±0.11m | 0.08±0.06c | 0.08±0.03d | 4.26±1.73bc | |
| Archer | 4.56±0.97bcdefgh | 2.20±0.65defgh | 1.38±0.67ghijklm | 0.37±0.42bc | 0.47±0.44cd | 8.82±2.68a | |
| Abi 700 | 4.31±2.32cdefgh | 2.41±0.44cdefgh | 1.11±0.31ijklm | 0.16±0.10bc | 0.10±0.07cd | 8.06±3.15ab | |
| Sutter | 3.88±0.64efgh | 2.36±0.44cdefgh | 1.54±0.36fghijklm | 0.46±0.21bc | 0.29±0.15cd | 8.52±1.29a | |
| CUF 101 | 3.11±0.83gh | 1.98±1.41efgh | 0.65±0.15m | 0.23±0.15bc | 0.18±0.12cd | 6.15±2.60abc | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 3.54±1.04abcde | 2.01±0.44abcd | 1.26±0.33abcdefg | 0.33±0.06bc | 0.21±0.06cd | 7.35±1.36abc | |
| 皇冠Crown | 3.37±0.38abcde | 1.84±0.32abcde | 1.15±0.06abcdefghi | 0.26±0.06bc | 0.23±0.05bcd | 6.85±0.74abc | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 2.86±0.79abcdefg | 1.76±0.49abcde | 1.11±0.07abcdefghi | 0.37±0.13abc | 0.33±0.11abcd | 6.43±1.13abc | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 3.26±0.16abcdef | 1.63±0.12abcdef | 1.13±0.08abcdefghi | 0.24±0.04bc | 0.13±0.08cd | 6.40±0.01abc | |
| MF4020 | 3.71±0.43abcd | 2.09±0.42abc | 1.70±0.13a | 0.39±0.24abc | 0.20±0.10cd | 8.10±0.86a | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 3.02±0.70abcdefg | 1.51±0.63abcdefg | 1.19±0.31abcdefgh | 0.25±0.02bc | 0.17±0.11cd | 6.15±1.66abc | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 3.26±1.59abcdef | 1.35±0.61bcdefgh | 0.87±0.47efghijklm | 0.07±0.07bc | 0.07±0.04cd | 5.59±2.75abc | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 2.78±1.01abcdefg | 0.99±0.20efgh | 0.37±0.12klm | 0.04±0.04c | 0.04±0.05cd | 4.22±1.01c | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 3.47±0.15abcde | 1.70±0.43abcde | 1.02±0.20bcdefghi | 0.25±0.10bc | 0.21±0.02cd | 6.65±0.64abc | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 3.89±0.37ab | 1.62±0.08abcdef | 0.96±0.25cdefghijkl | 0.16±0.17bc | 0.10±0.07cd | 6.73±0.86abc | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 3.54±0.46abcde | 1.40±0.36bcdefgh | 0.92±0.24defghijklm | 0.21±0.19bc | 0.14±0.16cd | 6.21±0.88abc | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 3.79±0.13abc | 1.74±0.32abcde | 0.98±0.24cdefghijkl | 0.10±0.13bc | 0.07±0.08cd | 6.68±0.66abc | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 3.89±0.71ab | 1.52±0.33abcdefg | 1.02±0.34bcdefghi | 0.21±0.19bc | 0.19±0.22cd | 6.82±1.58abc | |
| WL712 | 3.53±0.10abcde | 1.93±0.07abcd | 1.31±0.20abcdef | 0.41±0.15abc | 0.28±0.14abcd | 7.46±0.38abc | |
| WL656HQ | 3.27±0.53abcdef | 1.83±0.27abcde | 1.12±0.23abcdefghi | 0.32±0.13bc | 0.30±0.12cd | 6.84±1.18abc | |
| WL525HQ | 3.58±0.15abcde | 2.39±0.18a | 1.62±0.47ab | 0.70±0.32bc | 0.53±0.26a | 8.82±1.21a | |
| WL358HQ | 3.07±0.42abcdefg | 1.27±0.20cdefgh | 1.32±0.10abcdef | 0.29±0.14bc | 0.23±0.09bcd | 6.18±0.54abc | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 3.22±0.73abcdef | 1.54±0.10abcdefg | 0.95±0.20cdefghijklm | 0.16±0.07bc | 0.11±0.06cd | 5.98±0.94abc | |
| WL298HQ | 3.74±0.45abc | 2.26±0.35ab | 1.55±0.24abc | 0.38±0.10abc | 0.22±0.13cd | 8.16±0.50a | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 3.48±0.77abcde | 1.89±0.45abcde | 1.13±0.32abcdefghi | 0.27±0.21bc | 0.30±0.02abcd | 6.97±1.79abc | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 3.03±0.32abcdefg | 1.84±0.49abcde | 1.05±0.44bcdefghi | 0.19±0.25bc | 0.16±0.20cd | 6.26±1.65abc | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 3.95±0.79ab | 2.05±0.28abc | 1.28±0.12abcdefg | 0.28±0.10bc | 0.20±0.09cd | 7.75±0.95abc | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 3.61±0.12abcde | 1.83±0.11abcde | 1.47±0.15abcde | 0.39±0.18abc | 0.26±0.10abcd | 7.56±0.32abc | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 3.58±0.45abcde | 2.27±0.25ab | 1.46±0.07abcdef | 0.29±0.14bc | 0.16±0.05cd | 7.76±0.60abc | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 3.18±0.52abcdefg | 1.83±0.15abcde | 1.63±0.24ab | 0.44±0.23ab | 0.35±0.21abc | 7.42±0.80abc | |
| 威龙Weilon | 3.16±0.59abcdefg | 1.35±0.54bcdefgh | 1.18±0.19abcdefgh | 0.25±0.13bc | 0.14±0.07cd | 6.07±1.26abc | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 2.96±0.29abcdefg | 1.43±0.19bcdefgh | 1.38±0.15abcdef | 0.21±0.12bc | 0.16±0.09cd | 6.14±0.47abc | |
| 天马Pegasis | 3.28±0.91abcdef | 1.97±0.42abcd | 1.39±0.27abcdef | 0.35±0.13abc | 0.33±0.10abcd | 7.31±1.75abc | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 3.34±0.80abcdef | 1.74±0.38abcde | 1.19±0.15abcdefgh | 0.35±0.11abc | 0.29±0.08abcd | 6.91±1.38abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 3.16±0.39abcdefg | 1.68±0.36abcde | 1.03±0.13bcdefghi | 0.26±0.14bc | 0.25±0.09abcd | 6.38±0.66abc | |
| Bara520YQ | 3.73±0.17abc | 1.97±0.41abcd | 1.28±0.24abcdefg | 0.35±0.19abc | 0.22±0.16cd | 7.54±1.03abc | |
| Bara416WET | 4.31±1.12a | 1.66±0.48abcde | 1.50±0.11abcd | 0.35±0.16abc | 0.32±0.13abcd | 8.14±1.08a | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 3.46±0.63abcde | 1.86±0.26abcde | 1.30±0.11abcdef | 0.28±0.07bc | 0.20±0.09cd | 7.10±0.87abc | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 3.56±0.54abcde | 1.50±0.19abcdefg | 1.13±0.10abcde | 0.42±0.10abc | 0.52±0.18ab | 7.14±0.51abc | |
| P | 品种Cultivar | 0* | |||||
| 茬次Cut | 0* | ||||||
| 品种×茬次Cultivar×cut | 0* | ||||||
品种 Cultivar | 茬次Cutting | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |
| Maverick | 55.94±12.23cd | 54.50±5.98de | 30.00±5.63abc | 21.50±8.65abcd |
| Vernal | 59.84±10.25bcd | 60.89±3.73bcd | 25.13±14.53c | 24.22±11.48abcd |
| Boja | 70.54±10.07abcd | 66.70±1.79abcd | 33.94±7.75abc | 19.83±4.97cd |
| Ranger | 71.83±11.65abcd | 58.70±2.97abcd | 30.27±11.05abc | 20.71±7.97bcd |
| Archer | 71.73±7.49abcd | 64.07±2.08abcd | 36.42±12.59abc | 30.55±10.63abc |
| Abi 700 | 75.40±5.40abcd | 62.62±4.06bcd | 34.81±4.02abc | 21.53±0.75abcd |
| Sutter | 71.29±7.09abcd | 75.05±18.57a | 37.59±4.22abc | 25.41±4.33abcd |
| CUF 101 | 74.54±8.12abcd | 59.54±6.61bcde | 46.57±3.35ab | 30.23±5.33abcd |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 69.59±9.56abcd | 63.72±3.32abcd | 37.62±3.47abc | 25.33±2.47abcd |
| 皇冠Crown | 71.50±8.36abcd | 59.47±2.67bcde | 40.61±3.91abc | 31.31±4.48abc |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 78.45±13.32abc | 68.22±0.95abc | 42.75±8.68abc | 30.79±7.78abc |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 71.23±6.80abcd | 66.50±2.25abcd | 40.36±8.02abc | 24.00±5.77abcd |
| MF4020 | 70.94±9.52abcd | 62.88±1.70abcd | 40.68±6.64abc | 25.64±5.91abcd |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 68.66±8.29abcd | 62.78±2.16abcd | 36.81±2.96abc | 25.98±3.87abcd |
| 斯贝德Spade | 66.32±8.20abcd | 57.32±4.47bcde | 26.66±6.00bc | 24.68±0.43abcd |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 53.32±7.98d | 48.05±3.59e | 28.24±11.74abc | 16.71±3.18d |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 60.36±12.76bcd | 55.66±5.21cde | 34.35±9.54abc | 25.30±5.83abcd |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 69.64±10.41abcd | 58.77±1.58bcde | 33.57±10.87abc | 24.46±5.12abcd |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 63.92±4.56abcd | 62.98±2.09abcd | 38.13±6.15abc | 23.95±5.86abcd |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 65.20±4.69abcd | 54.79±5.21de | 28.24±10.30abc | 21.75±8.34abcd |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 65.02±11.07abcd | 61.54±0.95bcd | 30.96±5.33abc | 20.77±10.60bcd |
| WL712 | 73.80±4.18abcd | 65.47±1.34abcd | 45.60±2.26ab | 30.22±6.18abcd |
| WL656HQ | 79.00±10.59abc | 65.98±3.90abcd | 42.96±3.65abc | 34.81±3.71a |
| WL525HQ | 82.47±3.03ab | 67.91±3.56abc | 47.12±9.89a | 32.73±6.11abc |
| WL358HQ | 61.14±10.56bcd | 65.19±6.41abcd | 44.02±4.57abc | 28.38±7.49abcd |
| 惊喜Surprise | 64.63±8.23abcd | 61.40±3.94bcd | 35.04±0.68abc | 22.09±5.18abcd |
| WL298HQ | 72.87±7.27abcd | 64.96±3.12abcd | 41.94±4.17abc | 24.66±5.03abcd |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 73.11±11.38abcd | 65.57±3.22abcd | 42.04±11.11abc | 29.96±5.52abcd |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 73.86±5.61abcd | 62.30±3.93bcd | 41.77±15.03abc | 26.77±12.26abcd |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 78.30±4.85abc | 66.58±3.56abcd | 41.70±12.20abc | 30.07±6.79abcd |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 68.50±4.99abcd | 63.16±1.30abcd | 41.87±4.74abc | 27.02±7.77abcd |
| 燃力士Energizer | 86.52±5.78a | 75.19±4.06a | 45.96±4.42ab | 29.84±4.54abcd |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 70.93±4.66abcd | 68.09±3.79abc | 37.91±8.15abc | 28.37±5.50abcd |
| 威龙Weilon | 62.87±3.76bcd | 62.84±3.85abcd | 35.29±4.98abc | 23.26±7.76abcd |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 59.35±7.28bcd | 59.81±1.74bcd | 38.24±5.76abc | 27.52±3.32abcd |
| 天马Pegasis | 77.77±7.14abc | 64.67±1.97abcd | 44.66±2.99abc | 33.94±6.38ab |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 73.77±10.27abcd | 68.54±4.15ab | 45.22±0.65abc | 33.05±5.42abc |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 61.24±12.69bcd | 63.34±7.80abcd | 45.68±4.40ab | 27.91±10.30abcd |
| Bara520YQ | 70.42±10.23abcd | 66.16±4.10abcd | 39.92±10.16abc | 30.45±6.83abcd |
| Bara416WET | 70.34±9.81abcd | 63.07±2.43abcd | 42.69±4.43abc | 30.24±5.30abcd |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 71.31±12.33abcd | 67.09±6.54abcd | 39.77±4.57abc | 23.98±6.23abcd |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 60.97±3.96bcd | 60.51±2.55bcd | 40.25±2.56abc | 25.72±3.95abcd |
Table 5 Comparison of plant height after cutting for each cut of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test (cm)
品种 Cultivar | 茬次Cutting | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |
| Maverick | 55.94±12.23cd | 54.50±5.98de | 30.00±5.63abc | 21.50±8.65abcd |
| Vernal | 59.84±10.25bcd | 60.89±3.73bcd | 25.13±14.53c | 24.22±11.48abcd |
| Boja | 70.54±10.07abcd | 66.70±1.79abcd | 33.94±7.75abc | 19.83±4.97cd |
| Ranger | 71.83±11.65abcd | 58.70±2.97abcd | 30.27±11.05abc | 20.71±7.97bcd |
| Archer | 71.73±7.49abcd | 64.07±2.08abcd | 36.42±12.59abc | 30.55±10.63abc |
| Abi 700 | 75.40±5.40abcd | 62.62±4.06bcd | 34.81±4.02abc | 21.53±0.75abcd |
| Sutter | 71.29±7.09abcd | 75.05±18.57a | 37.59±4.22abc | 25.41±4.33abcd |
| CUF 101 | 74.54±8.12abcd | 59.54±6.61bcde | 46.57±3.35ab | 30.23±5.33abcd |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 69.59±9.56abcd | 63.72±3.32abcd | 37.62±3.47abc | 25.33±2.47abcd |
| 皇冠Crown | 71.50±8.36abcd | 59.47±2.67bcde | 40.61±3.91abc | 31.31±4.48abc |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 78.45±13.32abc | 68.22±0.95abc | 42.75±8.68abc | 30.79±7.78abc |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 71.23±6.80abcd | 66.50±2.25abcd | 40.36±8.02abc | 24.00±5.77abcd |
| MF4020 | 70.94±9.52abcd | 62.88±1.70abcd | 40.68±6.64abc | 25.64±5.91abcd |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 68.66±8.29abcd | 62.78±2.16abcd | 36.81±2.96abc | 25.98±3.87abcd |
| 斯贝德Spade | 66.32±8.20abcd | 57.32±4.47bcde | 26.66±6.00bc | 24.68±0.43abcd |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 53.32±7.98d | 48.05±3.59e | 28.24±11.74abc | 16.71±3.18d |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 60.36±12.76bcd | 55.66±5.21cde | 34.35±9.54abc | 25.30±5.83abcd |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 69.64±10.41abcd | 58.77±1.58bcde | 33.57±10.87abc | 24.46±5.12abcd |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 63.92±4.56abcd | 62.98±2.09abcd | 38.13±6.15abc | 23.95±5.86abcd |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 65.20±4.69abcd | 54.79±5.21de | 28.24±10.30abc | 21.75±8.34abcd |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 65.02±11.07abcd | 61.54±0.95bcd | 30.96±5.33abc | 20.77±10.60bcd |
| WL712 | 73.80±4.18abcd | 65.47±1.34abcd | 45.60±2.26ab | 30.22±6.18abcd |
| WL656HQ | 79.00±10.59abc | 65.98±3.90abcd | 42.96±3.65abc | 34.81±3.71a |
| WL525HQ | 82.47±3.03ab | 67.91±3.56abc | 47.12±9.89a | 32.73±6.11abc |
| WL358HQ | 61.14±10.56bcd | 65.19±6.41abcd | 44.02±4.57abc | 28.38±7.49abcd |
| 惊喜Surprise | 64.63±8.23abcd | 61.40±3.94bcd | 35.04±0.68abc | 22.09±5.18abcd |
| WL298HQ | 72.87±7.27abcd | 64.96±3.12abcd | 41.94±4.17abc | 24.66±5.03abcd |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 73.11±11.38abcd | 65.57±3.22abcd | 42.04±11.11abc | 29.96±5.52abcd |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 73.86±5.61abcd | 62.30±3.93bcd | 41.77±15.03abc | 26.77±12.26abcd |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 78.30±4.85abc | 66.58±3.56abcd | 41.70±12.20abc | 30.07±6.79abcd |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 68.50±4.99abcd | 63.16±1.30abcd | 41.87±4.74abc | 27.02±7.77abcd |
| 燃力士Energizer | 86.52±5.78a | 75.19±4.06a | 45.96±4.42ab | 29.84±4.54abcd |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 70.93±4.66abcd | 68.09±3.79abc | 37.91±8.15abc | 28.37±5.50abcd |
| 威龙Weilon | 62.87±3.76bcd | 62.84±3.85abcd | 35.29±4.98abc | 23.26±7.76abcd |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 59.35±7.28bcd | 59.81±1.74bcd | 38.24±5.76abc | 27.52±3.32abcd |
| 天马Pegasis | 77.77±7.14abc | 64.67±1.97abcd | 44.66±2.99abc | 33.94±6.38ab |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 73.77±10.27abcd | 68.54±4.15ab | 45.22±0.65abc | 33.05±5.42abc |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 61.24±12.69bcd | 63.34±7.80abcd | 45.68±4.40ab | 27.91±10.30abcd |
| Bara520YQ | 70.42±10.23abcd | 66.16±4.10abcd | 39.92±10.16abc | 30.45±6.83abcd |
| Bara416WET | 70.34±9.81abcd | 63.07±2.43abcd | 42.69±4.43abc | 30.24±5.30abcd |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 71.31±12.33abcd | 67.09±6.54abcd | 39.77±4.57abc | 23.98±6.23abcd |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 60.97±3.96bcd | 60.51±2.55bcd | 40.25±2.56abc | 25.72±3.95abcd |
品种 Cultivar | 含水量Water content | 鲜干比Fresh-to-dry ratio | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 春季Spring | 夏季Ⅰ Summer Ⅰ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季Autumn | 春季Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季Autumn | ||
| Maverick | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.63±0.06a | 0.70±0.02cde | 3.66±0.60bc | 3.81±0.20abcde | 2.74±0.42bc | 3.40±0.27bcd | |
| Vernal | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.62±0.13a | - | 3.61±0.33bc | 3.94±0.44abcde | 2.82±0.94bc | - | |
| Boja | 0.70±0.03cd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.70±0.12a | 0.71±0.04cde | 3.35±0.38bc | 3.80±0.17abcde | 2.65±0.21bc | 3.48±0.49bcd | |
| Ranger | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.71±0.02d | 0.69±0.10a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.57±0.39bc | 3.52±0.27e | 3.51±1.31ab | 3.74±0.13abcd | |
| Archer | 0.72±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.05abcd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.59±0.23bc | 3.84±0.76abcde | 3.11±0.28abc | 2.77±1.53d | |
| Abi 700 | 0.72±0.01bcd | 0.72±0.01cd | 0.69±0.02a | 0.72±0.00cde | 3.52±0.18bc | 3.62±0.12cde | 3.19±0.22abc | 3.56±0.02bcd | |
| Sutter | 0.77±0.05a | 0.72±0.03cd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.72±0.01cde | 4.56±1.13a | 3.55±0.41de | 3.18±0.28abc | 3.61±0.17bcd | |
| CUF 101 | 0.72±0.05abcd | 0.71±0.04d | 0.67±0.05a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.71±0.69bc | 3.52±0.50e | 3.04±0.43abc | 3.74±0.10abcd | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.74±0.00abcd | 0.67±0.04a | 0.77±0.07abc | 3.77±0.24abc | 3.85±0.06abcde | 3.04±0.37abc | 4.75±1.88ab | |
| 皇冠Crown | 0.71±0.01bcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.66±0.05a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.45±0.17bc | 3.79±0.11abcde | 2.97±0.37abc | 3.72±0.12abcd | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.76±0.01a | 0.68±0.04a | 0.77±0.09abcde | 3.63±0.47bc | 4.21±0.18ab | 3.11±0.42abc | 5.00±2.60a | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 0.75±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.06a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.95±0.35abc | 3.73±0.13abcde | 2.90±0.50bc | 3.71±0.06abcd | |
| MF4020 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.76±0.02ab | 0.70±0.04a | 0.72±0.02cde | 3.77±0.30abc | 4.14±0.29abc | 3.40±0.46ab | 3.64±0.28bcd | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.67±0.05a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.93±0.19abc | 4.01±0.18abcde | 3.10±0.51abc | 3.73±0.06abcd | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.06a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.58±0.38bc | 4.03±0.21abcde | 3.07±0.50abc | 3.66±0.12abcd | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 0.71±0.02bcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.06a | 0.69±0.01de | 3.41±0.21bc | 3.79±0.10abcde | 3.93±0.93a | 3.25±0.14cd | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.75±0.01bcde | 3.95±0.18abc | 3.67±0.23bcde | 3.11±0.27abc | 3.97±0.23abcd | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.63±0.11a | 0.71±0.00cde | 3.80±0.42abc | 3.92±0.39abcde | 2.82±0.77bc | 3.50±0.04bcd | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.72±0.02bcd | 0.66±0.04a | 0.74±0.00bcde | 3.70±0.47bc | 3.63±0.22cde | 2.94±0.32abc | 3.84±0.06abcd | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.04a | 0.70±0.01cde | 3.70±0.21bc | 3.73±0.17abcde | 3.13±0.40abc | 3.37±0.11cd | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.70±0.02bcd | 0.75±0.02abcd | 0.71±0.03a | 0.71±0.01cde | 3.39±0.27bc | 3.98±0.38abcde | 3.45±0.36ab | 3.47±0.11bcd | |
| WL712 | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.70±0.04a | 0.73±0.02bcde | 3.91±0.28abc | 3.66±0.15bcde | 3.32±0.39abc | 3.77±0.26abcd | |
| WL656HQ | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.76±0.34abc | 3.83±0.18abcde | 3.13±0.18abc | 3.85±0.17abcd | |
| WL525HQ | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.69±0.03a | 0.74±0.00bcde | 3.62±0.35bc | 3.87±0.18abcde | 3.27±0.32abc | 3.80±0.02abcd | |
| WL358HQ | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.69±0.03a | 0.72±0.00cde | 3.64±0.20bc | 4.03±0.19abcde | 3.22±0.30abc | 3.61±0.04bcd | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.01a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.53±0.16bc | 3.82±0.09abcde | 3.01±0.11abc | 3.75±0.13abcd | |
| WL298HQ | 0.76±0.02ab | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.67±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 4.13±0.30ab | 4.07±0.10abcde | 3.07±0.19abc | 3.78±0.09abcd | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.57±0.07bc | 3.81±0.10abcde | 3.01±0.22abc | 3.78±0.13abcd | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.03a | 0.80±0.09ab | 3.76±0.38abc | 3.93±0.16abcde | 2.88±0.29bc | 3.80±0.39abcd | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.02a | 0.72±0.01cde | 3.67±0.17bc | 3.81±0.07abcde | 2.89±0.18bc | 3.52±0.16bcd | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 0.75±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.04abcd | 0.69±0.04a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.96±0.47abc | 3.89±0.5abcde | 3.25±0.42abc | 3.72±0.19abcd | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.02abc | 0.66±0.04a | 0.71±0.02cde | 3.87±0.12abc | 4.02±0.27abcde | 2.93±0.30bc | 3.51±0.28bcd | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 0.69±0.05d | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.66±0.05a | 0.69±0.04e | 3.26±0.49c | 3.90±0.24abcde | 2.99±0.38abc | 3.27±0.44cd | |
| 威龙Weilon | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.01a | 0.77±0.14abcd | 3.64±0.51bc | 3.80±0.14abcde | 3.15±0.15abc | 3.34±0.40cd | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 0.74±0.00abcd | 0.75±0.03abc | 0.71±0.03a | 0.71±0.01cde | 3.82±0.07abc | 4.10±0.43abcd | 3.44±0.36ab | 3.45±0.08bcd | |
| 天马Pegasis | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.75±0.02abc | 0.71±0.04a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.70±0.32bc | 4.05±0.25abcde | 3.48±0.43ab | 3.79±0.11abcd | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 0.75±0.05abc | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.45±0.38b | 0.82±0.09a | 4.13±0.83ab | 3.73±0.10abcde | 2.36±1.18c | 4.20±1.10abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 0.70±0.01cd | 0.73±0.04abcd | 0.67±0.06a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.32±0.16bc | 3.70±0.52abcde | 3.07±0.56abc | 3.66±0.14abcd | |
| Bara520YQ | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.05a | 0.72±0.03cde | 3.90±0.38abc | 3.88±0.11abcde | 3.05±0.41abc | 3.54±0.38bcd | |
| Bara416WET | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.69±0.01a | 0.76±0.06abcde | 3.84±0.45abc | 3.96±0.17abcde | 3.20±0.14abc | 4.27±1.10abc | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 0.75±0.04abcd | 0.76±0.01a | 0.70±0.02a | 0.72±0.02cde | 4.05±0.63abc | 4.24±0.15a | 3.31±0.25abc | 3.57±0.19bcd | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.71±0.02d | 0.67±0.03a | 0.73±0.02bcde | 3.73±0.31abc | 3.50±0.21e | 3.06±0.31abc | 3.78±0.24abcd | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0.951 | 0.327 | ||||||
| 季节Season (S) | 0.000* | 0.000* | |||||||
| 品种×季节C×S | 0.197 | 0.551 | |||||||
Table 6 Comparison of water content and fresh-to-dry ratio of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
品种 Cultivar | 含水量Water content | 鲜干比Fresh-to-dry ratio | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 春季Spring | 夏季Ⅰ Summer Ⅰ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季Autumn | 春季Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季Autumn | ||
| Maverick | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.63±0.06a | 0.70±0.02cde | 3.66±0.60bc | 3.81±0.20abcde | 2.74±0.42bc | 3.40±0.27bcd | |
| Vernal | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.62±0.13a | - | 3.61±0.33bc | 3.94±0.44abcde | 2.82±0.94bc | - | |
| Boja | 0.70±0.03cd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.70±0.12a | 0.71±0.04cde | 3.35±0.38bc | 3.80±0.17abcde | 2.65±0.21bc | 3.48±0.49bcd | |
| Ranger | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.71±0.02d | 0.69±0.10a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.57±0.39bc | 3.52±0.27e | 3.51±1.31ab | 3.74±0.13abcd | |
| Archer | 0.72±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.05abcd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.59±0.23bc | 3.84±0.76abcde | 3.11±0.28abc | 2.77±1.53d | |
| Abi 700 | 0.72±0.01bcd | 0.72±0.01cd | 0.69±0.02a | 0.72±0.00cde | 3.52±0.18bc | 3.62±0.12cde | 3.19±0.22abc | 3.56±0.02bcd | |
| Sutter | 0.77±0.05a | 0.72±0.03cd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.72±0.01cde | 4.56±1.13a | 3.55±0.41de | 3.18±0.28abc | 3.61±0.17bcd | |
| CUF 101 | 0.72±0.05abcd | 0.71±0.04d | 0.67±0.05a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.71±0.69bc | 3.52±0.50e | 3.04±0.43abc | 3.74±0.10abcd | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.74±0.00abcd | 0.67±0.04a | 0.77±0.07abc | 3.77±0.24abc | 3.85±0.06abcde | 3.04±0.37abc | 4.75±1.88ab | |
| 皇冠Crown | 0.71±0.01bcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.66±0.05a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.45±0.17bc | 3.79±0.11abcde | 2.97±0.37abc | 3.72±0.12abcd | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.76±0.01a | 0.68±0.04a | 0.77±0.09abcde | 3.63±0.47bc | 4.21±0.18ab | 3.11±0.42abc | 5.00±2.60a | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 0.75±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.06a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.95±0.35abc | 3.73±0.13abcde | 2.90±0.50bc | 3.71±0.06abcd | |
| MF4020 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.76±0.02ab | 0.70±0.04a | 0.72±0.02cde | 3.77±0.30abc | 4.14±0.29abc | 3.40±0.46ab | 3.64±0.28bcd | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.67±0.05a | 0.73±0.00bcde | 3.93±0.19abc | 4.01±0.18abcde | 3.10±0.51abc | 3.73±0.06abcd | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.06a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.58±0.38bc | 4.03±0.21abcde | 3.07±0.50abc | 3.66±0.12abcd | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 0.71±0.02bcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.06a | 0.69±0.01de | 3.41±0.21bc | 3.79±0.10abcde | 3.93±0.93a | 3.25±0.14cd | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.68±0.03a | 0.75±0.01bcde | 3.95±0.18abc | 3.67±0.23bcde | 3.11±0.27abc | 3.97±0.23abcd | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.63±0.11a | 0.71±0.00cde | 3.80±0.42abc | 3.92±0.39abcde | 2.82±0.77bc | 3.50±0.04bcd | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.72±0.02bcd | 0.66±0.04a | 0.74±0.00bcde | 3.70±0.47bc | 3.63±0.22cde | 2.94±0.32abc | 3.84±0.06abcd | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.04a | 0.70±0.01cde | 3.70±0.21bc | 3.73±0.17abcde | 3.13±0.40abc | 3.37±0.11cd | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.70±0.02bcd | 0.75±0.02abcd | 0.71±0.03a | 0.71±0.01cde | 3.39±0.27bc | 3.98±0.38abcde | 3.45±0.36ab | 3.47±0.11bcd | |
| WL712 | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.70±0.04a | 0.73±0.02bcde | 3.91±0.28abc | 3.66±0.15bcde | 3.32±0.39abc | 3.77±0.26abcd | |
| WL656HQ | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.76±0.34abc | 3.83±0.18abcde | 3.13±0.18abc | 3.85±0.17abcd | |
| WL525HQ | 0.72±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.69±0.03a | 0.74±0.00bcde | 3.62±0.35bc | 3.87±0.18abcde | 3.27±0.32abc | 3.80±0.02abcd | |
| WL358HQ | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.69±0.03a | 0.72±0.00cde | 3.64±0.20bc | 4.03±0.19abcde | 3.22±0.30abc | 3.61±0.04bcd | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.01a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.53±0.16bc | 3.82±0.09abcde | 3.01±0.11abc | 3.75±0.13abcd | |
| WL298HQ | 0.76±0.02ab | 0.75±0.01abc | 0.67±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 4.13±0.30ab | 4.07±0.10abcde | 3.07±0.19abc | 3.78±0.09abcd | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 0.72±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.02a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.57±0.07bc | 3.81±0.10abcde | 3.01±0.22abc | 3.78±0.13abcd | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 0.73±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.03a | 0.80±0.09ab | 3.76±0.38abc | 3.93±0.16abcde | 2.88±0.29bc | 3.80±0.39abcd | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.65±0.02a | 0.72±0.01cde | 3.67±0.17bc | 3.81±0.07abcde | 2.89±0.18bc | 3.52±0.16bcd | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 0.75±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.04abcd | 0.69±0.04a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.96±0.47abc | 3.89±0.5abcde | 3.25±0.42abc | 3.72±0.19abcd | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.75±0.02abc | 0.66±0.04a | 0.71±0.02cde | 3.87±0.12abc | 4.02±0.27abcde | 2.93±0.30bc | 3.51±0.28bcd | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 0.69±0.05d | 0.74±0.02abcd | 0.66±0.05a | 0.69±0.04e | 3.26±0.49c | 3.90±0.24abcde | 2.99±0.38abc | 3.27±0.44cd | |
| 威龙Weilon | 0.72±0.04abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.68±0.01a | 0.77±0.14abcd | 3.64±0.51bc | 3.80±0.14abcde | 3.15±0.15abc | 3.34±0.40cd | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 0.74±0.00abcd | 0.75±0.03abc | 0.71±0.03a | 0.71±0.01cde | 3.82±0.07abc | 4.10±0.43abcd | 3.44±0.36ab | 3.45±0.08bcd | |
| 天马Pegasis | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.75±0.02abc | 0.71±0.04a | 0.74±0.01bcde | 3.70±0.32bc | 4.05±0.25abcde | 3.48±0.43ab | 3.79±0.11abcd | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 0.75±0.05abc | 0.73±0.01abcd | 0.45±0.38b | 0.82±0.09a | 4.13±0.83ab | 3.73±0.10abcde | 2.36±1.18c | 4.20±1.10abc | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 0.70±0.01cd | 0.73±0.04abcd | 0.67±0.06a | 0.73±0.01bcde | 3.32±0.16bc | 3.70±0.52abcde | 3.07±0.56abc | 3.66±0.14abcd | |
| Bara520YQ | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.74±0.01abcd | 0.67±0.05a | 0.72±0.03cde | 3.90±0.38abc | 3.88±0.11abcde | 3.05±0.41abc | 3.54±0.38bcd | |
| Bara416WET | 0.74±0.03abcd | 0.75±0.01abcd | 0.69±0.01a | 0.76±0.06abcde | 3.84±0.45abc | 3.96±0.17abcde | 3.20±0.14abc | 4.27±1.10abc | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 0.75±0.04abcd | 0.76±0.01a | 0.70±0.02a | 0.72±0.02cde | 4.05±0.63abc | 4.24±0.15a | 3.31±0.25abc | 3.57±0.19bcd | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 0.73±0.02abcd | 0.71±0.02d | 0.67±0.03a | 0.73±0.02bcde | 3.73±0.31abc | 3.50±0.21e | 3.06±0.31abc | 3.78±0.24abcd | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0.951 | 0.327 | ||||||
| 季节Season (S) | 0.000* | 0.000* | |||||||
| 品种×季节C×S | 0.197 | 0.551 | |||||||
品种 Cultivar | 叶粗蛋白Leaf crude protein (%) | 茎粗蛋白Stem crude protein (%) | 叶茎比Leaf-stem ratio | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | 春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | 春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | ||
| Maverick | 23.09±3.26ab | 22.77±1.40b | 23.49±0.88bcdef | 20.84±3.46ab | 10.41±1.71ab | 11.40±1.15abcde | 14.12±1.23b | 0.89±0.09c | 1.08±0.06abcde | 1.72±0.47ab | 2.73±0.27bcde | |
| Vernal | 22.63±1.38ab | 21.59±1.31b | 22.42±0.81bcdef | 9.18±0.32b | 11.39±0.82abcde | 0.93±0.09bc | 0.85±0.08de | 1.47±0.57abcde | ||||
| Boja | 21.37±0.55b | 21.26±4.58b | 22.42±0.39bcdef | 20.59±0.51ab | 9.24±0.89b | 10.16±1.04de | 12.59±0.65b | 1.17±0.11abc | 0.92±0.06bcde | 1.16±0.17defg | 2.79±1.22bcde | |
| Ranger | 22.46±1.16ab | 22.63±1.44b | 22.38±0.54bcdef | 22.78±1.72ab | 9.66±0.90ab | 10.76±0.12abcde | 11.95±0.58b | 1.19±0.20abc | 0.95±0.08bcde | 0.98±0.20g | 2.19±0.43cde | |
| Archer | 23.55±0.45ab | 21.86±4.46b | 22.67±0.63bcdef | 23.28±0.69a | 9.42±0.30b | 10.54±0.91abcde | 12.24±0.72b | 1.13±0.28abc | 1.14±0.15abcd | 1.29±0.18bcdefg | 2.67±0.71bcde | |
| Abi 700 | 24.48±2.73a | 23.69±1.75ab | 23.76±2.53abcdef | 21.76±0.44ab | 9.69±0.90b | 11.44±0.39abcde | 12.54±0.23b | 1.14±0.08abc | 0.88±0.03bcde | 1.51±0.17abcde | 2.57±0.37bcde | |
| Sutter | 22.13±0.27ab | 22.68±1.31b | 22.30±1.14bcdef | 20.96±3.06ab | 9.79±0.37ab | 10.83±1.18abcde | 12.10±0.86b | 1.04±0.60abc | 0.95±0.10bcde | 1.24±0.07cdefg | 2.16±0.24cde | |
| CUF 101 | 22.18±0.45ab | 22.23±1.89b | 22.83±0.22bcdef | 22.01±1.33ab | 9.31±0.65b | 10.07±1.04e | 11.54±1.18b | 1.08±0.13abc | 0.94±0.17bcde | 1.11±0.27defg | 1.53±0.31de | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 22.26±0.52ab | 24.07±0.87ab | 24.64±1.03abc | 21.85±1.26ab | 9.77±0.17ab | 11.99±0.56a | 13.23±0.35b | 1.19±0.25abc | 0.95±0.05bcde | 1.36±0.22abcdefg | 2.41±0.42bcde | |
| 皇冠Crown | 24.21±2.07ab | 28.54±10.39a | 21.99±0.47def | 22.29±1.69ab | 11.41±0.41a | 10.82±0.59abcde | 12.05±1.41b | 1.35±0.37abc | 1.00±0.09abcde | 1.37±0.27abcdefg | 2.35±0.12bcde | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 23.17±1.50ab | 22.46±1.52b | 21.71±1.32ef | 22.30±1.10ab | 9.62±0.84ab | 10.91±1.10abcde | 11.51±0.75b | 1.11±0.10abc | 0.88±0.23bcde | 0.97±0.11g | 1.97±0.13cde | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 22.63±1.67ab | 23.92±1.45ab | 23.20±0.70bcdef | 21.36±3.69ab | 9.44±1.04b | 11.90±0.55ab | 12.82±1.09b | 1.26±0.03abc | 1.01±0.14abcde | 1.41±0.30abcdefg | 3.38±1.68abc | |
| MF4020 | 23.27±0.17ab | 23.30±1.22b | 22.66±0.76bcdef | 22.62±1.36ab | 9.69±0.22ab | 10.81±0.49abcde | 13.23±0.11b | 1.23±0.16abc | 0.98±0.03bcde | 1.32±0.23abcdefg | 2.68±0.98bcde | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 22.66±0.17ab | 23.89±1.50ab | 23.27±0.76bcdef | 20.82±2.05ab | 10.53±1.44ab | 10.93±0.44abcde | 12.70±0.43b | 1.12±0.22abc | 0.98±0.22bcde | 1.54±0.13abcd | 2.54±0.23bcde | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 23.42±0.95ab | 23.28±1.57b | 24.09±1.56abcde | 22.35±1.11ab | 10.00±1.20ab | 10.86±0.34abcde | 12.31±0.20b | 1.13±0.33abc | 1.27±0.25a | 1.54±0.07abcd | 1.39±1.24e | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 23.17±1.13ab | 22.90±1.57b | 23.44±0.42bcdef | 21.69±0.22ab | 9.62±2.15ab | 11.81±0.22abc | 12.38±1.68b | 1.50±0.27ab | 0.94±0.03bcde | 1.54±0.23abcd | 3.83±1.51ab | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 21.41±2.45b | 22.93±2.49b | 23.02±1.44bcdef | 23.30±1.12a | 9.09±0.68b | 10.60±0.60abcde | 12.28±0.41b | 1.10±0.21abc | 1.16±0.27ab | 1.67±0.18abc | 2.76±0.29bcde | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 22.59±2.59ab | 23.20±1.74b | 22.40±1.05bcdef | 22.13±0.76ab | 10.07±2.43ab | 11.29±0.35abcde | 12.17±0.53b | 0.89±0.40c | 0.87±0.09cde | 1.74±0.58ab | 2.87±0.29bcde | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 23.05±1.82ab | 23.91±2.06ab | 24.02±1.57abcde | 22.00±1.61ab | 9.44±0.66b | 10.92±0.74abcde | 12.25±0.52b | 1.15±0.31abc | 0.88±0.12bcde | 1.23±0.04cdefg | 2.62±0.11bcde | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 22.31±0.95ab | 22.31±1.69b | 24.20±1.72abcde | 22.87±1.19ab | 8.91±0.89b | 10.60±0.49abcde | 13.25±0.34b | 1.16±0.30abc | 1.16±0.05abc | 1.19±0.12defg | 2.84±0.14bcde | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 22.30±0.95ab | 22.32±2.02b | 23.46±1.86bcdef | 23.14±0.73a | 9.16±1.22b | 11.75±0.45abcd | 13.78±1.49b | 1.14±0.33abc | 1.04±0.33abcde | 1.37±0.19abcdefg | 2.87±1.03bcde | |
| WL712 | 22.83±2.29ab | 23.01±2.55b | 23.14±0.45bcdef | 22.78±0.89ab | 9.95±0.47ab | 11.05±1.10abcde | 12.91±0.29b | 1.57±0.32a | 0.92±0.15bcde | 1.41±0.08abcdefg | 2.28±0.26cde | |
| WL656HQ | 22.88±1.08ab | 22.61±1.73b | 22.31±1.57bcdef | 23.09±1.17a | 10.07±0.73ab | 10.84±0.16abcde | 11.87±0.45b | 1.33±0.44abc | 0.89±0.21bcde | 1.27±0.14bcdefg | 1.86±0.40cde | |
| WL525HQ | 22.61±0.80ab | 23.91±1.55ab | 23.38±0.65bcdef | 23.02±0.64a | 9.15±0.42b | 11.61±0.98abcde | 13.34±1.05b | 1.39±0.40abc | 0.83±0.13e | 1.15±0.18defg | 2.03±0.27cde | |
| WL358HQ | 22.86±1.52ab | 23.15±1.66b | 22.16±0.79bcdef | 22.41±0.24ab | 9.07±0.52b | 10.59±0.86abcde | 11.82±0.65b | 1.26±0.27abc | 1.05±0.16abcde | 1.53±0.42abcde | 2.35±0.32bcde | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 22.32±2.46ab | 23.38±1.55b | 22.67±0.39bcdef | 19.80±1.41b | 9.28±0.89b | 11.67±1.39abcde | 12.58±0.31b | 1.52±0.10ab | 1.00±0.10abcde | 1.78±0.54a | 2.39±0.44bcde | |
| WL298HQ | 22.61±0.79ab | 23.89±1.96ab | 22.62±0.79bcdef | 23.28±0.79a | 9.90±0.34ab | 11.48±0.60abcde | 13.23±1.35b | 1.29±0.26abc | 0.92±0.22bcde | 1.39±0.21abcdefg | 2.99±0.79abcd | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 22.52±0.15ab | 23.14±1.91b | 21.89±2.01def | 23.50±0.31a | 9.24±0.34b | 11.79±0.27abcd | 12.35±1.27b | 1.15±0.22abc | 0.95±0.15bcde | 1.36±0.18abcdefg | 2.06±0.20cde | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 23.18±0.57ab | 22.47±2.20b | 21.92±0.65def | 23.15±0.37a | 8.81±1.16b | 10.21±0.61cde | 11.79±0.21b | 1.15±0.39abc | 0.97±0.15bcde | 1.35±0.06abcdefg | 2.19±0.50cde | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 22.62±1.15ab | 24.48±4.26ab | 22.12±1.21cdef | 22.28±1.14ab | 9.28±0.70b | 11.01±0.39abcde | 12.49±0.47b | 1.23±0.44abc | 0.89±0.12bcde | 1.16±0.07defg | 1.94±0.43cde | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 23.54±1.15ab | 23.50±2.81b | 24.40±1.29abcd | 22.51±0.57ab | 9.84±0.94ab | 10.68±0.69abcde | 11.96±0.24b | 1.41±0.26abc | 0.93±0.02bcde | 1.38±0.07abcdefg | 1.67±0.35de | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 22.14±0.72ab | 22.83±1.76b | 21.22±2.53f | 22.27±0.95ab | 9.18±1.11b | 10.27±0.52bcde | 11.83±0.98b | 1.20±0.23abc | 0.84±0.08e | 1.05±0.09efg | 1.88±0.16cde | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 23.63±0.92ab | 23.99±0.71ab | 22.47±2.33bcdef | 22.35±1.01ab | 9.59±0.49ab | 10.87±0.22abcde | 12.96±0.51b | 1.08±0.30abc | 0.87±0.06bcde | 1.36±0.14abcdefg | 2.11±0.35cde | |
| 威龙Weilon | 22.71±1.72ab | 23.64±0.70ab | 24.69±0.57ab | 22.79±1.51ab | 9.17±0.41b | 11.94±0.65a | 12.97±0.19b | 1.40±0.41abc | 1.03±0.05abcde | 1.27±0.25bcdefg | 2.08±0.42abcde | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 22.90±0.88ab | 24.11±1.65ab | 24.02±0.50abcde | 21.18±2.08ab | 9.90±0.35ab | 11.02±0.29abcde | 13.52±0.51b | 1.46±0.33abc | 1.07±0.13abcde | 1.53±0.19abcde | 2.00±0.33cde | |
| 天马Pegasis | 23.95±1.59ab | 23.18±2.17b | 23.09±1.28bcdef | 23.50±0.79a | 10.40±0.98ab | 10.96±0.32abcde | 12.50±0.46b | 1.22±0.41abc | 0.90±0.12bcde | 1.08±0.12defg | 1.62±0.30de | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 22.26±2.12ab | 22.36±1.89b | 22.51±0.87bcdef | 21.20±2.04ab | 10.45±0.24ab | 11.03±1.40abcde | 12.61±0.58b | 1.25±0.21abc | 0.90±0.23bcde | 1.02±0.10fg | 1.89±0.28cde | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 23.29±0.48ab | 22.60±1.06b | 23.00±0.15bcdef | 23.21±1.34a | 9.65±0.55ab | 11.39±0.69abcde | 12.09±0.33b | 1.26±0.30abc | 0.87±0.19bcde | 1.18±0.03defg | 1.91±0.28cde | |
| Bara520YQ | 23.77±1.58ab | 23.42±1.41b | 23.87±0.38abcde | 22.98±0.47a | 10.19±0.23ab | 10.52±1.46abcde | 13.06±0.15b | 1.37±0.32abc | 1.01±0.02abcde | 1.28±0.28bcdefg | 2.58±0.49bcde | |
| Bara416WET | 22.85±1.24ab | 22.51±1.06b | 23.05±0.67bcdef | 22.96±1.48a | 10.50±0.12ab | 11.80±0.59abcd | 12.08±0.48b | 1.23±0.09abc | 1.11±0.13abcde | 1.43±0.08abcdefg | 4.02±2.75a | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 23.99±0.81ab | 22.62±2.04b | 25.96±2.88a | 22.25±0.91ab | 9.97±1.79ab | 10.96±0.67abcde | 18.98±9.53a | 1.40±0.39abc | 0.97±0.14bcde | 0.96±0.18g | 2.66±0.18bcde | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 23.07±1.96ab | 22.61±0.38b | 22.79±0.19bcdef | 23.66±0.95a | 9.77±0.45ab | 10.16±1.71de | 11.53±0.45b | 1.19±0.17abc | 1.03±0.09abcde | 1.53±0.22abcde | 2.55±0.67bcde | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0.010 | 0.007 | 0.000 | ||||||||
| 季节Season (S) | 0.396 | 0.000 | 0.000 | |||||||||
| 品种×季节C×S | 0.987 | 0.123 | 0.003 | |||||||||
Table 7 Comparison of leaf-stem ratio and crude protein content of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
品种 Cultivar | 叶粗蛋白Leaf crude protein (%) | 茎粗蛋白Stem crude protein (%) | 叶茎比Leaf-stem ratio | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | 春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | 春季 Spring | 夏季Ⅰ SummerⅠ | 夏季Ⅱ Summer Ⅱ | 秋季 Autumn | ||
| Maverick | 23.09±3.26ab | 22.77±1.40b | 23.49±0.88bcdef | 20.84±3.46ab | 10.41±1.71ab | 11.40±1.15abcde | 14.12±1.23b | 0.89±0.09c | 1.08±0.06abcde | 1.72±0.47ab | 2.73±0.27bcde | |
| Vernal | 22.63±1.38ab | 21.59±1.31b | 22.42±0.81bcdef | 9.18±0.32b | 11.39±0.82abcde | 0.93±0.09bc | 0.85±0.08de | 1.47±0.57abcde | ||||
| Boja | 21.37±0.55b | 21.26±4.58b | 22.42±0.39bcdef | 20.59±0.51ab | 9.24±0.89b | 10.16±1.04de | 12.59±0.65b | 1.17±0.11abc | 0.92±0.06bcde | 1.16±0.17defg | 2.79±1.22bcde | |
| Ranger | 22.46±1.16ab | 22.63±1.44b | 22.38±0.54bcdef | 22.78±1.72ab | 9.66±0.90ab | 10.76±0.12abcde | 11.95±0.58b | 1.19±0.20abc | 0.95±0.08bcde | 0.98±0.20g | 2.19±0.43cde | |
| Archer | 23.55±0.45ab | 21.86±4.46b | 22.67±0.63bcdef | 23.28±0.69a | 9.42±0.30b | 10.54±0.91abcde | 12.24±0.72b | 1.13±0.28abc | 1.14±0.15abcd | 1.29±0.18bcdefg | 2.67±0.71bcde | |
| Abi 700 | 24.48±2.73a | 23.69±1.75ab | 23.76±2.53abcdef | 21.76±0.44ab | 9.69±0.90b | 11.44±0.39abcde | 12.54±0.23b | 1.14±0.08abc | 0.88±0.03bcde | 1.51±0.17abcde | 2.57±0.37bcde | |
| Sutter | 22.13±0.27ab | 22.68±1.31b | 22.30±1.14bcdef | 20.96±3.06ab | 9.79±0.37ab | 10.83±1.18abcde | 12.10±0.86b | 1.04±0.60abc | 0.95±0.10bcde | 1.24±0.07cdefg | 2.16±0.24cde | |
| CUF 101 | 22.18±0.45ab | 22.23±1.89b | 22.83±0.22bcdef | 22.01±1.33ab | 9.31±0.65b | 10.07±1.04e | 11.54±1.18b | 1.08±0.13abc | 0.94±0.17bcde | 1.11±0.27defg | 1.53±0.31de | |
| 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 22.26±0.52ab | 24.07±0.87ab | 24.64±1.03abc | 21.85±1.26ab | 9.77±0.17ab | 11.99±0.56a | 13.23±0.35b | 1.19±0.25abc | 0.95±0.05bcde | 1.36±0.22abcdefg | 2.41±0.42bcde | |
| 皇冠Crown | 24.21±2.07ab | 28.54±10.39a | 21.99±0.47def | 22.29±1.69ab | 11.41±0.41a | 10.82±0.59abcde | 12.05±1.41b | 1.35±0.37abc | 1.00±0.09abcde | 1.37±0.27abcdefg | 2.35±0.12bcde | |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 23.17±1.50ab | 22.46±1.52b | 21.71±1.32ef | 22.30±1.10ab | 9.62±0.84ab | 10.91±1.10abcde | 11.51±0.75b | 1.11±0.10abc | 0.88±0.23bcde | 0.97±0.11g | 1.97±0.13cde | |
| 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 22.63±1.67ab | 23.92±1.45ab | 23.20±0.70bcdef | 21.36±3.69ab | 9.44±1.04b | 11.90±0.55ab | 12.82±1.09b | 1.26±0.03abc | 1.01±0.14abcde | 1.41±0.30abcdefg | 3.38±1.68abc | |
| MF4020 | 23.27±0.17ab | 23.30±1.22b | 22.66±0.76bcdef | 22.62±1.36ab | 9.69±0.22ab | 10.81±0.49abcde | 13.23±0.11b | 1.23±0.16abc | 0.98±0.03bcde | 1.32±0.23abcdefg | 2.68±0.98bcde | |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 22.66±0.17ab | 23.89±1.50ab | 23.27±0.76bcdef | 20.82±2.05ab | 10.53±1.44ab | 10.93±0.44abcde | 12.70±0.43b | 1.12±0.22abc | 0.98±0.22bcde | 1.54±0.13abcd | 2.54±0.23bcde | |
| 斯贝德Spade | 23.42±0.95ab | 23.28±1.57b | 24.09±1.56abcde | 22.35±1.11ab | 10.00±1.20ab | 10.86±0.34abcde | 12.31±0.20b | 1.13±0.33abc | 1.27±0.25a | 1.54±0.07abcd | 1.39±1.24e | |
| 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 23.17±1.13ab | 22.90±1.57b | 23.44±0.42bcdef | 21.69±0.22ab | 9.62±2.15ab | 11.81±0.22abc | 12.38±1.68b | 1.50±0.27ab | 0.94±0.03bcde | 1.54±0.23abcd | 3.83±1.51ab | |
| 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 21.41±2.45b | 22.93±2.49b | 23.02±1.44bcdef | 23.30±1.12a | 9.09±0.68b | 10.60±0.60abcde | 12.28±0.41b | 1.10±0.21abc | 1.16±0.27ab | 1.67±0.18abc | 2.76±0.29bcde | |
| 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 22.59±2.59ab | 23.20±1.74b | 22.40±1.05bcdef | 22.13±0.76ab | 10.07±2.43ab | 11.29±0.35abcde | 12.17±0.53b | 0.89±0.40c | 0.87±0.09cde | 1.74±0.58ab | 2.87±0.29bcde | |
| 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 23.05±1.82ab | 23.91±2.06ab | 24.02±1.57abcde | 22.00±1.61ab | 9.44±0.66b | 10.92±0.74abcde | 12.25±0.52b | 1.15±0.31abc | 0.88±0.12bcde | 1.23±0.04cdefg | 2.62±0.11bcde | |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 22.31±0.95ab | 22.31±1.69b | 24.20±1.72abcde | 22.87±1.19ab | 8.91±0.89b | 10.60±0.49abcde | 13.25±0.34b | 1.16±0.30abc | 1.16±0.05abc | 1.19±0.12defg | 2.84±0.14bcde | |
| 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 22.30±0.95ab | 22.32±2.02b | 23.46±1.86bcdef | 23.14±0.73a | 9.16±1.22b | 11.75±0.45abcd | 13.78±1.49b | 1.14±0.33abc | 1.04±0.33abcde | 1.37±0.19abcdefg | 2.87±1.03bcde | |
| WL712 | 22.83±2.29ab | 23.01±2.55b | 23.14±0.45bcdef | 22.78±0.89ab | 9.95±0.47ab | 11.05±1.10abcde | 12.91±0.29b | 1.57±0.32a | 0.92±0.15bcde | 1.41±0.08abcdefg | 2.28±0.26cde | |
| WL656HQ | 22.88±1.08ab | 22.61±1.73b | 22.31±1.57bcdef | 23.09±1.17a | 10.07±0.73ab | 10.84±0.16abcde | 11.87±0.45b | 1.33±0.44abc | 0.89±0.21bcde | 1.27±0.14bcdefg | 1.86±0.40cde | |
| WL525HQ | 22.61±0.80ab | 23.91±1.55ab | 23.38±0.65bcdef | 23.02±0.64a | 9.15±0.42b | 11.61±0.98abcde | 13.34±1.05b | 1.39±0.40abc | 0.83±0.13e | 1.15±0.18defg | 2.03±0.27cde | |
| WL358HQ | 22.86±1.52ab | 23.15±1.66b | 22.16±0.79bcdef | 22.41±0.24ab | 9.07±0.52b | 10.59±0.86abcde | 11.82±0.65b | 1.26±0.27abc | 1.05±0.16abcde | 1.53±0.42abcde | 2.35±0.32bcde | |
| 惊喜Surprise | 22.32±2.46ab | 23.38±1.55b | 22.67±0.39bcdef | 19.80±1.41b | 9.28±0.89b | 11.67±1.39abcde | 12.58±0.31b | 1.52±0.10ab | 1.00±0.10abcde | 1.78±0.54a | 2.39±0.44bcde | |
| WL298HQ | 22.61±0.79ab | 23.89±1.96ab | 22.62±0.79bcdef | 23.28±0.79a | 9.90±0.34ab | 11.48±0.60abcde | 13.23±1.35b | 1.29±0.26abc | 0.92±0.22bcde | 1.39±0.21abcdefg | 2.99±0.79abcd | |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 22.52±0.15ab | 23.14±1.91b | 21.89±2.01def | 23.50±0.31a | 9.24±0.34b | 11.79±0.27abcd | 12.35±1.27b | 1.15±0.22abc | 0.95±0.15bcde | 1.36±0.18abcdefg | 2.06±0.20cde | |
| 南苜701 Nanmu 701 | 23.18±0.57ab | 22.47±2.20b | 21.92±0.65def | 23.15±0.37a | 8.81±1.16b | 10.21±0.61cde | 11.79±0.21b | 1.15±0.39abc | 0.97±0.15bcde | 1.35±0.06abcdefg | 2.19±0.50cde | |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 22.62±1.15ab | 24.48±4.26ab | 22.12±1.21cdef | 22.28±1.14ab | 9.28±0.70b | 11.01±0.39abcde | 12.49±0.47b | 1.23±0.44abc | 0.89±0.12bcde | 1.16±0.07defg | 1.94±0.43cde | |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin+ | 23.54±1.15ab | 23.50±2.81b | 24.40±1.29abcd | 22.51±0.57ab | 9.84±0.94ab | 10.68±0.69abcde | 11.96±0.24b | 1.41±0.26abc | 0.93±0.02bcde | 1.38±0.07abcdefg | 1.67±0.35de | |
| 燃力士Energizer | 22.14±0.72ab | 22.83±1.76b | 21.22±2.53f | 22.27±0.95ab | 9.18±1.11b | 10.27±0.52bcde | 11.83±0.98b | 1.20±0.23abc | 0.84±0.08e | 1.05±0.09efg | 1.88±0.16cde | |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 23.63±0.92ab | 23.99±0.71ab | 22.47±2.33bcdef | 22.35±1.01ab | 9.59±0.49ab | 10.87±0.22abcde | 12.96±0.51b | 1.08±0.30abc | 0.87±0.06bcde | 1.36±0.14abcdefg | 2.11±0.35cde | |
| 威龙Weilon | 22.71±1.72ab | 23.64±0.70ab | 24.69±0.57ab | 22.79±1.51ab | 9.17±0.41b | 11.94±0.65a | 12.97±0.19b | 1.40±0.41abc | 1.03±0.05abcde | 1.27±0.25bcdefg | 2.08±0.42abcde | |
| 北极熊Gibraltar | 22.90±0.88ab | 24.11±1.65ab | 24.02±0.50abcde | 21.18±2.08ab | 9.90±0.35ab | 11.02±0.29abcde | 13.52±0.51b | 1.46±0.33abc | 1.07±0.13abcde | 1.53±0.19abcde | 2.00±0.33cde | |
| 天马Pegasis | 23.95±1.59ab | 23.18±2.17b | 23.09±1.28bcdef | 23.50±0.79a | 10.40±0.98ab | 10.96±0.32abcde | 12.50±0.46b | 1.22±0.41abc | 0.90±0.12bcde | 1.08±0.12defg | 1.62±0.30de | |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 22.26±2.12ab | 22.36±1.89b | 22.51±0.87bcdef | 21.20±2.04ab | 10.45±0.24ab | 11.03±1.40abcde | 12.61±0.58b | 1.25±0.21abc | 0.90±0.23bcde | 1.02±0.10fg | 1.89±0.28cde | |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 23.29±0.48ab | 22.60±1.06b | 23.00±0.15bcdef | 23.21±1.34a | 9.65±0.55ab | 11.39±0.69abcde | 12.09±0.33b | 1.26±0.30abc | 0.87±0.19bcde | 1.18±0.03defg | 1.91±0.28cde | |
| Bara520YQ | 23.77±1.58ab | 23.42±1.41b | 23.87±0.38abcde | 22.98±0.47a | 10.19±0.23ab | 10.52±1.46abcde | 13.06±0.15b | 1.37±0.32abc | 1.01±0.02abcde | 1.28±0.28bcdefg | 2.58±0.49bcde | |
| Bara416WET | 22.85±1.24ab | 22.51±1.06b | 23.05±0.67bcdef | 22.96±1.48a | 10.50±0.12ab | 11.80±0.59abcd | 12.08±0.48b | 1.23±0.09abc | 1.11±0.13abcde | 1.43±0.08abcdefg | 4.02±2.75a | |
| 苜蓿皇后Queen | 23.99±0.81ab | 22.62±2.04b | 25.96±2.88a | 22.25±0.91ab | 9.97±1.79ab | 10.96±0.67abcde | 18.98±9.53a | 1.40±0.39abc | 0.97±0.14bcde | 0.96±0.18g | 2.66±0.18bcde | |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 23.07±1.96ab | 22.61±0.38b | 22.79±0.19bcdef | 23.66±0.95a | 9.77±0.45ab | 10.16±1.71de | 11.53±0.45b | 1.19±0.17abc | 1.03±0.09abcde | 1.53±0.22abcde | 2.55±0.67bcde | |
| P | 品种Cultivar (C) | 0.010 | 0.007 | 0.000 | ||||||||
| 季节Season (S) | 0.396 | 0.000 | 0.000 | |||||||||
| 品种×季节C×S | 0.987 | 0.123 | 0.003 | |||||||||
性状 Character | 指标 Indicators | 第1茬First cutting | 第2茬Second cutting | 第3茬Third cutting | 第4茬Fourth cutting | 第5茬Fifth cutting | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | ||
农艺 Agronomic | FGY (kg·m-2) | 3.43 | 0.49 | 14.27 | 1.75 | 0.35 | 20.04 | 1.17 | 0.29 | 24.80 | 0.28 | 0.12 | 43.19 | 0.22 | 0.12 | 24.84 |
| FDR (%) | 3.72 | 0.23 | 6.18 | - | - | - | 3.85 | 0.17 | 4.42 | 3.10 | 0.27 | 8.70 | 3.70 | 0.37 | 10.01 | |
| LSR (%) | 1.22 | 0.29 | 23.76 | - | - | - | 0.97 | 0.15 | 15.45 | 1.34 | 0.28 | 20.94 | 2.44 | 0.80 | 32.79 | |
| PHAM (cm) | 69.49 | 9.99 | 14.38 | 63.16 | 6.32 | 10.01 | 38.41 | 8.45 | 22.00 | 26.58 | 6.75 | 25.04 | 13.13 | 6.27 | 47.76 | |
品质 Quality | LCP (%) | 22.88 | 1.38 | 6.03 | - | - | - | 23.17 | 2.37 | 10.23 | 23.04 | 1.39 | 6.03 | 22.30 | 1.50 | 6.73 |
| SCP (%) | 9.68 | 0.93 | 9.61 | - | - | - | - | - | - | 11.04 | 0.84 | 7.61 | 12.64 | 1.79 | 14.16 | |
Table 8 Coefficient of variation of traits of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
性状 Character | 指标 Indicators | 第1茬First cutting | 第2茬Second cutting | 第3茬Third cutting | 第4茬Fourth cutting | 第5茬Fifth cutting | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | M | SD | CV(%) | ||
农艺 Agronomic | FGY (kg·m-2) | 3.43 | 0.49 | 14.27 | 1.75 | 0.35 | 20.04 | 1.17 | 0.29 | 24.80 | 0.28 | 0.12 | 43.19 | 0.22 | 0.12 | 24.84 |
| FDR (%) | 3.72 | 0.23 | 6.18 | - | - | - | 3.85 | 0.17 | 4.42 | 3.10 | 0.27 | 8.70 | 3.70 | 0.37 | 10.01 | |
| LSR (%) | 1.22 | 0.29 | 23.76 | - | - | - | 0.97 | 0.15 | 15.45 | 1.34 | 0.28 | 20.94 | 2.44 | 0.80 | 32.79 | |
| PHAM (cm) | 69.49 | 9.99 | 14.38 | 63.16 | 6.32 | 10.01 | 38.41 | 8.45 | 22.00 | 26.58 | 6.75 | 25.04 | 13.13 | 6.27 | 47.76 | |
品质 Quality | LCP (%) | 22.88 | 1.38 | 6.03 | - | - | - | 23.17 | 2.37 | 10.23 | 23.04 | 1.39 | 6.03 | 22.30 | 1.50 | 6.73 |
| SCP (%) | 9.68 | 0.93 | 9.61 | - | - | - | - | - | - | 11.04 | 0.84 | 7.61 | 12.64 | 1.79 | 14.16 | |
| 品种Cultivar | WCD | SRPR | R | FD | 品种Cultivar | WCD | SRPR | R | FD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WL525HQ | 0.7382 | 0.569 | 1 | 8 | Sutter | 0.5957 | 0.704 | 22 | 7 |
| CUF 101 | 0.7124 | 0.639 | 2 | 9 | 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 0.5925 | 0.773 | 23 | 1.2~1.6 |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 0.7051 | 0.631 | 3 | 3 | 惊喜Surprise | 0.5893 | 0.829 | 24 | 4 |
| WL656HQ | 0.6989 | 0.717 | 4 | 9.3 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.5861 | 0.792 | 25 | 3 |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 0.6867 | 0.664 | 5 | 8 | Bara416WET | 0.5829 | 0.769 | 26 | 4 |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 0.6813 | 0.707 | 6 | 10 | 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 0.5797 | 0.792 | 27 | 6 |
| 天马Pegasis | 0.6684 | 0.745 | 7 | 9 | 北极熊Gibraltar | 0.5765 | 0.848 | 28 | 2 |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 0.6652 | 0.744 | 8 | 8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.5733 | 0.751 | 29 | 3~4 |
| 燃力士Energizer | 0.6553 | 0.798 | 9 | 6 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.5701 | 0.829 | 30 | 3~4 |
| WL358HQ | 0.6421 | 0.776 | 10 | 4.1 | 苜蓿皇后Queen | 0.5669 | 0.789 | 31 | 2 |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 0.6389 | 0.784 | 11 | 4.3 | MF4020 | 0.5637 | 0.770 | 32 | 4 |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin | 0.6327 | 0.732 | 12 | 4 | Vernal | 0.5605 | 0.690 | 33 | 2 |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 0.6295 | 0.766 | 13 | 8 | 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 0.5573 | 0.738 | 34 | 9+ |
| Archer | 0.6253 | 0.734 | 14 | 5 | Abi 700 | 0.5541 | 0.855 | 35 | 6 |
| 南苜701 Nan Mu 701 | 0.6181 | 0.816 | 15 | 7 | WL712 | 0.5509 | 0.688 | 36 | 10.2 |
| Bara520YQ | 0.6149 | 0.730 | 16 | 5 | 斯贝德Spade | 0.5477 | 0.922 | 37 | 1 |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 0.6117 | 0.732 | 17 | 5 | Boja | 0.5445 | 0.778 | 38 | 3 |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.6085 | 0.898 | 18 | 7 | 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 0.5413 | 0.889 | 39 | 1 |
| 皇冠Crown | 0.6053 | 0.777 | 19 | 2~3 | Ranger | 0.5381 | 0.882 | 40 | 3 |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 0.6021 | 0.792 | 20 | 3.5 | Maverick | 0.5317 | 0.887 | 41 | 1 |
| 威龙Weilon | 0.5989 | 0.791 | 21 | 3 | WL298HQ | 0.5317 | 0.752 | 42 | 3.2 |
Table 9 Gray correlation degree of 42 alfalfa cultivars in the test
| 品种Cultivar | WCD | SRPR | R | FD | 品种Cultivar | WCD | SRPR | R | FD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WL525HQ | 0.7382 | 0.569 | 1 | 8 | Sutter | 0.5957 | 0.704 | 22 | 7 |
| CUF 101 | 0.7124 | 0.639 | 2 | 9 | 龙牧806 Longmu 806 | 0.5925 | 0.773 | 23 | 1.2~1.6 |
| 淮扬4号Huaiyang No.4 | 0.7051 | 0.631 | 3 | 3 | 惊喜Surprise | 0.5893 | 0.829 | 24 | 4 |
| WL656HQ | 0.6989 | 0.717 | 4 | 9.3 | 公农5号Gongnong No.5 | 0.5861 | 0.792 | 25 | 3 |
| 巨能801 Magnum No.801 | 0.6867 | 0.664 | 5 | 8 | Bara416WET | 0.5829 | 0.769 | 26 | 4 |
| 赛迪10 Sardi 10 | 0.6813 | 0.707 | 6 | 10 | 巨能601 Magnum No.601 | 0.5797 | 0.792 | 27 | 6 |
| 天马Pegasis | 0.6684 | 0.745 | 7 | 9 | 北极熊Gibraltar | 0.5765 | 0.848 | 28 | 2 |
| 游客+Eureka+ | 0.6652 | 0.744 | 8 | 8 | 中苜1号Zhongmu No.1 | 0.5733 | 0.751 | 29 | 3~4 |
| 燃力士Energizer | 0.6553 | 0.798 | 9 | 6 | 甘农3号Gannong No.3 | 0.5701 | 0.829 | 30 | 3~4 |
| WL358HQ | 0.6421 | 0.776 | 10 | 4.1 | 苜蓿皇后Queen | 0.5669 | 0.789 | 31 | 2 |
| 大银河Galaxie Max | 0.6389 | 0.784 | 11 | 4.3 | MF4020 | 0.5637 | 0.770 | 32 | 4 |
| 阿迪娜+Adrenalin | 0.6327 | 0.732 | 12 | 4 | Vernal | 0.5605 | 0.690 | 33 | 2 |
| 艾薇雅Aivia | 0.6295 | 0.766 | 13 | 8 | 巨能995 Magnum No.995 | 0.5573 | 0.738 | 34 | 9+ |
| Archer | 0.6253 | 0.734 | 14 | 5 | Abi 700 | 0.5541 | 0.855 | 35 | 6 |
| 南苜701 Nan Mu 701 | 0.6181 | 0.816 | 15 | 7 | WL712 | 0.5509 | 0.688 | 36 | 10.2 |
| Bara520YQ | 0.6149 | 0.730 | 16 | 5 | 斯贝德Spade | 0.5477 | 0.922 | 37 | 1 |
| 赛沃5 Saivo 5 | 0.6117 | 0.732 | 17 | 5 | Boja | 0.5445 | 0.778 | 38 | 3 |
| 甘农9号Gannong No.9 | 0.6085 | 0.898 | 18 | 7 | 草原3号Caoyuan No.3 | 0.5413 | 0.889 | 39 | 1 |
| 皇冠Crown | 0.6053 | 0.777 | 19 | 2~3 | Ranger | 0.5381 | 0.882 | 40 | 3 |
| 沃苜1号Womu No.1 | 0.6021 | 0.792 | 20 | 3.5 | Maverick | 0.5317 | 0.887 | 41 | 1 |
| 威龙Weilon | 0.5989 | 0.791 | 21 | 3 | WL298HQ | 0.5317 | 0.752 | 42 | 3.2 |
| [1] | Tucker J J, Mullenix M K, Rios E, et al. Systems management strategies for increasing alfalfa use in warm-humid regions. Grassland Research, 2024, 3(2): 187-198. |
| [2] | Ta H T, Teixeira E I, Brown H E, et al. Yield and quality changes in lucerne of different fall dormancy ratings under three defoliation regimes. European Journal of Agronomy, 2020, 115: 126012. |
| [3] | Feng Y P, Shi Y, Zhao M Y, et al. Yield and quality properties of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and their influencing factors in China. European Journal of Agronomy, 2022, 141: 126637. |
| [4] | Li Y Z, Li X R, Zhang J, et al. Physiological and proteomic responses of contrasting alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) varieties to high temperature stress. Frontiers in Plant Science, 2021, 12: 753011. |
| [5] | Tong C C, Liu X J, Yun X K, et al. Correlation between the cold resistance of alfalfa varieties and their fall dormancy. Grassland and Turf, 2020, 40(6): 84-88, 94. |
| 童长春, 刘晓静, 运向凯, 等. 苜蓿品种抗寒性与秋眠级的相关性研究. 草原与草坪, 2020, 40(6): 84-88, 94. | |
| [6] | Zhao J T, Yue Y F, Zhang Q B, et al. Relationship between cold resistance of alfalfa, degree of fall-dormancy and snow cover thickness in Northern Xinjiang. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2022, 31(8): 24-34. |
| 赵建涛, 岳亚飞, 张前兵, 等. 不同秋眠级紫花苜蓿品种抗寒性对新疆北疆地区覆雪厚度的响应. 草业学报, 2022, 31(8): 24-34. | |
| [7] | Liu Z Y, Li X L, Li F, et al. Mechanisms underlying the effects of fall dormancy on the cold acclimation and winter hard-iness of Medicago sativa. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 2015, 39(6): 635-648. |
| 刘志英, 李西良, 李峰, 等. 紫花苜蓿秋眠型对低温驯化过程与越冬耐寒适应的作用机理. 植物生态学报, 2015, 39(6): 635-648. | |
| [8] | Han R H, Gao G J. Evaluation on heat-resistance of varieties of purple-flower alfalfa with fall dormancy classes at seedling stage. Animal Husbandry and Feed Science, 2009, 30(6): 158-159, 180. |
| 韩瑞宏, 高桂娟. 秋眠级不同的紫花苜蓿苗期耐热性评价. 畜牧与饲料科学, 2009, 30(6): 158-159, 180. | |
| [9] | Zhao Y, Bi Y F, Wang H, et al. The relationship between heat-tolerance and fall dormancy of Medicago sativa cultivars at seed germination stage. Grassland and Turf, 2012, 32(6): 11-16. |
| 赵雁, 毕玉芬, 王荟, 等. 种子萌发期紫花苜蓿秋眠级与耐热性的关系. 草原与草坪, 2012, 32(6): 11-16. | |
| [10] | Zhang X X. The identification and mechanism of heat resistance on different rank of fall-dormancy alfalfas in summer. Zhengzhou: Henan Agricultural University, 2010. |
| 张晓霞. 不同秋眠级紫花苜蓿越夏期抗热性鉴定及其机理研究. 郑州: 河南农业大学, 2010. | |
| [11] | Wang M, Li L, Jia R, et al. Evaluation of physiological characteristics and cold resistance of 10 alfalfa varieties under low temperature stress. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2024, 33(6): 76-88. |
| 王敏, 李莉, 贾蓉, 等. 10种紫花苜蓿在低温胁迫下的生理特性及耐寒性评价. 草业学报, 2024, 33(6): 76-88. | |
| [12] | Li L B, Aibibula·Yimamu, Halimulai·Nrehemaiti, et al. Comparative analysis of growth and production performance among alfalfa varieties with different fall dormancy classes in the agricultural region of northern Tianshan Mountains. Feed Research, 2024, 47(21): 130-137. |
| 李陆斌, 艾比布拉·伊马木, 哈里木拉提·努热合买提, 等. 不同秋眠级苜蓿品种在天山北坡农业区的生长与生产性能比较. 饲料研究, 2024, 47(21): 130-137. | |
| [13] | Qi J J, Fu D Q, Wang X Z, et al. Comparison of production performance and nutritional quality of alfalfa with different autumn dormancy levels in Shihezi area. Feed Research, 2023, 46(14): 125-130. |
| 齐江姣, 付东青, 王旭哲, 等. 石河子地区不同秋眠级紫花苜蓿生产性能和营养品质比较. 饲料研究, 2023, 46(14): 125-130. | |
| [14] | Sun Y L, Liu X S, Li S Y, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of production performance with different fall dormancy rates of alfalfa in Shihezi, Xinjiang. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2022, 30(5): 1227-1236. |
| 孙延亮, 刘选帅, 李生仪, 等. 新疆石河子地区不同秋眠级紫花苜蓿生产性能的综合评价. 草地学报, 2022, 30(5): 1227-1236. | |
| [15] | Li J H, Zhu X Q, Yu C Q, et al. Study on adaptability of different fall-dormancy grade alfalfa varieties in high altitude valley agricultural area of Tibet. China Herbivore Science, 2023, 43(3): 27-31, 36. |
| 李锦华, 朱新强, 余成群, 等. 西藏高海拔河谷农区不同秋眠型苜蓿品种适应性研究. 中国草食动物科学, 2023, 43(3): 27-31, 36. | |
| [16] | Wang X L, Li H, Mi F G, et al. Comparison of production performance and winter survival rate of different fall dormancy alfalfa varieties. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2019, 28(6): 82-92. |
| 王晓龙, 李红, 米福贵, 等. 不同秋眠级苜蓿生产性能及越冬率评价. 草业学报, 2019, 28(6): 82-92. | |
| [17] | Zhao H M, You Y L, Li Y, et al. Adaptability evaluation of different fall dormant alfalfa varieties in the Haihe Plain. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2020, 42(1): 48-57. |
| 赵海明, 游永亮, 李源, 等. 不同秋眠级苜蓿品种在海河平原区的适应性评价. 中国草地学报, 2020, 42(1): 48-57. | |
| [18] | Lu X S, Yun X J, Wang T M, et al. Rules for alfalfa fall dormancy rate evaluation: GB/T 37069-2018. Beijing: China Standards Press, 2018. |
| 卢欣石, 贠旭江, 王铁梅, 等. 苜蓿秋眠性分级评定: GB/T 37069-2018. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2018. | |
| [19] | Yun X J, Yuan Q H, Su J K, et al. Code of practice for herbage variety registration: GB/T 30395-2013. Beijing: China Standards Press, 2014. |
| 贠旭疆, 袁庆华, 苏加楷, 等. 草品种审定技术规程: GB/T 30395-2013. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2014. | |
| [20] | National Market Supervision and Administration Bureau, National Standardization Administration CommitteeAnimal feed—Preparation of test samples: GB/T 20195-2024. Beijing: China Standards Press, 2024. |
| 国家市场监督管理总局,国家标准化管理员会. 动物饲料 试样的制备: GB/T 20195-2024.北京: 中国标准出版社, 2024. | |
| [21] | Liu Y K, Wang J W, Wang J, et al. Comparison and analysis of production performance and nutritional value of 13 alfalfa varieties in the Cangzhou saline-alkali area. Pratacultural Science, 2023, 40(7): 1823-1832. |
| 刘艳昆, 王佳文, 王静, 等. 13个紫花苜蓿品种在沧州盐碱地的生产性能和营养价值. 草业科学, 2023, 40(7): 1823-1832. | |
| [22] | Gao Y M, Yu J, Sarina, et al. Climate suitability evaluation of 16 alfalfa varieties in Tongliao area. Animal Husbandry and Feed Science, 2021, 42(1): 91-97. |
| 高亚敏, 于静, 萨日娜, 等. 16个紫花苜蓿品种在通辽地区气候适宜性试验研究. 畜牧与饲料科学, 2021, 42(1): 91-97. | |
| [23] | Li Y, Xu Z M, Li Z Y, et al. Introduction of American alfalfa materials with different fall dormancy in Anhui Province. Grassland and Turf, 2021, 41(3): 125-129, 136. |
| 李岩, 徐智明, 李争艳, 等. 不同秋眠级美国紫花苜蓿材料在安徽地区的引种试验. 草原与草坪, 2021, 41(3): 125-129, 136. | |
| [24] | Zheng M N, Liang X Z, Han Z S, et al. Productivity and nutritional value of 28 alfalfa varieties in the Yanmenguan area of Shanxi Province. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2018, 27(5): 97-108. |
| 郑敏娜, 梁秀芝, 韩志顺, 等. 不同苜蓿品种在雁门关地区的生产性能和营养价值研究. 草业学报, 2018, 27(5): 97-108. | |
| [25] | Lv H G, Kang J M, Long R C, et al. Yield evaluation of 22 alfalfa cultivars in Hebei area. Acta Agrestia Sinica, 2018, 26(4): 948-958. |
| 吕会刚, 康俊梅, 龙瑞才, 等. 河北地区22个紫花苜蓿品种的生产性能比较研究. 草地学报, 2018, 26(4): 948-958. | |
| [26] | Cao H, Geng Z G, Li Q, et al. Adaptability of 11 alfalfa varieties in southern Qingyang. Pratacultural Science, 2018, 35(8): 1937-1947. |
| 曹宏, 耿智广, 李茜, 等. 11个紫花苜蓿品种在庆阳南部的适应性. 草业科学, 2018, 35(8): 1937-1947. | |
| [27] | Monirifar H, Roudsari A M, Ghassemi S, et al. Harvest time and cultivar effects on growth, physiological traits, yield and quality of alfalfa in saline condition. International Journal of Plant Production, 2020, 14(3): 453-462. |
| [28] | Shen Y H, Li X L, Liu J H, et al. Comparative study on production performance and nutritional value of 21 alfalfa varieties. Journal of Shenyang Agricultural University, 2025, 56(4): 33-43. |
| 申玉华, 李晓兰, 刘敬红, 等. 21个紫花苜蓿品种的生产性能和营养价值比较研究. 沈阳农业大学学报, 2025, 56(4): 33-43. | |
| [29] | Lü X D, Wang J G, Bai Y C. Comprehensive evaluation on nutrition value of 11 introduced alfalfa varieties in Inner Mongolia. Grassland and Turf, 2013, 33(3): 21-25, 30. |
| 吕小东, 王建光, 白音仓. 内蒙古引进的11个国外苜蓿品种营养价值的灰色评价. 草原与草坪, 2013, 33(3): 21-25, 30. | |
| [30] | Tang K T, Zhang F F, Wang X Z, et al. Study on the hay yield and nutrition of ten alfalfa varieties in different fall dormancy classes in Northern Xinjiang. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 2018, 40(3): 43-48. |
| 唐开婷, 张凡凡, 王旭哲, 等. 北疆10个不同秋眠级紫花苜蓿引进品种产量与营养品质研究. 中国草地学报, 2018, 40(3): 43-48. |
| [1] | Jin-hui YANG, Xiao-tong WANG, Yong-long MA, Dong-wen YU, Yu-hua TONG, Shu-xia LI. Effect of CeO2 NPs on the salt tolerance of alfalfa seedlings [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(8): 45-54. |
| [2] | Zhao-peng HUANG, Rong HE, Li-li NAN, Jia-le LIU, Wen-ke YANG. Effects of exogenous melatonin on endogenous hormones and organic acids in alfalfa seedlings under low-phosphorus stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(8): 55-64. |
| [3] | Fen-qi CHEN, Jin-qing ZHANG, Yi-jian YU, Zhen-yu LI. Identification, bioinformatics analysis of AP2 subfamily genes and MsBBM gene cloning in alfalfa [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(7): 117-134. |
| [4] | Hao-zhen LIU, Jia-lu CHAO, Shi-qin ZHAO, Cheng WANG, Jing-hong ZHANG, Shou-jiang SUN. Genome-wide identification of BBR-BPC genes in Medicago sativa and their transcript profiles in response to seed aging [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(7): 135-150. |
| [5] | Wu LI, Jia-jing LI, Jie-bing LI, Zhen-zhou LI, Ming GUO, Yan NIU, Hao SUN, De-feng LI, Ying-hua SHI, Zhen-tian LI, Bo-shuai LIU, Ya-lei CUI, Zhi-chang WANG, Yong-tao LI, Xiao-yan ZHU. Optimization of fermentation and ultrasound-assisted extraction parameters for alfalfa saponins [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(7): 201-216. |
| [6] | Jiang-ping MA, Li-juan CAO, Wen-wen ZHANG, Meng-yu ZHAO, Teng-fei WANG, Yi-yin ZHANG, Bin WANG, Jia-wang LI, Xiao-bing WANG, Jian LAN. Effects of reseeding and phosphorus application on productivity and soil in improvement of degraded alfalfa stands [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(7): 92-104. |
| [7] | Jiang-bo XU, Chang-wei MEI, Dong CHEN, Run-yao JIANG, Song-chang GUO, Xiu-hong WU, Ju-ying LUO, Hai-yuan HUANG, Fang LIU. The effect of alfalfa meal on the average daily gain, slaughter performance, meat quality, and serum biochemical indicators of two different hybrid lines of Liangsan pigs [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(6): 202-215. |
| [8] | Meng-yu REN, Li-qun WANG, Li-li NAN, Jia-yu GUO. Responses of new alfalfa lines to salt stress [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(6): 24-34. |
| [9] | Yu-lin NIU, Ming-fang BAO, Wen-hu WANG, Xin CHEN, Kai-qiang LIU, Wen-hui LIU, Yan QIN. A multivariate evaluation of agronomic traits, yield and seed production in ten accessions of Bromus inermis from the Three-River-Source Region [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(6): 83-92. |
| [10] | Xiao-cong LI, Ju-hui YAN, Xing WANG, Peng-fei HU, Yu-nong YE, Bing-zhe FU. Effects of different inter-row planting ratios of alfalfa and smooth brome on grass production performance and soil physicochemical properties [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(5): 113-125. |
| [11] | Wen-hui DENG, Xiao-na ZHAO, Jia-yi YONG, Si-yu GUAN, Guo-qiang HU, Teng-fei WANG, Hai-ying HU. Effects of intercropping oat with different densities on alfalfa seed yield and its constituent factors [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(4): 100-111. |
| [12] | Ping MA, Zhi-guo LIU, Yu-shu SHA, Ya-ling LIU, Xiao-mei TUO, Bing-zhe FU, Xue-qing GAO. Nitrogen utilization characteristics of alfalfa at the seedling stage and screening of nitrogen-efficient varieties [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(4): 112-123. |
| [13] | Tian ZHANG, Hua-juan LENG, Jing CUI, Fei HE, Xue WANG, Ming-na LI, Qing-chuan YANG, Jun-mei KANG. Identification of synaptotagmin gene family members in alfalfa and their transcript profiles under abiotic stresses [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(4): 158-168. |
| [14] | Yi-bo WANG, Xue-hua MING, Jian-yong ZHANG, Qi YUAN, Jian-ming DU, Bin WANG, Teng-fei WANG, Yi-yin ZHANG, Jian LAN, Le MU. Multi-trait evaluation of the production performance and seed yield of new oat germplasm materials in the arid area of Ningxia [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(4): 86-99. |
| [15] | Hao-bin JIA, Hao-yun JIANG, Ai-hua LI, Hai-bo WANG, Sun-quan LIN, Yue PAN, Jun-hong HUO, Jin-shun ZHAN. Effects of diets with different concentrate-to-roughage ratios on the growth rate, serum biochemical indexes, and rumen fermentation of Guangfeng goats [J]. Acta Prataculturae Sinica, 2026, 35(3): 170-184. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||